Mini 2011: Partition Mafia (Game Over)

[BuJaber]

(We lynch group 2 in this scenario obviously)

[dramonic]

It's a fucking bus driver with flavor, there's nothing bastardy about it.
Holy fuck just... stop.

[dramonic]

It should not be pulling teeth to lynch the fucking cop guilty.

[Kokichi Oma]

You can switch me out for someone is group 3, i'm fine with that

[DeasVail]

im heading home now so ill wait til i get to my computer before looking at that. talk about your hf read in the mean tine

I have played with Fitz quite a few times and this /feels/ like scum-Fitz to me, but I’ll also try and be logical.

The focus on you “policy lynching” me was weird. It lasted a bit too long and the thing about you being more suspect for denying it seemed like trying a bit too hard to maintain the push.

A lot of what he’s saying about what we should do this game day is based around what would make sense based on what other people are saying rather than what he himself actually thinks.

He also sounds like robotic scum Fitz to me and is doing the scum Fitz thing of talking about options instead of true content.

[riku]

So, are we gonna lynch 2 or not?

[dramonic]

The guilty is
[BuJaber, Wisdom, Kokichi, Pine, Riku]

It's not
[BuJaber, Wisdom, Muffin, Pine, Riku]
It's not
[BuJaber, Dramonic, Kokichi, Pine Riku]
It's not
[Cakez, Wisdom Kokichi, Pine, Riku]
It's not
[BuJaber, Wisdom, Kokichi, RMOJ, Riku]

It's [BuJaber, Wisdom, Kokichi, Pine, Riku].
You don't fuck up the guilty for the lolz because you think you're better than facts.
You lynch the group as is and you get your scum lynch

Fucking Christ, and I though I had an ego.

[BuJaber]

Bus driver is so different wtf

In a game where scum have all the power in deciding who goes in which group, giving them the power to change their mind during the day seems cruel and op to me. That is why it's bastardy.

The ONLY reason to give this role to scum would be to fuck with town into falsely townreading the player. It's bastardy.

[BuJaber]

One of them might be lying but I just can't fathom how actually giving scum this role is acceptable by anyone.

[Kokichi Oma]

So, what are you even saying. If you think I'm scum why do you believe my guilty result?

[DeasVail]

Bus driver is so different wtf

In a game where scum have all the power in deciding who goes in which group, giving them the power to change their mind during the day seems cruel and op to me. That is why it's bastardy.

The ONLY reason to give this role to scum would be to fuck with town into falsely townreading the player. It's bastardy.

If scum don’t have any roles like that then the game can be easily broken.

[zMuffinMan]

I think it's unlikely that scum would do something as conspicuous as softing a PR and risking negative attention /at at time/ when people are talking about the setup possibly being mountainous

i'm reading this completely differently to you because i'm almost certain that eddie picked up on me soft-claiming something on like p2 or whatever it was. it means nothing to me because i expect he already knew i had a role, just not specifically what role. also not sure why you think scum wouldn't do that or why you think people react badly to soft-claims (unless the meta has changed drastically in the past 2 years, this never happens - at best they're null)

i don't really agree with the point about #641, mostly because i think those look like seem-like-im-doing-something questions

is this everything to the read?

[Kokichi Oma]

I think I'm just going to ignore Dramonic because he's just spewing out conf bias crap, because he scumread me early and doesn't want to be wrong.

[dramonic]

I don't.

However
If I'm wrong, there is scum in group 2.
If I'm right, there is scum in group 2.

[dramonic]

This is literally the opposite of confirmation bias. It's fact bias <_<

[DeasVail]

Well not easily but I think it would be giving town too much power.

PEdit: not everything but those were the things that most stood out to me.

[BuJaber]

Bus driver is so different wtf

In a game where scum have all the power in deciding who goes in which group, giving them the power to change their mind during the day seems cruel and op to me. That is why it's bastardy.

The ONLY reason to give this role to scum would be to fuck with town into falsely townreading the player. It's bastardy.

If scum don’t have any roles like that then the game can be easily broken.

How so.. put 1 confirmed town with scum tomorrow. Force them to lynch them and kill the other confirmed town with your 1 shot.

It's not broken and town can still lose.

[Kokichi Oma]

I shouldn't have even used my shot, this is stupid.

[DeasVail]

Muffin what is your read on Eddie?

[dramonic]

Bus driver is so different wtf

In a game where scum have all the power in deciding who goes in which group, giving them the power to change their mind during the day seems cruel and op to me. That is why it's bastardy.

The ONLY reason to give this role to scum would be to fuck with town into falsely townreading the player. It's bastardy.

It's like you think partitioning is bad for town.
It makes scum way easier to lynch.
Then again, there are people like you who don't want to lynch confirmed scum, so...

[DeasVail]

Bus driver is so different wtf

In a game where scum have all the power in deciding who goes in which group, giving them the power to change their mind during the day seems cruel and op to me. That is why it's bastardy.

The ONLY reason to give this role to scum would be to fuck with town into falsely townreading the player. It's bastardy.

If scum don’t have any roles like that then the game can be easily broken.

How so.. put 1 confirmed town with scum tomorrow. Force them to lynch them and kill the other confirmed town with your 1 shot.

It's not broken and town can still lose.

I disagree

[zMuffinMan]

Muffin what is your read on Eddie?

copout, but i don't have a read on him

his grand reveal about the reason he's been pushing group 3 all game was unimpressive. nothing he's done so far looks like something i couldn't also see from scum. the unhelpful "i'm doing my own thing, fuck your questions" style is boring (#nothypocritical) so i'm just going to leave him in my poe pool for now. i might actually go back and read through his ISO at some point tonight because i honestly can't remember anything he's done this game outside of saying 'vote g3' and the claim stuff

[zMuffinMan]

he's like where i am for you for me

[zMuffinMan]

The focus on you “policy lynching” me was weird. It lasted a bit too long and the thing about you being more suspect for denying it seemed like trying a bit too hard to maintain the push.

ok. talk about your read progression on pine. because in your initial catch-up, i don't remember you mentioning him, but he's been doing this all game

[zMuffinMan]

rereading #530 in the context of how he's played, it's not as bad as i thought it was and i'm ok with it (even though i think it's a pretty dumb reason) (the "unfortunately" at the end seemed mildly town too, i suppose)