Open 728: Sharing is Caring (GAME OVER)

[Mathdino]

I think I'm pretty satisfied with the day
VOTE: jjh927

Welcome to the beginning of the end of the beginning

Consolidate wagons, people

[Almost50]

Sharing is Caring D1 VC #18

jjh927 (5): northsidegal, the worst, pinturicchio, ruru, Mathdino,
HeWhoSwims (3): davesaz, ofrhz, BlackStar,
the worst (2): HitAlt, jjh927,

Not Voting: Something_Smart, Zoronos, HeWhoSwims,

(expired on 2018-06-06 23:00:00)

Knock! Knock!
Who’s there?
Robin.
Robin who?
Robin you, Now hand over the cash!

[Mathdino]

Is there anything else that needs to happen today? Anything you guys want me to actually read?

Decent chance I get killed but I'm here all night folks

[northsidegal]

what's your read on hewhoswims?

[Mathdino]

Not town

Gut says not scum with jjh though so decent lynch contender tomorrow in the worst case

Someone should meta read him if he has scum meta

He feels like he's tonereadable but I'm not the one to be doing that

[pinturicchio]

I've played with scum!HWS. I don't feel the same way I felt in that game about him, and I was the one who caught him there. I've not said a lot about that issue because I was biased (I was the Jailkeeper and stopped his shot and I got pretty convinced that that was what happened, since there was a Doc claim too), so maybe my metaread is not as solid as I wish it was... But is definetely enough to push jjh instead of him

[Zoronos]

I’m super low availability at the moment:
Math: my notes have odds of scum JJH+the worst being low odds. Did your read on the worst change or is this a compromise towards wagon unification?

[northsidegal]

Math: my notes have odds of scum JJH+the worst being low odds. Did your read on the worst change or is this a compromise towards wagon unification?

i'm interested to hear why.

[northsidegal]

why you have them being partnered at low odds, that is.

[ruru]

For the record I read somewhere in HWS's meta that he often gets mislynched as town

[northsidegal]

For the record I read somewhere in HWS's meta that he often gets mislynched as town

is that true?

i might have to adjust how i read him, then.

[ruru]

I think it was in post-game or twilight of a newbie game where he was town, I forget the specifics

[Zoronos]

why you have them being partnered at low odds, that is.

The parked cross votes most of the day.
I thought HWS and the worst were more likely partners if HWS is scum. HWS seemed to subtly be shading the worst around when HitAlt was talking about his partner theories while HWS was still on ofrhz.

Family is in town this weekend so I’m going to around late night or brief phone posts, so no handy post links until later tonight.

[northsidegal]

meh, i thought a few of their interactions looked specifically like scum theater, but i guess this is probably a conversation that's better had after we've actually had a flip.

[Mathdino]

Math: my notes have odds of scum JJH+the worst being low odds. Did your read on the worst change or is this a compromise towards wagon unification?

I have them at equal odds of being scum independently so I don't really care about unpacking that associative

NSG thought they were bussing earlier so

[Zoronos]

She did? I must missed that.

Huh, my mental picture of your read state did not include that suspicion Math. I’m a bit surprised.

[Mathdino]

I never stopped scumreading jjh
I just wanted to see what would happen if I pushed TW instead

[Zoronos]

Likely my bias showing through. I’ve thought of JJH and the worst being incompatible scum partners, but if you think it’s possible they’re cross bussing I can understand how it would be possible to hold that viewpoint.

[jjh927]

I got prodded and you guys are being dumb

I had a particularly difficult exam yesterday

[jjh927]

I could full on case the worst here but I'm done writing essays, at least for a bit. Maybe tomorrow

[jjh927]

NSG is being surprisingly incompetent from my pov, the worst is scum, mathdino should know better, IDK shit about ruru



Pintu- what's different about me here than in noir

[northsidegal]

NSG is being surprisingly incompetent from my pov, the worst is scum, mathdino should know better, IDK shit about ruru

what about my play has been incompetent, even from your own point of view?

are you saying that you've played to your town meta this game such that a knowledge of it would mean that i would be townreading you?

[jjh927]

I'm saying that your two real votes are wrong and you've been tunneling those reads

[northsidegal]

no, i really haven't been tunneling them, at least not in the sense of screaming for people to follow me.

you didn't answer my question about whether or not my vote is reasonable from my perspective. you saying that my vote is wrong just from your perspective is meaningless - if you're going to say that i'm being incompetent, then my vote has to be unreasonable, it can't just be wrong.

like, let's posit that there was some "theoretical scumgame" and a person played exactly to it, even if they were town. would you call someone who voted that person incompetent just for being wrong even if their reasons were right?

[northsidegal]

even from your own perspective of (theoretically) knowing that you're town, unless you think there are reasons that from

my

perspective i should be townreading you and i'm just not seeing those reasons, you can't say that i'm being incompetent for just being wrong. i'm not psychic.