Mini 2011: Partition Mafia (Game Over)

[Wisdom]

A scumflip why?
I accounted for every team possible

[northsidegal]

nonsensical tunneler

yet somehow nobody can ever explain how I don't make sense

i don't even know what the reasons

for

you scumreading me are outside of "you're pushing bujaber and PoE".

lmao
Its not like ive explained why every team without you is not a thing

your assumptions about what scum would and wouldn't do, especially when it comes to the partitions, are faulty.

you're doing the equivalent of what is really lazy NKA or VCA to conclude that multiple permutations of scumteams are impossible.

that's really all it comes down to - what you think scum would or have done does not match up to what scum actually have done. i'm not sure why it's so

incredibly

unrealistic to you that scum would have a different thought process than you when it comes to evaluating things like the partition. that's just theory of mind.

[Eddie Cane]

you did. unfortunately theres too many variables with 3 scum alive for it to ever be feasible. wifom explanations yhat are relatively sensible are gonna be wrong sometimes.

you are a player competent as xcum. you should know how easy it is to case literally anything you want. logic finds ways to explain things, and memory will leave you remembering the times you were right so it spirals. anyone good at xcum really shouldn't have that kind of holes in their town games my guy <3

[Eddie Cane]

wisdom, you've managed to make yourself extremely town by self voting and not backing down at l-2 or finding an excuse to vote g2. if you're xcum props to you. if not, you really need to get your head out of the clouds. get to the point where I'm town, and if you have time to psot 600 times you have time to iso me, and then we can talk about nsg. you have quite literally said from my pov g3 is the best lunch so I dont gwt eh you're so shocked I'm fighting g1.

[Eddie Cane]

do you understand what I'm saying? at all?

[Wisdom]

partitioning is not like voting or killing

You can vote or kill someone for wifom, and if it backfires, oh well, you can fight it. Partitioning in a certain way and having it backfire can instantly cost the game.

You cant tell me that muffin puts himself with eddie and kokichi for wifom when thats the group that will get lynched 95% of the time.
You cant tell me fitz and realmen risk the game on g3 not getting lynched given the gamestate.

[northsidegal]

You cant tell me that muffin puts himself with eddie and kokichi for wifom when thats the group that will get lynched 95% of the time.
You cant tell me fitz and realmen risk the game on g3 not getting lynched given the gamestate.

you don't know what their thought processes would be like - perhaps fitz and realmen thought that the whole you/eddie thing would spill over to today, especially after everyone in day 1's group 3 flipping town. i'm not sure - my point is, the reasoning i've seem from you has all been from your own perspective, and so will diverge from what other people as scum actually would have done. your view of the "gamestate" isn't necessarily the same as what scum's might have been.

[Eddie Cane]

do you understand what I'm saying? at all?

[Kokichi Oma]

I'm gonna catch up now, its been a few pages in only a few hours wtf

[zMuffinMan]

eddie, do you think all 3 scum are in G3? or are you just being extra wary of me?

[Kokichi Oma]

My post continued: Meaning that pre switch we had some combination of 1/2/0 split or 0/3/0 split.

The combination of putting 1 scum in each group AND 1 of each of the guilty pool in each group is implausible to me and eddie being a mover. It is a very bad strategy imo and I don't think any of the living players are bad enough to think it's the way to go.

-pedit fine VOTE: unvote

Consider my vote on g1 for the time being.

What? 0/3/0? I don't understand why just because wisdom townreads you means you think he's town. it's lazy.

[Eddie Cane]

eddie, do you think all 3 scum are in G3? or are you just being extra wary of me?

much more the latter. tiny bit the former.

[Kokichi Oma]

i dont agree with you being town so no

Again, tell me what non-nsg scumgroups make sense and why.

kok / fitz / roj

technically, muffin over one of them but nsgs more likely to be scum than muffin


I'll do group 1 if 3 wont get the support but 3 is safer

This is why you're scum. You realize 3 would be that 2 people HAVE to be scum in it. There is no way you're that dense.

[Eddie Cane]

stop distancing man it gets me less town cred from bussing you

[Kokichi Oma]

btw, NSG should really be voting G3 atm if she thinks wisdom is town. in any world where it's eddie+me+someone in G3, the game would be over now

i've been saying all day that i think three is the best lynch choice. i haven't been voting out of just an aversion to voting early in lylo, but -shrug-

seems like the game will be ending soon anyways

VOTE: group 3

NSG, I think you're town so hopefully you've unvoted by the time I've caught up.

[northsidegal]

NSG, I think you're town so hopefully you've unvoted by the time I've caught up.

ironic.

Kokichi, you keep saying that voting group 3 is a scumclaim - in what way? explain it to me, please.

[Kokichi Oma]

If we lynch 1 scum 1 town

We're down to 4 town 2 scum so we can afford to lynch 1 townie tomorrow right?

I think? Are we sure maf only get 1 kill? I saw eddie say this. The odds of scum being a 1 shot vig or anything isn't out of the question, I guess.

[Kokichi Oma]

Imagine I died overnight or got lynched yesterday

You would now be citing that I was townreading Kokichi and nsg

We dont even know if they would currently still have those reads

That's funny considering that if it wasn't for you we would have at least one scum dead right now.

[zMuffinMan]

If we lynch 1 scum 1 town

We're down to 4 town 2 scum so we can afford to lynch 1 townie tomorrow right?

I think? Are we sure maf only get 1 kill? I saw eddie say this. The odds of scum being a 1 shot vig or anything isn't out of the question, I guess.

no...

scum get a single factional kill

it's in the rules

[northsidegal]

no, that's definitely not a thing.

[northsidegal]

NSG, I think you're town so hopefully you've unvoted by the time I've caught up.

ironic.

Kokichi, you keep saying that voting group 3 is a scumclaim - in what way? explain it to me, please.

hey kokichi i'm p-editing you with this please respond to it before you do the rest of your catchup

[northsidegal]

muffinman, you're being kind of concise. what are you thinking right now?

[zMuffinMan]

that i'm busy but i'm just about to head to lunch

and you guys are really spammy (#nothypocritical)

[Kokichi Oma]

Wisdom she's good... I actually am more convinced that she's scum after I started voting g1 than before but I feel bad about lynching her.

I am not good as scum.

People seem to have this idea but i literally have no idea where it comes from and i hate it more than anything.

Why do you utterly refuse to read and force me to keep bashing this against your skull?

Please literally read anything that i'm talking about.

To be fair, when she was SK or maf (i dont remember which one) in the Not_mafia game. she was way more quiet than she is now. Which is why I TR her here.

[zMuffinMan]

eddie, do you think all 3 scum are in G3? or are you just being extra wary of me?

much more the latter. tiny bit the former.

if it helps, i'm town

i probably wouldn't lie about this