SUPP 2017 MAFIA: COMPLETE

[Srceenplay]

@fire Taly a 0? I was going to give them a 8-10

@maria. PP a 10. I thought the consensus was the lower half?

[TehBrawlGuy]

You guys blown the thread up during my drive today.

Probably to tired to read and absorb anything.

Do we all want to post how we are voting before end of day?
It might help us figure out who is getting offed at night before it happens.

I think this is only a good idea if we agree to two lynches. If we don't fully commit to a pseudolynch, it hurts more than it helps.

[Chara]

Ratings are hard to figure out because I need to find where to put my townreads, the people I want alive, the people I want dead, and the people I sr.
change PP to a 10

why? even if he's town, he's never getting killed with a high ranking, or investigated. now that he's claimed his ability, ranking him high is nothing but unhelpful unless you're just absolutely certain he's town and don't care about his role.

[Fire Assassin]

Claim doesn't =ali
look fhr the way they claimed that's what's important not the claim itself.
Also I hope I'm not the only one openly lying about rankings here

Why would you tell us your lying about rankings and hoping people are lying MariaR lol.

[Srceenplay]

I’m not catching up tonight. Zoning out as I try.
Been on the road since 6:30am and checked into hotel at 10pm.

Going to read some manga and pass out.

[MariaR]

@fire Taly a 0? I was going to give them a 8-10

@maria. PP a 10. I thought the consensus was the lower half?

Eh PP is prob town
my rankings aren't gonna be 100% honest because I refuse to believe scum doesn't have a power to influence votes
Pedit: Why would I care about his role

[Srceenplay]

You guys blown the thread up during my drive today.

Probably to tired to read and absorb anything.

Do we all want to post how we are voting before end of day?
It might help us figure out who is getting offed at night before it happens.

I think this is only a good idea if we agree to two lynches. If we don't fully commit to a pseudolynch, it hurts more than it helps.

I don’t see how.
If anything it shows us what direction we are heading going into night.
That’s a lot better than going blind and it forces some accountability.

[Chara]

Eh PP is prob town
my rankings aren't gonna be 100% honest because I refuse to believe scum doesn't have a power to influence votes
Pedit: Why would I care about his role

because it exists? but if you think he's town, you answered my question already.


pedit: what does knowing who'll die at night help us do?

[MariaR]

his role doesn't mean shit *yawn*

[TehBrawlGuy]

Claim doesn't =ali
look fhr the way they claimed that's what's important not the claim itself.
Also I hope I'm not the only one openly lying about rankings here

i'm aware, but when someone I already had reservations about claims a perfect scum role, that definitely does not ease my suspicions
(ftr, though I think the circumstances around the claim make it even worse, as I laid out in my other post)

[Fire Assassin]

How can I convince you all that Espeonage is scum and needs 0s?
Ill take a 0 if thats what it takes.

[Espeonage]

Hey Espeonage, you "scumread" me. Why have you only been making comments to other people about scumreading me but not engaging with me? Or even addressing my scumcase on you.

I specifically used the word scum lean. Everything is slight in magnitude right now.

But sure, gimme the cliffnotes and I'll see if I care.

[MariaR]

How can I convince you all that Espeonage is scum and needs 0s?
Ill take a 0 if thats what it takes.

Fake.

Anyway going to bed

[TehBrawlGuy]

You guys blown the thread up during my drive today.

Probably to tired to read and absorb anything.

Do we all want to post how we are voting before end of day?
It might help us figure out who is getting offed at night before it happens.

I think this is only a good idea if we agree to two lynches. If we don't fully commit to a pseudolynch, it hurts more than it helps.

I don’t see how.
If anything it shows us what direction we are heading going into night.
That’s a lot better than going blind and it forces some accountability.

How does it force any accountability? There's nothing preventing the scumteam from just lying about their actual rankings.

[Fire Assassin]

How can I convince you all that Espeonage is scum and needs 0s?
Ill take a 0 if thats what it takes.

Fake.

Anyway going to bed

No you aren't nerd.

[Chara]

Fire, your problem with Taly is he's asking surface-level questions he should know the answer to. my answer is i've seen Taly ask more questions than necessary as town so it isn't going into my read of him. what's the problem?

pedit: obvious, but i agree with Brawl. was scumreading Penguin before the claim. even if i entirely disregard it, i still scumread him.

[TehBrawlGuy]

Eh PP is prob town
my rankings aren't gonna be 100% honest because I refuse to believe scum doesn't have a power to influence votes
Pedit: Why would I care about his role

because it exists? but if you think he's town, you answered my question already.


pedit: what does knowing who'll die at night help us do?

it helps the scumteam strategically rank to try and kill off the players they want, rather than who the town wants

it absolutely does not help the town at all unless we vote in a strong enough bloc to prevent scum from altering the results

[Fire Assassin]

Slight scum read huh. Thats interesting. Don't want to commit now?

[Chara]

i like Brawl for town again. :>

pedit: i like Brawl for town x2 for the way he answered that, but also i wanted Srceen to have to answer before you did for him.

[Espeonage]

Slight scum read huh. Thats interesting. Don't want to commit now?

I literally said this a few pages ago. -.-

[TehBrawlGuy]

i like Brawl for town again. :>

pedit: i like Brawl for town x2 for the way he answered that, but also i wanted Srceen to have to answer before you did for him.

i know, but I care less about your read on Screen than I do very forcefully making sure Town does not fuck this up by giving too much info to Scum (sorry!)

[Fire Assassin]

Fire, your problem with Taly is he's asking surface-level questions he should know the answer to. my answer is i've seen Taly ask more questions than necessary as town so it isn't going into my read of him. what's the problem?

pedit: obvious, but i agree with Brawl. was scumreading Penguin before the claim. even if i entirely disregard it, i still scumread him.

Just that you told me you saw genuine posts by him and than I ask you for them and you tell me that "anything can be faked" was mildly annoying to tell you the truth.

[Fire Assassin]

Slight scum read huh. Thats interesting. Don't want to commit now?

I literally said this a few pages ago. -.-

I missed that, what changed specifically?

[Chara]

Just that you told me you saw genuine posts by him and than I ask you for them and you tell me that "anything can be faked" was mildly annoying to tell you the truth.

like i already explained, i wasn't saying "Taly sounds very genuine", and if i did, it wasn't what i meant.

i was saying that you thought the questions were fake because they were surface level, while i've known Taly to ask lots of 'surface' questions as either alignment, so i didn't think they had to be fake.

[Fire Assassin]

Where is the worst?