Mini Normal 2012: Tropical Mafia [Endgame]

[Mumble]

Why do you think JarJar was the NK?

Also, answering a question with a question is annoying and sets it up so that you don't have to take a stance, so I'm giving you scumpoints for it.

[texcat]

Why do you think JarJar was the NK?

Could have been done because scum was scared that JarJar would have made a hard push on Dredd and been successful. Could have been because scum wanted to setup Dredd and have us believe my aforementioned statement. Could have been a random kill. Could have been for some other unknown reason.

I don't know why, and I don't see how speculating on it is helpful.

I obviously don't know why either, but I don't see the harm in speculating about it. And I get to see reactions to the speculation. While it's far from conclusive, I don't think we should ignore the bits of information that scum give us.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

@Mumble: Let's talk about a hypothetical world where you and I are confirmed townies. Who are the 3 scums?

[Mumble]

I obviously don't know why either, but I don't see the harm in speculating about it. And I get to see reactions to the speculation. While it's far from conclusive, I don't think we should ignore the bits of information that scum give us.

Then which one do you think is most likely, since you want to speculate?

[Mumble]

@Mumble: Let's talk about a hypothetical world where you and I are confirmed townies. Who are the 3 scums?

Havo/tex/fitz

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Not sure about fitz here, but I agree on the former 2

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

I would rather tex first though. Tex > Havo >> Gustavo is my current lynch order

[bacy]

i think we should be lynching in havingfitz/havo/judge today

So I assume you're town reading Texcat?

and the ones not on that list?

poe more than anything really. she's likely the next scum if one of those three arent

[bacy]

Not sure about fitz here, but I agree on the former 2

why are you not sure about fitz? are you townreading him?

[Havo]

How about that mass claim?

Anyone want to argue against it?

[bacy]

if someone has any info they should definitely come out with it but otherwise meh doesn't help us much now that I think about it really

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Not sure about fitz here, but I agree on the former 2

why are you not sure about fitz? are you townreading him?

Nit a strong read, but yes. This is likely his town play.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

if someone has any info they should definitely come out with it but otherwise meh doesn't help us much now that I think about it really

Fuck me! Alright. I probably should have let it run and see if there was a Doctor. Otherwise; I'm dead meat and you guys have a mountain to climb, but here goes:

I'm a parity cop. The way my role works is I submit ONE TARGET every night, and I get told if this target is aligned with the

directly previous

target or not (that's close enough paraphrasing without actually quoting, I think).

Anyway, Jodax targeted Mumble. Obviously this alone means nothing because there's no previous target.

Then I took over and after what happened in D2 I decided Shoshin was a good check. They came back as aligned with Mumble. (Check my posts of the previous day where I believe I strongly hinted that they were of the same alignment, so if Shoshin had flipped red I would have known Mumble is too).

Last night I targeted texcat, and she is

not aligned

with the previous target (Shoshin).

That's why I've been trying to push for her lynch today, but I was also hoping I won't have to out which would have given me a good chance to get another result (I don't think any sane scum would have shot me here, and especially not over Mumble whom I now know is town).

So, if there's a Doctor out there they should be on me tonight so I can deliver another result.. or maybe they should protect Mumble and we take our chances. I mean, obviously don't say who you'd be protecting. Let's keep the scum team on their toes.

If there is no Doctor though... GOOD LUCK!

VOTE: texcat

[texcat]

That's just a lie.

VOTE: Dredd

[texcat]

Town should be careful voting me here. One vote and scum can hammer me.

[Mumble]

I'm inclined to believe Dredd, but I want to hear what others have to say.

texcat, why did you want to vote me prior to Dredd's claim?

[texcat]

It is mostly your D1 interactions with Shoshin.

[Mumble]

I'm going to need more than that. What specifically?

[texcat]

I'm too lazy to go back and reread and quote when you are no longer my top pick for scum. But my general thoughts were that both you and Gustavo were going after Shoshin. I think one of you must be scum, and I think it's you because you backed off some and Gustavo just hardheadedly pushed on.

@mod

What's happened to Gustavo btw?

[havingfitz]

If it wasn't apparent I'm not engaged in mafia much over the weekends. I might try to do some reading today but probably won't post thoughts until tomorrow soonest. If I've missed anything directed at me I'll try to respond asap.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Oh, God! Looks like we lost already. God help you, Mumble. You'll need much more than just luck to nail the other 2 scums.

[bacy]

I think dredd's claim is believable enough at this point. Also if texcat was town I'd expect much more resistance from her..

[texcat]

Dredd is lying.

[bacy]

Oh, God! Looks like we lost already.

God help you, Mumble. You'll need much more than just luck to nail the other 2 scums.

nothing really that significant has happened between your claim and that post here, what made you say

that?

[bacy]

Dredd is lying.

posts like that dont convince me one bit tho :/