NEWBIE 1858: MEDICAL MAFIA (fin)

[ejjinami]

Let's lynch the IC

schad said that might be his town behavior, why are you confident he's scum?

"might"
I don't feel any real scum hunting from him so I'm good lynching him. I'm fine lynching not_mafia too.

What do you think about the other players?

[Draynth]

I'm answering now but why

exactly

do you think I'm scum

[Draynth]

Shat and Draynth are town

Why do you think myself and Shat are town?

can you write what do you think about shadd?

I'm not sure what I think right now

On the one hand the way he tiptoed around calling people scum is suspicious to me, his follow up post reacting to my point is along the same vein so It could just be a playstyle thing.
I'll ISO schadd now and get some more in depth thoughts

Can you write what did you mean by “paranoid” in your previous post?

I wasn't sure if it was something I should legitimately be considering or not

Spoiler:

Just realised I find the wording of this readslist kinda strange

If myself, rei and soul are all being suspected why are we listed as 'more not as town' rather than 'slightly scummy' or whatever else

It's as if schadd doesn't want to step on any toes by calling people out as scum.

Am I being too paranoid here?

If shadd was null for you and you had no reasons to think of him as town, why say you're paranoid? Even if you were thinking about "your argument being a weak one", that was a rather weird choice of words imo. That sounds kinda simmilar to the reason you “scumread” schadd for. lol

I never said schadd was a null read
I think there's a big difference between what schadd did (appeared to not want to call people out as scum) and not wanting to overanalyze something. Does that make sense?

I've always been a lurker until I feel I'm engaged in the game, it's just the way I end up playing most of the time.

It's also possible that my playstyle has changed, I haven't played a game in ~6 months after all (The last game that I played

that I didn't replace out of

can be found here)

I wasn’t talking just about lurking :/ I was talking about the “rereading the thread” after showing up. I didn’t see you doing that anywhere, you barely even quoted anything, so I really doubt I could have missed it. Did you do that before?

Just because I didn't quote many posts doesn't mean I didn't read it. In fact you have no way of knowing if I actually read the thread or not, you kinda have to just take my word for it. It's not AI either way

Do you feel your playstyle changed? If so, can you write what feels different?

Perhaps, I think I'm a smarter player as I've played more games.
When I first started I tended to make big posts and try to make points with tons of evidence, and as a result I was forcing evidence to suit theories, rather than the other way around. (The point I was trying to make wasn't always the point that was coming across if that makes sense)
I try to post less now in order to make sure that I keep my thoughts clear, If I don't do that I confuse myself most of the time

Will post schadd stuff later

To everyone, who would you be ok with lynching today. We don't have a whole lot of time left and nolynching should generally be avoided d1

my answer is in my today's 2'nd post.
and who do you want to lynch? I don't remember you saying much about that

No idea as of right now, I really don't have any reads strong enough to vote upon. I haven't ISO'd schadd yet so perhaps he'll be added to that list, I don't know

[soulshade55r]

Let's lynch the IC

Eh if IC is scum we are much obliged to hang them
Ejjinami seems to know what they are doing right now and there are some smart enough players to hold the game

[WhemeStar]

ON TOP OF PAGE 6 IM DONE FOR NOW

Shat and Draynth are town
Ejji and Rei are scumreads
Rest are null or don’t matter

can you elaborate? what makes I and rei scum? what makes shat and dray town?

Uh if I remember correctly one post you defended but didn’t defend rei and that makes me think either your buddying Rei or your scum with Rei

[WhemeStar]

I was so proud someone else scumread ejji and the you think this post is town out of everything?

What did you mean by: "out of everything"?

and I'm geting townvibes from that post. :/ even though he's basically scumreading me. lol

Out of everything as in u have a lot of posts and that post wasn’t towny

[ejjinami]

I'm answering now but why

exactly

do you think I'm scum

yeah, in a moment.

[ejjinami]

I never said schadd was a null read
I think there's a big difference between what schadd did (appeared to not want to call people out as scum) and not wanting to overanalyze something. Does that make sense?

From the previous post I got you weren't really townreading him. :/ I got the feeling you thought his "reads" were the only thing worth reading. Can you say what did you think of him then?

[ejjinami]

I've always been a lurker until I feel I'm engaged in the game, it's just the way I end up playing most of the time.

It's also possible that my playstyle has changed, I haven't played a game in ~6 months after all (The last game that I played

that I didn't replace out of

can be found here)

I wasn’t talking just about lurking :/ I was talking about the “rereading the thread” after showing up. I didn’t see you doing that anywhere, you barely even quoted anything, so I really doubt I could have missed it. Did you do that before?

Just because I didn't quote many posts doesn't mean I didn't read it. In fact you have no way of knowing if I actually read the thread or not, you kinda have to just take my word for it. It's not AI either way

Ok…… :/ you’re either pretending not to see the point, or really thinking you did nothing wrong.

As far as I get it, town lurking would be:
lurk --> pop up when sth pings you --> reread the thread (if you feel like it) to react to the less important stuff you didn’t bother to write about previously

And I started doubting if you’re town after 181 and 182.
If you felt shat’s locktown post was kinda scummy, it feels unnatural you’d wait with writing about it.
You being scum would fit there pretty well. Scum!you (obviously) couldn’t think shatt’s post was important or would make her scum, so you didn’t bother to pop in, but you reacted to it later cause you wanted to pretend to be doing sth/actively looking for scum.
Same with the reaction to esp’s and schadd’s posts. Town!you would need to seriously not be into the game to do that imo.
Can you comment on that?

[ejjinami]

And sorry, I’m seriously dumb. There was almost no meme phase this game so it’s obvious dray would feel more carefree in the rest of his games, especially since he replaced out in quite a few of them. ;-; Forget about that argument, it was plain stupid.

[ejjinami]

Let's lynch the IC

Eh if IC is scum we are much obliged to hang them
Ejjinami seems to know what they are doing right now and there are some smart enough players to hold the game

Does that mean you want to lynch esp?
and why would the: "I know what I'm doing" make you feel lynching esp is good? Like, I was pretty much saying not to lynch him, so if you felt I'm town and I'm onto sth, why talk about voting esp, not dray?

[ejjinami]

ON TOP OF PAGE 6 IM DONE FOR NOW

Shat and Draynth are town
Ejji and Rei are scumreads
Rest are null or don’t matter

can you elaborate? what makes I and rei scum? what makes shat and dray town?

Uh if I remember correctly one post you defended but didn’t defend rei and that makes me think either your buddying Rei or your scum with Rei

seriously, that one post? -_-
I understood rei's post as "friendly, uncorrelated with being paranoid", but 2cre said it's scummy cause it's "unfriendly when paranoid". It would really be scummy if it was like that so I asked about it. There isn't much to read into there.

and what about shat and dray, why are they town?

[Draynth]

I'm answering now but why

exactly

do you think I'm scum

yeah, in a moment.

Why won't you say now?
You've voted me and said that I'm one of two people you'll lynch today. It's seriously unhelpful that you're A) not telling the town why you think I'm scum and B) Not giving me a chance to defend myself

[Draynth]

Ok…… :/ you’re either pretending not to see the point, or really thinking you did nothing wrong.

As far as I get it, town lurking would be:
lurk --> pop up when sth pings you --> reread the thread (if you feel like it) to react to the less important stuff you didn’t bother to write about previously

And I started doubting if you’re town after 181 and 182.
If you felt shat’s locktown post was kinda scummy, it feels unnatural you’d wait with writing about it.
You being scum would fit there pretty well. Scum!you (obviously) couldn’t think shatt’s post was important or would make her scum, so you didn’t bother to pop in, but you reacted to it later cause you wanted to pretend to be doing sth/actively looking for scum.
Same with the reaction to esp’s and schadd’s posts. Town!you would need to seriously not be into the game to do that imo.
Can you comment on that?

How is actively lurking a good idea for scum here, can you please think through what you're saying.
You're basing this off how you *think* town

should

play, even if it contradicts what scum are trying to do.

[Draynth]

Also, you're basing a lot of points on the fact that you think I said that I reread the thread multiple times.
Nowhere did I say that.
That's about 2/3 instances now where you've claimed that I said something I haven't.

[Draynth]

3 days until deadline

[ejjinami]

I'm answering now but why

exactly

do you think I'm scum

yeah, in a moment.

Why won't you say now?
You've voted me and said that I'm one of two people you'll lynch today. It's seriously unhelpful that you're A) not telling the town why you think I'm scum and B) Not giving me a chance to defend myself

it takes some time to write things. -_- lol

[ejjinami]

How is actively lurking a good idea for scum here, can you please think through what you're saying.
You're basing this off how you *think* town

should

play, even if it contradicts what scum are trying to do.

How does it contradict? and why would scum!you not want to lurk if you do that as town?

[Draynth]

I'm answering now but why

exactly

do you think I'm scum

yeah, in a moment.

Why won't you say now?
You've voted me and said that I'm one of two people you'll lynch today. It's seriously unhelpful that you're A) not telling the town why you think I'm scum and B) Not giving me a chance to defend myself

it takes some time to write things. -_- lol

So you've voted for me and made 6/7 posts without giving any reasoning as to why you voted for me
mmkay

[WhemeStar]

Also if we have no better lynch options NotMafia is great 100% of the time

[ejjinami]

Also, you're basing a lot of points on the fact that you think I said that I reread the thread multiple times.
Nowhere did I say that.
That's about 2/3 instances now where you've claimed that I said something I haven't.

.....isn't lurking: being on the thread but not writing? or am I not geting sth here? -_-
you said yourself you're lurking and didn't you just pop up to react and go back to the posts you didn't react to previously? lol

[ejjinami]

I'm answering now but why

exactly

do you think I'm scum

yeah, in a moment.

Why won't you say now?
You've voted me and said that I'm one of two people you'll lynch today. It's seriously unhelpful that you're A) not telling the town why you think I'm scum and B) Not giving me a chance to defend myself

it takes some time to write things. -_- lol

So you've voted for me and made 6/7 posts without giving any reasoning as to why you voted for me
mmkay

-_- lol
u doing that on purpose?

[ejjinami]

Also, you're basing a lot of points on the fact that you think I said that I reread the thread multiple times.
Nowhere did I say that.
That's about 2/3 instances now where you've claimed that I said something I haven't.

.....isn't lurking: being on the thread but not writing? or am I not geting sth here? -_-
you yourself said "you're lurking" and didn't you just "pop up to react" and then go back to the posts you didn't react to previously? lol

EWPOP- put in "" cuz it was impossible to read.
and @dray, were you lurking? inactivity is not really lurking

[Draynth]

.....isn't lurking: being on the thread but not writing? or am I not geting sth here? -_-
you said yourself you're lurking and didn't you just pop up to react and go back to the posts you didn't react to previously? lol

You keep changing your points
You said I was tactically replying to posts at certain times because I'm scum
I disagree with that because you're basing it off something I never even said

-_- lol
u doing that on purpose?

Am I doing what on purpose
Do you not see how anti-town what you are doing is

[ejjinami]

.....isn't lurking: being on the thread but not writing? or am I not geting sth here? -_-
you said yourself you're lurking and didn't you just pop up to react and go back to the posts you didn't react to previously? lol

You keep changing your points
You said I was tactically replying to posts at certain times because I'm scum
I disagree with that because you're basing it off something I never even said

wait, what?
lurking=reading the thread, but not responding.
you said you were lurking
you waited with responding to posts that I think town!you shouldn't want to wait with

where am I changing the points? What are you seeing in my posts?