Mini Normal 2010 - Scientific Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Srceenplay]

Wait where did he do that? If that's the case it confirms there's scum in the hood and that's he's scum (unless there's like two hoods that have an overlapping member, which I don't think is possible..?)

@Screen: could you go over scum Garuga a bit more?

I have more reads but VOTE: Shoshin before anything else.
Looking at mod meta quickly.

Garuga is basically just from their pt perspective.
I was torn between them and BuJaber.
But after Garuga still trying to deflect from Shoshin I think it’s definitely them.

[Srceenplay]

Nope I don't see those 3 together at all.

I think there is a big chance garuga is scum with one of them. But that would clear the other imo.

Like it's shoshin/garuga/x or brawl/garuga/x or even screen/garuga/x (kudos on the theatrics if this is it) but in the event that scum is found in the hood and garuga also flips scum they'd be a really terrible team if their 3rd member was also in the hood. I don't think the hood survives until end game. I mean I can't speak for anyone else but I'd be so paranoid if I was alive at lylo and 1 of the neighbors was still alive with me.

Again, brawl is on the list because of the theater.
We were having the discussion amongst ourselves in the pt.
As soon as I left for the night the stopped in the pt and moved to the main thread.
What motivation is behind that? It felt awkward and looks like theater.
Brawl is not as strong as the other two but it’s definitely worth an invest.

[Srceenplay]

Screen: could you go over scum Garuga a bit more?

I should have just answered this^

[Srceenplay]

Are

No jesters no third option just an easy lynch.

[Garuga]

I’ll go ahead and announce the scum team.

Shoshin
Garuga
Brawl

We lynch Shoshin.
Vig Garuga
Cop brawl.

Your reads are dead-on BTW.

[ByronVilla]

I’ll go ahead and announce the scum team.

Shoshin
Garuga
Brawl

We lynch Shoshin.
Vig Garuga
Cop brawl.

Your reads are dead-on BTW.

Ok that just kinda ruins the game if you're telling the truth.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Garuga

[Srceenplay]

I’ll go ahead and announce the scum team.

Shoshin
Garuga
Brawl

We lynch Shoshin.
Vig Garuga
Cop brawl.

Your reads are dead-on BTW.

/ff

[TehBrawlGuy]

But I've been wanting to lynch one of you even before screen confirmed being in a neighborhood.

Shoshin is scum by play not just odds.

You have other suspects I will gladly discuss with you, but the lynch shouldn't change for today.

I agree, I just want everyone on the wagon to state some version of the bolded so we can look at this afterwards under that lens.

Thoughts on TiaM?

Oh ok, so let me rephrase my question, how does Garuga get tangled into this?

I’ll go ahead and announce the scum team.

Shoshin
Garuga
Brawl

We lynch Shoshin.
Vig Garuga
Cop brawl.

Gotta line up those mislynches amirite?

OMGUS much?

Considering he called my read on him fake with no arguments whatsoever, I'm not going to give him the privilege of a proper post.

In the event you

are

actually Town, you're not giving him the "privilege of a post", you're giving players like me it so we don't mislynch your ass.

[TehBrawlGuy]

Normally I catch up page by page, but I’ve seen some of the stuff about PTs so have more knowledge than I usually would.

@Boys: Bujaber townread earlier was for good thought process, asking questions that I could see town asking (aka that I was thinking at times), effort. Much more reason to townread him after the PT revelations.

Shoshin seems scum based on PT stuff as of p9. Rereading the first couple of pages and either Shoshin is unaware that 3 person neighbourhoods usually contain scum, or he isn’t trying to hunt in it like the other two are.

@Screen/Brawl- was there any mention early in the neighbourhood that one of you was likely scum?

Yeah, Screen had a tussle with me and Sho over it. Screen said our first priority should be figuring out who in the Hood was Scum, whereas Sho and I disagreed and said it should be in general scumhunting and reads development. My rationale was threefold:
Breaking the town out of RVS and generating discussion was the most important because it gets the whole Town going
We could simply wait and sort the hood naturally as info comes in based on our discussions both in thread and in PT.
Getting a case going on someone b/c they're in the hood or said something off in PT is not feasible without claiming, so better to wait until you can build cases off of in-thread content.

[TehBrawlGuy]

Nope I don't see those 3 together at all.

I think there is a big chance garuga is scum with one of them. But that would clear the other imo.

Like it's shoshin/garuga/x or brawl/garuga/x or even screen/garuga/x (kudos on the theatrics if this is it) but in the event that scum is found in the hood and garuga also flips scum they'd be a really terrible team if their 3rd member was also in the hood. I don't think the hood survives until end game. I mean I can't speak for anyone else but I'd be so paranoid if I was alive at lylo and 1 of the neighbors was still alive with me.

Again, brawl is on the list because of the theater.
We were having the discussion amongst ourselves in the pt.
As soon as I left for the night the stopped in the pt and moved to the main thread.
What motivation is behind that? It felt awkward and looks like theater.
Brawl is not as strong as the other two but it’s definitely worth an invest.

I can't speak for Sho, but my motivation was that Sho was Scum, and that you're either also Scum or pretty obnoxious/clueless Town and either way it was better to just do shit in the thread.

[Srceenplay]

Screen said our first priority should be figuring out who in the Hood was Scum, whereas Sho and I disagreed and said it should be in general scumhunting and reads development.

Not entirely true.
I said our first priority should be sorting each other. Not “find the scum”.
Shoshin opened with they will assume we are all town until later.

[TwoInAMillion]

VOTE: garuga

[Gustavo]

VOTE: Garuga

[TehBrawlGuy]

Look, Gustavo, if you're here enough to vote on the scumclaim, you're here enough to give us a few sentences of your thoughts. Stop being a dead weight slot.

[Gustavo]

I had a gut read on Garuga before I went on v/la. I searched my name and he looked bad for his vote on me. Misrepping my joke into something else and using that as a reason to vote is scummy as shit.

I see 2 quick votes on this page so I start reading backwards and see the claim. That’s all I know. I don’t know anything else cause I haven’t read anything.

If that doesn’t satisfy your request. Vote me.

[Gustavo]

I was on v/la dude. Don’t call me dead weight. I haven’t been here. Now piss off

[TehBrawlGuy]

That's all I was asking for. You hadn't commented on anyone besides Byron up until this point, I didn't know how much of the thread you'd read, and I don't like naked votes.

[Srceenplay]

Why are we letting scum derail the lynch?

[Gustavo]

That's all I was asking for. You hadn't commented on anyone besides Byron up until this point, I didn't know how much of the thread you'd read, and I don't like naked votes.

When scum gives up. Naked votes are inevitable

[BuJaber]

Thoughts on TiaM?

He hasn't really pinged me. He seems to be saying the right things. It might be buddying but I am just going to assume that town don't have a lot to disagree about so far.


Why all the votes on garuga? He's only scum once we confirm there is scum in the neighborhood. But him flipping town doesn't clear the neighbors so there's no point in lynching him first.

Frankly I can see screen's point here. This feels like wagon derailment, or an attempt to split up the town/create confusion and doubt.

[TwoInAMillion]

I love how everyone is scumreading me and yet not voting me.

In that case, I'll just reveal I'm this game's

Mafia Rolecop

.

[BuJaber]

So a policy lynch?

Just the timing of it is suspicious. Yes a scum claim should never be given a pass but why is he doing it now when shoshin was looking like the winning wagon?

Nobody voting for shoshin is saying that garuga is town. Garuga is day 2 lynch if shoshin flips scum. So assuming he is scum, and shoshin is his partner why would he sacrifice himself?

Also if he is scum and brawl (or screen) is his partner? Why would he derail shoshin's wagon, when it can buy him and his team 1 day without scum lynches and all of them alive for night 1?

I think it's simply that shoshin has a stronger scum role.

[Archwing]

VC 1.04

Ah yes... the Hairy Ball Theorem. If you had a ball, and it was completely covered in hair, then there would be no feasible way to have all of the hair lying down without overlapping itself. This translates to vector fields. Which, on Earth, is what we use to study wind. What does this all mean? At any one time, you can be guaranteed that there is a spot on Earth where there is literally

no

wind. Neat!

BuJaber (1):

Shoshin

Mumble (0):

Voyc (0):

Gustavo (0):

Hopkirk (1):

Saudade

Saudade (0):

TwoInAMillion (0):

ByronVilla (1):

Mumble

Garuga (3):

ByronVilla, TwoInAMillion, Gustavo

Shoshin (4):

Srceenplay, BuJaber, TehBrawlGuy, Hopkirk

Srceenplay (1):

Garuga

TehBrawlGuy (0):

Knuflanto (1):

Voyc

Not Voting(1):

Knuflanto

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch!

Day 1 deadlines expires in:

(expired on 2018-05-24 19:32:18)

Mod Notes: Eureka!

Saudade has requested replacement. I will begin searching for that replacement now.

[Gustavo]

Nobody voting for shoshin is saying that garuga is town. Garuga is day 2 lynch if shoshin flips scum. So assuming he is scum, and shoshin is his partner why would he sacrifice himself?

You want to lynch an unknown first instead of a known? Why?

I don’t really care why he did what he did. He claimed scum. Barring him being a troll, I’m willing to just roll with it and we can discuss Shoshin tomorrow. Hopefully both are scum and town is in an excellent position.

I’ll do whatever the majority decides ultimately but for now I’m fine with my vote.

[Archwing]

MusicBox replaces Saudade.