Newbie 1863: Rugby - Game Over

[Quick]

I have not read the whole game and I doubt I will.

I don't know what the claims are, but I am assuming there are some at this point.

Someone catch me up on that stuff.

[Oxy]

I don't if I have mentioned this, but there is serious cogdis between my head and my gut on teacher.

my gut is screaming town, but my head is trying to beat it into submission with logic surrounding his result and his recent read on elephant and me.

in recent games when this happens, my gut is usually right.

tl;dr im really liking flicker for today's lynch

[Oxy]

Okay, quick we're in one of two setups:
JK vs goon + goon
or
JK + tracker vs RC + goon

the JK was player NK15, who was the NK last night.
N1 he jailed Thor, preventing his night kill.
N2 he jailed ???


Teacher claimed tracker yesterday - after NK15's claim.
N1 he tracked Thor, who obviously went no where (jailed VT)
N2 he tracked Flicker, but claims no result due to being jailed.

Let me pull up the posts surrounding the claims

[Meji Fan]

I've claimed vanilla, teacher has claimed tracker, NK15 now deceased was jailkeeper

[Irrelephant11]

ummm I don't have time for a full rewind, but we're in MYLO. The claims were from Not Known 15 (confirmed jailkeeper, died N2) and teacher (unconfirmed tracker). teacher's two night results were "no movement" from Thor, who was also the jailkeep choice N1 when nobody died, and "no result" N2 (i.e. teacher says NK15 jailkept him).

There's a vote count on the last page... we've talked a lot this game day about the likelihood of teacher actually being the tracker or not, and analyzed all possible scum teams to death.

Currently, I feel pretty confident Flicker is scum, though idk for sure who her partner is. Feel free to ask me about that or anything else.

Oh also, we're

basically

confirmed at this point to have a scum in You/Meji Fan/teacher and a scum in Me/Oxy/Flicker, which is useful info.

pedit: lol apparently Meji Fan has been all game waiting for you to ask just that

[Oxy]

NK15 claim:
388, 389, 440, 443

We're all in agreement that NK was town reading teacher during D2. With that in mind, consider NK's last few posts:
698, 700, 717, 730, 736

[Oxy]

Teacher's claim
508, 511, 512

Don't get too bogged down in the math. we determined later that it was far less damning to Thor than teacher presents here. But then we lynched Thor anyway LOL (proplay)

[Oxy]

Irrelephant is my strongest town read in this game.
As a result, with you and meji not hammering, Flicker is confirmed scum fmpov.

You are my second strongest town read, leaving teacher and meji as possible partners for teacher.

I've been going back and forth between these three all of this game day, so don't ask me which it is. Gut says meji, head says teacher because of the NK's thought process at eod2. It's hard for me to imagine NK15 actually jailing teacher last night.

[Oxy]

You are my second strongest town read, leaving teacher and meji as possible partners for

Flicker.

ebwop

[Oxy]

Meji's iso is not long. I suggest you read it.

[Quick]

Votecount 3.08

Quick (2) Teacher, Meji Fan L-2
Flicker (2) Irrelephant11, Oxy L-2
Not Voting (2) Flicker, Quick

Day three deadline is Thursday May 17, 8 PM PST. (expired on 2018-05-17 20:00:00)

With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch!

[/size]

So there is one Scum in Teacher, Meji Fan and one Scum in Flicker, Irrelephant, Oxy.

From what I have seen, Oxy doesn't look too bad. So In my mind, this gives us a PoE of 2 Scum in Teacher, Meji Fan, Irrelephant and Flicker.

Teacher claimed Tracker AFTER the JK claim, correct? And furthermore, Teacher claims to have been JK.

Did the JK leave any crumbs on who they would be JKing?

[Quick]

OK, I have to go to therapy in like 3 min. So I will be back at 4:00 PM CST.

[Oxy]

Did the JK leave any crumbs on who they would be JKing?

Read the following posts. They are the closest we have to crumbs.
We're all in agreement that NK was town reading teacher during D2. With that in mind, consider NK's last few posts:
698, 700, 717, 730, 736[/quote]

[teacher]

In post 822 I argue that his last words confirm that I was Jailkept. But that was only an after-the-fact interpretation. Prior to that, I read his last words as saying Nauci would be Jailkept.

@Elephant: I didnt mean for it to be suspenseful. Im moving to Flicker tonight at 9pm NY time. Im stalling because I havent been dialed in so want you to check that there arent issues.

[Oxy]

Did the JK leave any crumbs on who they would be JKing?

Read the following posts. They are the closest we have to crumbs.

We're all in agreement that NK was town reading teacher during D2. With that in mind, consider NK's last few posts:

698, 700, 717, 730, 736

ebwop

[Oxy]

oh man, we're actually going to win this game. It was looking doubtful for a while.

teacher voting flicker will confirm team to be meji + flicker

[Meji Fan]

Its probably just going to prove it's you and quick, since it's apparently not quick and teacher

[Oxy]

Its probably just going to prove it's you and quick, since it's apparently not quick and teacher

you played well! This was a great game for the strategy you employed.

[teacher]

VOTE: Flicker. @Elephant, for the record, if I lose I blame you (but if I win, Oxy may take the credit )

Regardless, this has been a very fun game.

[Oxy]

Could you place your vote in a less scummy manner next time? I'm sitting here just waiting to find out that this was all a teacher + meji slooow roll

[Oxy]

wtf is all of this 'I' shit like you're not a part of town

[teacher]

Sorry, was looking to have fun and blaming Elephant if it turns out right that I nailed Quick-Oxy SE team but couldnt get the votes.

I will unvote if youd rather. The kids get back in from sports in 10 though, so let me know soon.

[Oxy]

no dont unvote

[Meji Fan]

I'm not voting Flicker

[Oxy]

I don't actually think that scum!teacher voting scum!flicker makes a post like that.

And I don't believe you slow rolled me