Open 721: Pick Your Poison (Game Over)

[ruru]

i'm so cute now

Probably at least 50% this

[ofrhz]

PFP

ofrhz is the only player so far not to townread me.

I like this.

I don’t like that they’re not doing anything about that.

Also, you guys shitpost a lot more than I’m used to. Though I’m used to 72hr day phases, so I guess there’s more time to piss about here...

Anyway, shameless kinda sorta OMGUS ‘cause you should follow the rest of the herd, damnit.

VOTE: ofrhz

I think what you’ve written is NAI for an experienced player.

Why do you think it’s important that I sort you right away?

What’s PFP

[the worst]

do you scumread ofrhz?

@sunsh

[ofrhz]

ofrhz

Math recently stated Sajj was his top scumpick. What are your thoughts on one of your townreads thinking another of your townreads is worthy of the lynch?

Did he? He was scumreading Scioness based off of one post, and I haven’t seen his updated opinion of Scioness after her recent posts.

I’m not bothered about it because it’s still early in the day, and either of our reads can evolve.

[ofrhz]

i'm so cute now

Probably at least 50% this

[Mathdino]

i'm unprepared to read scioness without understanding the difference between her towngame and her scumgame

my northside pal was able to identify the difference easily, so clearly there IS something, it's just not within my range right now to see it

that said her recent posting wasn't scummy so she's not currently my top scumspect

[ofrhz]

Math, who are your top scumspects?

[Mathdino]

lynchpool: {AP, Draynth, Mohab, ofhrz, Sci, UglyDuck}

I don't have any
Not enough content to tell

[Sunshine13]

@ruru

for srs though

I mean if we can’t take your townread seriously, why should we take your votes seriously?

p.edit (presumably meaning pre-post edit?) I like to think I play the same as town and scum. I actually think I appear more townie as scum, but I’m biased like that.

Like I said before, I’m used to shorter games, so I tend to prefer people to form opinions quickly. It also means you’re engaging with what’s available in the game. I am experienced; don’t conflate that with me being good :p

What are your thoughts regarding ruru voting me based on townreading you, then?

PFP means “posting from phone”.

I’ll continue pointedly ignoring t-dubs. Sorry.

p.edit2: n’mind about math’s opinion regarding sajj, then

p.edit3: dudes let me post ffs

[Oxy]

Who needs scum reads, amirite?

Just call active people town and use poe as an excuse to reintroduce Lynch all Lurkers as policy.~~~

[Mathdino]

Wait skitter and the worst are outside both my townpool and lynchpool

I actually think TW is my top scumspect haha

[the worst]

Thats your paranoia speaking ignore me

[ruru]

I mean if we can’t take your townread seriously, why should we take your votes seriously?

[ofrhz]

What are your thoughts regarding ruru voting me based on townreading you, then?

I have never seen town ruru at work, but she is more proactive with her vote this game in comparison to her scumgame in Newbie 1859. It doesn't change my read on her.

[ofrhz]

I actually think TW is my top scumspect haha

Can you explain why?

[Mathdino]

It was the first RVS wagon and it was Sajj's first post. What could she have done to be less vague?

No alt, and I upon cursory examination, I have played 26 games of mafia. Holy shit. First game on this site since the place I normally play is pretty much dead used to smaller games (around 9-13 players) so I might try my hand at a bigger once once I get used to how things operate in a different place.

I think 13p is the perfect size game (give or take)
welcome. hope you enjoy it here.

sheeping the first rvs wagon to L-2 with nothing but a "hi" post pings me as more likely scummy than null/towny. L-2 also lacks the accountability of L-1 or even like a 2nd vote, it's a decent position for scum to be in.

idk if it were me I'd say something like "good wagon, evilduck must die (vote)" but that's not really the point.

I'm not lockscumming her ass and suggesting we lynch with fire but it's a great place to start

btw Math is super super heavily invested in the whole Mafia Discussion world and is incredibly sharp re. open setups. everything he says will be objectively correct or a highly educated opinion. but it's not alignment indicative.

All of this feels incredibly fake and forced tbh.

this read is actually on point and is the same read that i get reading this post

that's about it though

i don't see many players in this game that i would expect to make themselves obvious as scum on D1 so i'm primarily working off PoE here

[the worst]

VOTE: Mathdino
rofl

[Mathdino]

it's like you WANT me to get you lynched

[the worst]

Nah this is too 2d for town!Math

[the worst]

not gonna demand you find me scum in the next 10 posts or anything crazy but....where is the effort

[Mathdino]

well the fact that there's for sure scum somewhere in the following



means i'm not exactly in a place to nail scum or lead wagons

i can't nail someone off 1 or 2 posts nor do i have any faith in my ability to correctly scumread someone off 1 or 2 posts

i have my townbloc, now i'm just playing a waiting game

vote some lurkers with me, i was promised catchups

[the worst]

fiiiine VOTE: Draynth

[the worst]

if you're town and we correctly read each other I think we have a very very strong chance of winning

[Oxy]

this read is actually on point and is the same read that i get reading this post

that's about it though

i don't see many players in this game that i would expect to make themselves obvious as scum on D1 so i'm primarily working off PoE here

Is there a specific part to 81 that you read as fake?

Because I'm super not seeing it.

[the worst]

thank you Oxy, I would accept NAI on that post as it wasn't very game related but scumreading it is BS.
I'm pretty sure that style of posting also lines up with the first game Math and I played together (we were both town). sooo