NEWBIE 1858: MEDICAL MAFIA (fin)

[Shattiel]

This game is too slow can we vote not_mafia already?
He isn't even talking himself would someone defend him?

[Draynth]

Besides him refusing to engage a whole lot why is he scum?

[Shattiel]

Besides him refusing to engage a whole lot why is he scum?

point of elimination
I already isoed everyone and even some interactions with wheme and 2create but nothing really pings me

[Not_Mafia]

Lynch order should be

Shattiel ---> Game ends

[Shattiel]

Like even with just a policy lynch alone I'd still vote NM.
He's a bad person to be with on lylo. His iso is like a broken record he just keeps saying "Shat is scum" that's all he doesn't really gave much of anything for us to read coupled with the fact that he just vote for me no intention to understand or to explain he's a butt alright

[Shattiel]

Lynch order should be

Shattiel ---> Game ends

Hi scumbutt

[Draynth]

Alright I'm gonna iso both shatt and NM when I get home tonight, need to get some content to get this game moving.

[Bins]

|Votecount

3.1

|

(1)

Shattiel

—

Not_Mafia

(1)

Not_Mafia

—

Shattiel

(3)

Not Voting

—

Rei, schadd_, Draynth

With

5

alive, it's

3

to lynch.

Day 3

ends in

(expired on 2018-04-21 18:00:00)

.

[Draynth]

Ugh, I promise I'll do this tomorrow. Got about halfway through and jotted some points down but had to finish some college work. Schadd, you said you thought I was scum. Why do you think that?

[schadd_]

You said "I'm not sure" and "I don't think I can tell" so why would you defend him and say that shouldn't be a scumread when other people gave their opinion on a subject you're not sure?
Every post is ai even a fluff could be ai depending on the person who said it. Just because you can't see it being a scumread doesn't mean that others wouldn't see it too.

Wait, if I think stuff other people are scumreading him for might be NAI, why shouldn't I defend him? (I don't think I did that btw, I don't remember there being any strong scumreads on him... :/ so lol)
And yeah, I agree fluff can be AI. But I wouldn't be confident in reading that in his case. :/ and why should I stop myself from saying my opinion if I'm just not confident? like, every opinion should be helpful imo.

well the thing is 2creat posts was like 4-5 paragraphs.. you can't just summarize it into 1-2 sentences and call it nai or shouldn't be a scumread when you could scumread someone even with just a 1 sentence post

first mention of 2c slot

they did something a couple times, incl. here, where they mention him in a non-readsy way. i guess somewhat partnery esp. for a newbie but not groundbreaking

[schadd_]

Not_Mafia isnt doing anything so he's probably town

what changed this

[schadd_]

they did something a couple times, incl. here, where they mention him in a non-readsy way.

non-readsy meaning not related to a read of 2c

obv the post had something to do with reads

[schadd_]

soul
Rei
Draynth
Not_Mafia
Espeonage

As of right now I'm pretty sure 1 scum is here and around 70% sure two scums are here. It's still pretty early but let's see.

if you are doing the 2010 strat in the way espeonage claimed you probably put your partner in this

not doing so would be pretty bold

[schadd_]

first mention of 2c slot

oh thtbthb their first post lmao

Spoiler: other posts i was talking about

Oh by the way, what does locktown mean? Not familiar with that terminology.

can't be scum like a proven town or something.

btw.... I got slight scumbuddy feelings from the "but sure?"
but whatever

Is this your idea of a joke?

NGL

i guess there are two of them

in light of the first post there's like a ... mediumly reasonable and rather-newbie partner narrative there, like, early faux-pressure and then slide to a town read with some stuff that could pass as engagement

but i think they are conscious enough of partner tells to specifically avoid looking like that

[schadd_]

soul
Rei
Draynth
Not_Mafia
Espeonage

As of right now I'm pretty sure 1 scum is here and around 70% sure two scums are here. It's still pretty early but let's see.

If you're not townreading Rei, do you think her latest posts were NAI? What is your read on her? And why are you townreading 2cre?

not exacly nai I'm just not sure how to approach her posts. It could come from mafia/town from my pov because most of her posts are just a counter attack to 2creats post.

2cre isn't a solid town read. That long post he made in reply to rei sounds genuine.

saying he "isn't a solid town read" when pressed is mreennhh but this also just strikes me as not caring about a narrative

[schadd_]

soul
Rei
Draynth
Not_Mafia
Espeonage

As of right now I'm pretty sure 1 scum is here and around 70% sure two scums are here. It's still pretty early but let's see.

btw these names I listed are nulls.
I just pretty much town hunted and poed to get these names because there aren't really much posts to read them

Honestly, this is very 2010 scum. Call everyone scum, back down when questioned, then bring it up when you are correct and ride to the endgame. You need to be flipped.

I'll vote here when I have read/skimmed everything methinks.

This read of yours is shit btw
And guess what it's 2018 right now not 2010

this is the thing i mentioned uhhhhhh 2 days ago

pretty transparent frustration response, this is the sort of thing i would always get frustrated with back when mafia made me feel exciting emotions like surprise and frustration

and like you can feel that as scum but i think their immediate thought as scum would be like "haha bihhhh i didn't even put my partner there skrt skrt skrt"

[schadd_]

there was probably more stuff of some sort later in that ISO but i already ctrl F'd for 2c/wheme and didn't find much interesting

i might look at it later when i'm not like 11 minutes late for something

[schadd_]

ok time to do NM iso

ok done

[schadd_]

that was a joke

he had more posts than i remember

but i mean not that much stuff to glean

I don't believe the claim but in the absence of a cc

VOTE: Shat

this one was kinda bad

Wheme and Shatt have been pretty transparent for a while now

this one was also pretty lmao

[schadd_]

that second one is also just funny in light of the fact that like, if he is scum, he has just been pushing a vanity wagon (kinda? i mean when espeo was alive it was a reasonable wagon, idr anyone else pushing them that hard) and so it's like "what? oh yeah

obviously

i was also scumreading him"

i somewhat think that is too obvious to be something that he did

idk like, in the micro i played with him way back when, he posted about 2 times as scum, and that would have been more than a year ago but he does just look way more engaged here, obv not with, like,

content

, but like he has clearly been interested in shitting around a bit and he seems genuinely committed to lynching shat (though i don't really get the reasoning) (..or see any)

[Shattiel]

You said "I'm not sure" and "I don't think I can tell" so why would you defend him and say that shouldn't be a scumread when other people gave their opinion on a subject you're not sure?
Every post is ai even a fluff could be ai depending on the person who said it. Just because you can't see it being a scumread doesn't mean that others wouldn't see it too.

Wait, if I think stuff other people are scumreading him for might be NAI, why shouldn't I defend him? (I don't think I did that btw, I don't remember there being any strong scumreads on him... :/ so lol)
And yeah, I agree fluff can be AI. But I wouldn't be confident in reading that in his case. :/ and why should I stop myself from saying my opinion if I'm just not confident? like, every opinion should be helpful imo.

well the thing is 2creat posts was like 4-5 paragraphs.. you can't just summarize it into 1-2 sentences and call it nai or shouldn't be a scumread when you could scumread someone even with just a 1 sentence post

first mention of 2c slot

they did something a couple times, incl. here, where they mention him in a non-readsy way. i guess somewhat partnery esp. for a newbie but not groundbreaking

nop I'm talking with ejji here about his response to 2cs post.

[Shattiel]

Not_Mafia isnt doing anything so he's probably town

what changed this

wasn't actually sure of this.
It was just something I said on the spot

[Shattiel]

soul
Rei
Draynth
Not_Mafia
Espeonage

As of right now I'm pretty sure 1 scum is here and around 70% sure two scums are here. It's still pretty early but let's see.

If you're not townreading Rei, do you think her latest posts were NAI? What is your read on her? And why are you townreading 2cre?

not exacly nai I'm just not sure how to approach her posts. It could come from mafia/town from my pov because most of her posts are just a counter attack to 2creats post.

2cre isn't a solid town read. That long post he made in reply to rei sounds genuine.

saying he "isn't a solid town read" when pressed is mreennhh but this also just strikes me as not caring about a narrative

I just really forced that townread on 2c though. There's hardly anything I could read people at that time.

[Shattiel]

soul
Rei
Draynth
Not_Mafia
Espeonage

As of right now I'm pretty sure 1 scum is here and around 70% sure two scums are here. It's still pretty early but let's see.

btw these names I listed are nulls.
I just pretty much town hunted and poed to get these names because there aren't really much posts to read them

Honestly, this is very 2010 scum. Call everyone scum, back down when questioned, then bring it up when you are correct and ride to the endgame. You need to be flipped.

I'll vote here when I have read/skimmed everything methinks.

This read of yours is shit btw
And guess what it's 2018 right now not 2010

this is the thing i mentioned uhhhhhh 2 days ago

pretty transparent frustration response, this is the sort of thing i would always get frustrated with back when mafia made me feel exciting emotions like surprise and frustration

and like you can feel that as scum but i think their immediate thought as scum would be like "haha bihhhh i didn't even put my partner there skrt skrt skrt"

I was triggered there xD
I just couldn't get how his trying to get me lynched with his poor case he didn't even thought I'm town he just decided I'm scum for doing that and wants me flipped

[Shattiel]

that second one is also just funny in light of the fact that like, if he is scum, he has just been pushing a vanity wagon (kinda? i mean when espeo was alive it was a reasonable wagon, idr anyone else pushing them that hard) and so it's like "what? oh yeah

obviously

i was also scumreading him"

i somewhat think that is too obvious to be something that he did

idk like, in the micro i played with him way back when, he posted about 2 times as scum, and that would have been more than a year ago but he does just look way more engaged here, obv not with, like,

content

, but like he has clearly been interested in shitting around a bit and he seems genuinely committed to lynching shat (though i don't really get the reasoning) (..or see any)

if he does looks genuine in lynching me then he wouldve made a convincing case why I'm scum..