Newbie 1859 (Game Over)

[Oxy]

Yeah I realized. I don’t mind that much, but I feel like people are going to stay with their same wrong reads after I die which is kind of annoying.

If we lynch you (and you flip town)

Why do we lynch tomorrow?

Who do we never lynch?

[Oxy]

Who* not why

[ofrhz]

1. One of Scioness and pin. NSG needs to come under actual scrutiny

2. I don’t have the kind of information to say “never Lynch this person” but if people could stop scumreading ruru and Oxy, that’d be nice.

I said that bc skitter is independently scumreading you (Oxy) and Scioness is independently scumreading ruru, so my flip doesn’t seem like it’ll change their minds about that very much.

[Scioness Sajj]

they don't because being town or scum doesn't make said person be less or more logical.

the thing is ruru doesn't even try to defend you, ofrhz. she is trying to persuade pintu. and I think pintu is reading me and skitter by association not sheeping skitter's read on me.
1838 is a mess.
ruru just dropped her scum read on skitter to shade nsg, becuase she knows that pintu is townreading skitter and haven't said anything about nsg in a while.

[Oxy]

What I mean to say is hey, SS, I really like how you think about the game! I feel pretty confident that you're town, because you just come across as super genuine. Anyone who is scumreading you should probably stop now because it's just making the game unnecessarily confusing. Who do you think we should lynch?

@sajj Are you reading this as sincere? If so, you should know that it is sarcasm.

[Scioness Sajj]

I have never addressed it though?

and yes I know what it is.

[Oxy]

Okay, just checking.

If you understand that to be sarcasm, I really don't understand why you think 1838 is a mess.

[Scioness Sajj]

Ruru - In the quoted I have wrote examples of how you could have pocketed oxy. No clue why you think that pocketing is tone exclusive.

[skitter30]

I dislike oxy's reaction to the ofrhz wagon; I feel like he's setting up a lynchpool for tomorrow.

I don't like ofrhz' scumread on pin. I don't really like oxy's reaction to pin's post.

I'm vaguely wondering if I've been pocketed by scioness.

NSG needs to say something useful before the day ends.

[pinturicchio]

Lol I didn't read it as sarcasm and I was freaking out. Sorry, bad english strikes again

[Oxy]

Yeah, but your examples were garbage

Working together != pocketing

And the idea that Ruru never questions me was laughable.

And it's not unreasonable for Ruru to point out that she was not using 'traditional' methods of pocketing

which is something you have agreed with implicitly, if not explicitly.

@skitter How am I setting up a lynch pool?

[Scioness Sajj]

I'm vaguely wondering if I've been pocketed by scioness.

why so?

[Oxy]

Lol I didn't read it as sarcasm and I was freaking out. Sorry, bad english strikes again

lololol thanks for the smile, Pin =)

[skitter30]

That everyone who has been in my poe list is either at L-1 at or putting that person at L-1 makes it seem super likely that this is a bus

You're tying people on the wagon to an ofrzh scumflip.

[Oxy]

That everyone who has been in my poe list is either at L-1 at or putting that person at L-1 makes it seem super likely that this is a bus

You're tying people on the wagon to an ofrzh scumflip.

Please use logic to refute this from my pov

or acknowledge that I have reached a reasonable conclusion from my pov, and acknowledge that it isn't scummy.

Because coming to a logical conclusion when trying to determine who to lynch is not scummy

[ofrhz]

scioness- ruru’s townread on me was based on something I said in D1 I believe. I never had any reason to believe she had that strong of a townread on me. She can correct me if I’m wrong ofc.

Ruru is also right to point out the assumptions in pin’s reasoning.

Skitter- I kinda think you were/are. At least based on how Scioness talks to me and ruru and Oxy vs how she talks to you.

[Oxy]

Seriously skitter, I could say that the sky is blue and you would say that makes me scummy.

[Scioness Sajj]

Yeah, but your examples were garbage

Working together != pocketing

And the idea that Ruru never questions me was laughable.

And it's not unreasonable for Ruru to point out that she was not using 'traditional' methods of pocketing

which is something you have agreed with implicitly, if not explicitly.

i have never seen you work with anybody really. white knighting you is not working with you, doing what you tell her to do is not working with you

I don't really remember her disagreeing with you.

pointing out is not, shading me once again is another thing.

[ofrhz]

Ugh this is what I mean. After I flip, skitter is just going to keep pursuing the whole scum Oxy thing.

[ruru]

1. One of Scioness and pin. NSG needs to come under actual scrutiny

How would we accomplish this, like serious question

I townread you at first, honestly forget why that changed.

Also northsidegal, why aren’t you voting?

slipped my mind, honestly.

how much forum experience do you have?

This is my first forum game.

@ruru

how much forum experience do you have?

etc.

[ofrhz]

Lolllll that’s a good question. It has to start with everyone dropping their townread on NSG and putting pressure on her. It’s not out of the realm of possibility to argue that NSG hasn’t been seriously scum hunting

Then think how would scum NSG react? I think math left clues for that

[Scioness Sajj]

ofrhz feels like a caught scum now

[ofrhz]

wait But even if NSG is scum, I think it’s easier to find her partner.

[ofrhz]

Why would that be a sad thing from your POV? ...?

[Scioness Sajj]

I had a vote on you that was a sorting vote. Said few times that I wanna sort you out. Seems like you have gave up on even trying to defend yourself. So yeah it meh