Sid Meier's Civilization 5 UPick Mafia (GAME OVER)

[Gamma Emerald]

lmfao

[Chara]

hello Mark!!

[OnTheMark]

Hi everyone!

Someone catch me up the highlights.

[Chara]

honestly, just make ISOing Joey your first priority and you should have a pretty clear view of the game. that or brass.

[OnTheMark]

K that’s gonna take a bit. Anything urgent that needs to be addressed before I start that?

[Klazam]

fullclaim immediately.

[Kiana Kaslana]

Hello Mark!

[OnTheMark]

fullclaim immediately.

Lolz people always troll with fullclaim asks

Any serious requests?

Pedit Hi Kiana!

[Klazam]

not trolling. claim or ill assume youre scum stalling.

[Chara]

actually, a large part of my problems with Titus had to do with how she framed her fullclaim. for serious. :>

[Klazam]

That's plenty of time to check the claim plus chara gave mark a obvious hint there.

it doesnt matter what mark says now. ugh.

[OnTheMark]

actually, a large part of my problems with Titus had to do with how she framed her fullclaim. for serious. :>

Well I don’t give a shit about “problems”

Based on reading the first post we’re pretty much killing this shit

So I will go read Titus’s ISO and see

if

there is merit or I am being trolled by scum.

Hell with how much has flipped this game may be on lock.

[Gamma Emerald]

lol that's not a good sign

[Klazam]

VOTE: onthemark

[Chara]

That's plenty of time to check the claim plus chara gave mark a obvious hint there.

it doesnt matter what mark says now. ugh.

you just don't know them the way i do. <3
time to sleep.

[OnTheMark]

Just ISO’d Titus and she told the truth. Non consecutive doctor. Target was N2 brassherald.

Really fucking stupid imho as n1 always heal the IC barring a damn good reason.

[Gamma Emerald]

Just ISO’d Titus and she told the truth. Non consecutive doctor. Target was N2 brassherald.

Really fucking stupid imho as n1 always heal the IC barring a damn good reason.

You're right that it's stupid but for the wrong reason
read Joey or co-mod ISO to see why

[OnTheMark]

Creature was lynched Day 1. He was Maria I of Portugal (Domination Mafia...)
Dunkerdoodles was killed Night 1. He was Boudica of the Celts (Domination Mafia Pagan Spreader)
Varsoon was killed Night 1. He was Nebuchadnezzar II of Babylon (Science Mafia Role Cop)

So 21 players. 1/3rd is 7 so guessing 7 scum.

Best guess is three teams as three kills. One SK two mafia teams of three?

Gonna iso tomorrow and see if any heat mapping shows anything helpful towards that end.

Pedit definitely will make sure to focus on Joey.

[OnTheMark]

Im breaking the RP because i feel like it keeps me from responding quickly to new stuff and it might hinder my wincon.

@Elbirn about Brass: I disliked most of his content, its especially pretty underwhelming compared to the rest of the table. That being said, my mind changed since i made that vote because he's obviously and very heavily softing that his behavior is explained by his role which IMO is not something i think scum just does. He also had that attitude since the very first post so this is coherent with his posting.

Also inb4 anyone try to push that i am fishing for claims, Brass implied something about his role easily 4-5 times since the beginning of the game, if you didn't notice yet then you are just not paying attention, me saying that in this post doesn't help scum as much as it helps town give the guy some space.

Dear Prime Minister of Stars,

If you feel the RP was stopping you from responding immediately at this point in time, and not the others what caused your stop? I wonder who or what was being pushed at that time. And why did you feel the need to respond immediately? (Yes I am a hyperposter

as well

I am

not

saying hyperposting is scummy. I am saying I need to ascertain the root cause)

This is what I call a “significant event”. Anything that causes yourself or someone else to make a playstyle change or a change in reads is a significant event. Those need to address the why.

Sincerely,

I fucking hate this RP and doing this to make a point

[OnTheMark]

Well, I'm scum and I didn't catch that 'cus I'm bad at catching crumbs, so thanks, sucker.

Interesting response to a playerstyle shift.

Means more than likely Varsoon and Joey are probably NOT on the same scum team since Varsoon flipped scum.
Furthermore assuming no redirect/bus driver shenanigans
— Varsoon’s team shot Elbirn or Dunkerdoodles
— Dunkerdoodle’s team shot Elbirn or Varsoon
— Mysterious SK/one shot vig (still thinking SK) then takes care of the remainder.

Varsoon’s response to Elbrin at that time as well as Joey’s playstyle change means that Varsoon’s team almost certainly shot Elbirn and then Dunkerdoodle’s team shot Varsoon and the third kill was on Varsoon.

So then if the killer is an SK Varsoon was a threat. If the third killer is town they would have been scumreading Varsoon.

Mainly that page right now I find the most telling.

[OnTheMark]

Well, I'm scum and I didn't catch that 'cus I'm bad at catching crumbs, so thanks, sucker.

Interesting response to a playerstyle shift.

Means more than likely Varsoon and Joey are probably NOT on the same scum team since Varsoon flipped scum.
Furthermore assuming no redirect/bus driver shenanigans
— Varsoon’s team shot Elbirn or Dunkerdoodles
— Dunkerdoodle’s team shot Elbirn or Varsoon
— Mysterious SK/one shot vig (still thinking SK) then takes care of the remainder.

Varsoon’s response to Elbrin at that time as well as Joey’s playstyle change means that Varsoon’s team almost certainly shot Elbirn and then Dunkerdoodle’s team shot Varsoon and the third kill was on Dunkerdoodles.

So then if the killer is an SK Dunkerdoodles was a threat. If the third killer is town they would have been scumreading Dunkerdoodles.

Mainly that page right now I find the most telling.

Fuck insomnia I can no has type

[OnTheMark]

Vote Creature, Dunk.

ok
VOTE: creature

Am I really being wagoned for being busy today?

UNVOTE:

my meta is not lynchbait anymore is what im saying

Hm okay, what im saying is that you are lynchbait this game

why am i lynchbait this game and not just scum?
VOTE: joey

Looking at relevant points here in Dunkerdoodle’s ISO and their voting pattern and knowing Creature and Dunker were aligned means that unless Dunker is powerwolfing I find it highly unlikely Joey is scum with Creature and Dunker

[BuJaber]

Mark you should know shaz claimed vig (the 3rd kill).

[OnTheMark]

Since through prior established content, Joey is likely not Varsoon’s partner and Joey isn’t likely Dunkerdoodle’s partner this leaves Joey the SK or Town.

As much as if I am right and the kill is an SK, then it is cause for worry as the SK will

have

to start killing town, considering likely estimates of half scum are dead.

If I am wrong and it was a one shot vig the problem solves itself as there will be no more kills. And if the SK is stupid and doesn’t kill then problem solved and there are like a shit ton of lynches to catch them when Mafia is gone.

Tonight will probably help decide that.

So tldr Joey is probably town. Still working my way through Joey’s ISO.

[OnTheMark]

Mark you should know shaz claimed vig (the 3rd kill).

Lolz okay So Shaz is SK or a vig.

That makes life easy. Destroy mafia until three dead for each known color and if game continues lynch Shaz for being SK. If game continues after that then each mafia probably had four members. I would find that odd and tilting to say the least given a d1 lynch on scum. Or we just lynch Shaz now since 21/3 = 7 meaning Shaz likely SK but I wanna read Shaz ISO to see if there is any merit to the vig claim. I don’t see how it would make sense numerically to be a vig.