NEWBIE 1858: MEDICAL MAFIA (fin)

[Not_Mafia]

VOTE: Shattiel

[Rei]

ok so it seems a lot of you are dead set on shat
what happens if we lynch him then he flips town
i would probably be killed for my tunnel on wheme/2create in d1
we actually cant afford a mislynch like espeo said because next day would be lylo, correct?
the ones left would be

notmaf
dray
schadd

i want each of you to tell me who you would sus and why

[Draynth]

Before I answer, who do you suspect?

[Draynth]

Also nobody else vote for now please

[Shattiel]

I'm never gonna vote for schadd
This will be my lynch order
NM > Draynth > Rei

[Shattiel]

Rei has to be town

[Shattiel]

Also nobody else vote for now please

sorry I don't think I'll be voting anyone today besides NM
VOTE: Not_Mafia

[Shattiel]

I'm still feeling good about my schadd read and none of his posts have really changed it.

[Draynth]

Will post at some point tomorrow, hectic day today

[Draynth]

ok so it seems a lot of you are dead set on shat
what happens if we lynch him then he flips town
i would probably be killed for my tunnel on wheme/2create in d1

Why do you think that your tunnel on someone who flipped scum would lead to you being lynched if shat were to flip town over someone like myself or NM?

we actually cant afford a mislynch like espeo said because next day would be lylo, correct?

We

can

in the sense that mislynching today doesn't lose us the game, obviously its easier hitting scum sooner rather than later.
Honestly I think it'll narrow the pool down a lot as so far after the day 1 events and then the espeo catch we've only lost pr's at night

the ones left would be

notmaf
dray
schadd

i want each of you to tell me who you would sus and why

I'll still answer this but would like both you and Schadd to answer it first.

[Draynth]

And I want to reiterate, anyone who wants to vote either shatt or NM (both are already being voted for, one more puts them within lynch range)

please do not do so right now.

[Draynth]

Top tier mobile posting right there

[Draynth]

[@Bins]
Schadd hasn't posted in 10 days, any update?

[Draynth]

I meant to bold that, god I suck at this on my phone

[Rei]

If shat is town I would probably go for either scchad or not maf since dray is looking a bit townier, but tbh i have no lead atm
I still need to do some iso


@shattiel it makes no sense whasoever why you townread scchad so much
yes i get he had some logical and townie posts, but mafia can seem townie as well
you just haven't provided any other reason beside him being townie to trust him blindly like this
it makes me feel like you want to seem townie by not susing someone that we may suspect, aka "If i was mafia i would push for scchad but i town read him coz I'm a townie and I don't care about being mislynched!"

@dray I meant I would be killed at night if shat is a mislynch today
also espeo said "if shat flips town you can waste a mislynch on not maf"
but we couldnt really afford a mislynch next phase

[Shattiel]

@draynth I tend to post text walls. I'll try to lay it off to the best of my ability but it's not really my problem if you refuse to read them tbh. Last game I played here the average post D1 was probably longer than that and no one complained.

yeah draynth should be town

[Shattiel]

VOTE: not_mafia

Suspect name is suspect. You're either mafia, or you're confusing town by making an unprompted alignment claim. Neither is good.
You're going to have to explain

how you dare

to have a funny username, or land yourself a place at the top of my scumlist.

Okay, so we've heard nothing yet of ChickenFritters.
We've also heard nothing of:
- Not_Mafia since their first post
been inactive.

this is pretty much all of 2creat posts about notmafia

[Shattiel]

4) people normally scum read me all the time even when I am Town so probably badly :c

oh hey!

What do you mean by this? Are you saying you're scumreading soul already? If not, I have no idea what you could mean. You're being a bit ambiguous here.
If you are saying that soul is being scummy however, allow me to disagree. Let's actually pull up the thing you quoted earlier before you put the vote on:

Like your random voting style c: I'm bad at starting up so I'm gonna just wait until something comes up.

I can understand why that's not great play, but I can't understand why you would find such a thing scummy. Surely scum wouldn't say such a thing? It attracts the wrong kind of attention. Sure, lurking is a valid scum strategy.

Saying

you're going to lurk is not, in my opinion. Especially so early on, when you could easily just keep under the radar for a little bit before jumping in when some discussion has already taken place.
I would not call this a towntell at all, but it's also not a scumtell.

I suggest we get meaningful discussion underway ASAP so that no one can hide behind that excuse any longer.

*looks at this post*

Oh hey. Let's keep it going, yeah?

Anyway, rudimentary reads list incoming.
There hasn't been enough discussion to really rank people against each other, but I'll roughly put people in groups.

Reads list.

Town: Ejji
Null: Soul, Schadd, Espeonage
Scum: Rei.

My reason for putting Ejji in town, is that he has been the driving factor behind all discussion so far. There's been very little, so it's not a reliable read for sure, but this is all I have to go on right now.

My reason for putting Rei in scum is posting a complete non-answer to Ejji's question 4. Seriously, it doesn't get any more non-answer than that.
Rei contributes?
Rei tries her best to be good, but might not be very good??
Rei is friendly, but can also be unfriendly if paranoid???
This is a lot of words, but it tells us literally nothing.

I don't consider any other reads I've gathered so far to be meaningful enough to put anyone else in either town or scum.
I've also obviously excluded anyone who's been inactive.

Okay that reply to schad's post could either be bad distancing or just scum overreacting. I'd like to think the former right now at least until notmafia's flip.

Also Rei just couldn't be scum here

[Shattiel]

If shat is town I would probably go for either scchad or not maf since dray is looking a bit townier, but tbh i have no lead atm
I still need to do some iso


@shattiel it makes no sense whasoever why you townread scchad so much
yes i get he had some logical and townie posts, but mafia can seem townie as well
you just haven't provided any other reason beside him being townie to trust him blindly like this
it makes me feel like you want to seem townie by not susing someone that we may suspect, aka "If i was mafia i would push for scchad but i town read him coz I'm a townie and I don't care about being mislynched!"

@dray I meant I would be killed at night if shat is a mislynch today
also espeo said "if shat flips town you can waste a mislynch on not maf"
but we couldnt really afford a mislynch next phase

kek you've already decided that I'd get mislynched today?

Nah I've got lots of confidence with my tone reads.
If schadd is scum then damn I've gotta give it to him by passing through it.
Also It's not the logical thoughts it's the way he thinks I just can't imagine scum thinking that way when what should be filled in scum mind is how to look towny.

[Rei]

If shat is town I would probably go for either scchad or not maf since dray is looking a bit townier, but tbh i have no lead atm
I still need to do some iso


@shattiel it makes no sense whasoever why you townread scchad so much
yes i get he had some logical and townie posts, but mafia can seem townie as well
you just haven't provided any other reason beside him being townie to trust him blindly like this
it makes me feel like you want to seem townie by not susing someone that we may suspect, aka "If i was mafia i would push for scchad but i town read him coz I'm a townie and I don't care about being mislynched!"

@dray I meant I would be killed at night if shat is a mislynch today
also espeo said "if shat flips town you can waste a mislynch on not maf"
but we couldnt really afford a mislynch next phase

kek you've already decided that I'd get mislynched today?

Nah I've got lots of confidence with my tone reads.
If schadd is scum then damn I've gotta give it to him by passing through it.
Also It's not the logical thoughts it's the way he thinks I just can't imagine scum thinking that way when what should be filled in scum mind is how to look towny.

No I haven't "decided", I am thinking of the possibilities
I'll need to iso everyone and see is scchad is as towny as you think he is

[schadd_]

ok

[Draynth]

Say something of substance if you wouldn't mind

[schadd_]

i want each of you to tell me who you would sus and why

from memory, 70% dray 15% NM 13% shat 2% rei?

dray is like residual from d1, and i read d2 at some point during n2 and i remember his stuff made me think "wowie"

nm, i mean like,

is

readable i think, and i weakly think he is town by meta but there isn't anything i can say "he would convincingly not do this as scum"

shat i'm worried that i'm missing something because of people hard scumming them (and espeo probably wasn't just being defensive since he kept scumming her after outing himself) but for the most part they've been like..... fine. i remember there was something from when they were beefing with espeo that made them seem honest to me. incidentally they are townreading everyone except one person which i've noticed as a potentially towny thing often and it has been town several times out of several i think

rei uhhh i guess i believe u that u are town for pushing 2c/wheme + i think i see what ejji saw in her eod1

this all pending reread obv

[schadd_]

Say something of substance if you wouldn't mind

i wouldn't! thank you for your concern.

[Draynth]

Dw I can wait