Mini 2004 - Birth of the Necromancer - [DERP! - MOD LOSES]

[Nancy Drew 39]

But I’ve asked you now twice and you STILL won’t say what that is? Is it a secret or do you not even have one?

I almost always at least try to give a reason - esp. when explicitly asked.

It sounds like you don’t want to answer and the fact that I’ve asked you now twice reads like you really don’t have one.

oh no you avoided my question. I guess that means that just because someone asks a question doesn't mean you're obligated to answer! :3

It does indeed sound like I don't want to answer. That's because I don't want to answer. Not wanting to answer is not the same thing as not having a reason however.

I'll ask again: Can you think of any reason someone might have a reason to vote yet not want to share?


PS who the hell taught you how to use semicolons because good lord go get a refund

No, I really can’t tbh. Why would you want to hide your reasons?

Slamming me for grammer now, seriously?

[the worst]

All due respect ND39 but that was physically painful to watch......I am here to lynch scumz not relive the angst of my high school life

If youd put as much time into this game thinking about others' alignments as you have spamming AtE the game state would be a lot better and people would have actual reads on you.

Honest feedback

VOTE: Eeveelution

Great vote VOTE: Eeveelution

Well, sorry for that but I thought the votes last night on me were a joke; so I was shocked to find myself at L-2. j Would you really be this nonchalant if you unexpectedly found yourself at L-2 in a d1 maj vote? I seriously doubt it.

Thanks for the free “advice” but it would be far more helpful to me; to tell me your reasons for voting Evee.

ND39 confirmed optimal policy lynch if we need one

Address my other post now

[brassherald]

Nancy is probably town, but annoying AF at this point.

I am against policy lynching, though.

UNVOTE:

Smell y'all later.

[the worst]

Nancy enough with the selfmeta and theories
I want to see what you think about people's alignments.

Rn, I’m the most sus about Action Dan, I think his professed concern for me doesn’t add up; if he’s beyond convinced I’M scum.

I also don’t like Zito not giving any reason for voting on me; even when I pressed him on it.

VOTE: Action Dan

Are scum more likely to vote without reasons?
Why/why not?

^^^^
ND39 answer this one

[Tywin Lannister]

Catching up now, but I'm here.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Nancy enough with the selfmeta and theories
I want to see what you think about people's alignments.

Rn, I’m the most sus about Action Dan, I think his professed concern for me doesn’t add up; if he’s beyond convinced I’M scum.

I also don’t like Zito not giving any reason for voting on me; even when I pressed him on it.

VOTE: Action Dan

Are scum more likely to vote without reasons?
Why/why not?

In general, I’d definitely say yes or really bad ones. I was recently in a game where a player (who eventually flipped scum) invoked multiball.

So yeah, the thought process behind giving a read - accurate or not, is often key to descerning alignment.

[Papa Zito]

No, I really can’t tbh. Why would you want to hide your reasons?

Slamming me for grammer now, seriously?

*grammar


There's any number of reasons why I'd want to hide my reasons! I'm surprised as a graduate of MU you're not able to come up with any. I've been told so often how much better mafia play is over there. This isn't a newbie game tho so I'll leave that particular theory lesson for you to chew on.

Anyway it seems people have abandoned this wagon because they saw something shiny so I guess I'll go vote your partner now.


VOTE: Kokichi

[Wisdom]

Zito why dont you join us on eevee

[the worst]

Nancy enough with the selfmeta and theories
I want to see what you think about people's alignments.

Rn, I’m the most sus about Action Dan, I think his professed concern for me doesn’t add up; if he’s beyond convinced I’M scum.

I also don’t like Zito not giving any reason for voting on me; even when I pressed him on it.

VOTE: Action Dan

Are scum more likely to vote without reasons?
Why/why not?

In general, I’d definitely say yes or really bad ones. I was recently in a game where a player (who eventually flipped scum) invoked multiball.

So yeah, the thought process behind giving a read - accurate or not, is often key to descerning alignment.

Correct.

Answer the question. Why would scum do this more than town?

[the worst]

Ftr I will not join you on ActDan atm I am sorting you obv

[Papa Zito]

Zito why dont you join us on eevee

I'm mad you left the Nancy wagon. I wasn't done with it yet.

[Eddie Cane]

Zito why dont you join us on eevee

unfortunately he's eevee's partner D:

[Wisdom]

Well I was
Thats hardly an answer though
Why Kokichi and why not Eevee

[Papa Zito]

Well I was
Thats hardly an answer though
Why Kokichi and why not Eevee

unfortunately I'm eevee's partner D:

I'd rather talk to Kokichi.

[Nancy Drew 39]

All due respect ND39 but that was physically painful to watch......

I am here to lynch scumz not relive the angst of my high school life

If youd put as much time into this game thinking about others' alignments as you have spamming AtE the game state would be a lot better and people would have actual reads on you.

Honest feedback

VOTE: Eeveelution

Great vote VOTE: Eeveelution

Well, sorry for that but I thought the votes last night on me were a joke; so I was shocked to find myself at L-2. j Would you really be this nonchalant if you unexpectedly found yourself at L-2 in a d1 maj vote? I seriously doubt it.

Thanks for the free “advice” but it would be far more helpful to me; to tell me your reasons for voting Evee.

ND39 confirmed optimal policy lynch if we need one

Address my other post now

Yeah, I answered you the first time. Why am I the”confirmed optimal policy lynch”? Based on my trying to explain why I did what I did, or because you didn’t approve of my answer?

I get it; you think it was defensive on my part and that’s true in part, but you are also refusing to try to see things from my pov. I just didn’t find it helpful tbh. It was prob. the high school angst comment..

Why don’t YOU answer ME. I also asked a quedtion, which I’m still waiting for you to answer. Why Evee?

I also don’t take orders, esp. from anyone who prefaces it with advocating policy lynching me.

[the worst]

(:

[Nancy Drew 39]

No, I really can’t tbh. Why would you want to hide your reasons?

Slamming me for grammer now, seriously?

*grammar


There's any number of reasons why I'd want to hide my reasons! I'm surprised as a graduate of MU you're not able to come up with any. I've been told so often how much better mafia play is over there. This isn't a newbie game tho so I'll leave that particular theory lesson for you to chew on.

Anyway it seems people have abandoned this wagon because they saw something shiny so I guess I'll go vote your partner now.


VOTE: Kokichi

I’m hardly a “graduate” of MU; I’ve only played 4 games on there.

Now you’re on me for typos; well, expect a lot them.

I don’t have a partner. Once again, you just draw conclusions without any explanation whatsoever. That’s straight up shading. Or could this possibly projection on your part?

[Nancy Drew 39]

Well I was
Thats hardly an answer though
Why Kokichi and why not Eevee

unfortunately I'm eevee's partner D:

I'd rather talk to Kokichi.

Why aren’t you answering their question?

You expect us to “understand” you never giving reasons or answering questions? Well, I don’t and that shading in your last post; came totally out of left field.

[Nancy Drew 39]

UNVOTE: Unvote Action Dan


VOTE: Papa Zito

[the worst]

ND39 the reason I stated you as a good PL is because you're difficult to sort and dont seem to be open to explaining your reads/thought process.

On the balance or probabilities a random player you have an exchange with is more likely to be town than scum. You're acting like everyone is going after you. We are not all scum hun.

You seem to have ignored my question as to WHY scum are more likely to vote with no reasoning. Spoiler: that is a bottom tier excuse for a scumtell. If that's your earnst attempt at scumhunting and you're alive late game you'll lose this for town.

I am trying to see this fypov dude meet me half way. I have dropped 50 times the amount of readable content (i.e.not waffling theory talk) you have so sorry, I need you to engage me before I explain shit to you.

[Srceenplay]

Zito why dont you join us on eevee

unfortunately he's eevee's partner D:

Why don’t you think like me any other time?
Prodge

[the worst]

I miss you srceen. This game is lacking a certain srceeniness.

[Srceenplay]

It’s getting hard to bite my tongue.

[the worst]

Whats on your mind?

[Nancy Drew 39]

ND39 the reason I stated you as a good PL is because you're difficult to sort and dont seem to be open to explaining your reads/thought process.

On the balance or probabilities a random player you have an exchange with is more likely to be town than scum. You're acting like everyone is going after you. We are not all scum hun.

You seem to have ignored my question as to WHY scum are more likely to vote with no reasoning. Spoiler: that is a bottom tier excuse for a scumtell. If that's your earnst attempt at scumhunting and you're alive late game you'll lose this for town.

I am trying to see this fypov dude meet me half way. I have dropped 50 times the amount of readable content (i.e.not waffling theory talk) you have so sorry, I need you to engage me before I explain shit to you.

Of course I know that not everyone or even most who,are tunneling me are scum. I think Wisdom is likely town and I’m tr you too. Zito’s responses, esp. his sudden left-field shading of me with k; seemed really sus to me.

Okay, why? Because they’re not genuinely interested in solving but they want you to think they are; so they are far less likely to have a valid reason for their reads than town would. If they can get away without giving ANY reason at all for their reads; so much the better. One of the best scumtells tells is fakeness; just like genuineness is often a really good towntell.

With scum, it’s the sense of something not adding up.

And btw, you’d be very wrong about that; re: my “ losing it for town”. I greatly improve as the game progresses and on MU; I nailed the last scum in 3 out of 4 games. I inderstand why you or anyone here would find that difficult to believe. My strength is in late game but as everyone has observed; I majorily suck early game. I’m not really sure why that is but it has been more or less a consistent pattern in my gameplay.

I also have not “ignored” anything you’ve asked. I’m sincerely trying to answer your questions. I don’t know why you even think that. I’m baffled by it tbh.