NY214: Project Pinecone (Game over! Town wins!)

[Raskolnikov]

The lurk out the wagon until people get bored strats...

[the worst]

so this means we're prolly wagoning scum
yaey

[Raskolnikov]

nah not actually that reliable to read into but fuck

[the worst]

it's prolly too early to call but I feel ok about the gamestate rn

[Taly]

I'll like the gamestate more when we've got 2 scum dead.

[Skygazer]

I

haven't

heard Town say they'd be

"fine with being a mislynch"

in a game where Town wins.

I

have

heard Scum say they'd be

"fine with being a mislynch"

in a game that Town wins.

So I'm not swayed by

Sky's

recent posting over her alignment.

I will say that 1808 is a good reminder for me to ISO

profii

individually, I'll probably get to that tomorrow if everyone's too slow to cast a vote on

Elbirn

.

That's fair, probably not a strategically sound play as town to be willing to roll over and take the mislynch. I mean I have come to terms with the fact that I'll probably be lynched if/when elbirn flips scum (well, maybe even regardless of the flip) but I'll continue to scumhunt now that we have info.

I don't really see the activity meaning much one way or the other, it is Saturday after all.

[Andrius]

it is Saturday after all.

p. much this.

[profii]

Gonna do a catch-up after lunch but I’m miles behind

Are there any confirmed truths that I should know so my narrative is right as I go through

[xyzzy]

VOTE: Elbirn

[Taly]

L-2

[Taly]

Someone talk to me about

Andrius

and

MOI

[the worst]

Someone talk to me about

Andrius

and

MOI

s/s or t/t maybe? like I really don't like either of them but a clear is a clear

[the worst]

and I'm not sure how I feel about scummmMoI shoving people off the dram wagon d1 then hard clearing another scumbud d2 lol

[MagnaofIllusion]

I'll be doing a catch-up today ... my life is busy and this thread is too active so probably I'm just going to end up doing a State of the Game post unless there are specific questions I have missed in my brief phone skimming.

[Taly]

I'll be doing a catch-up today ... my life is busy and this thread is too active so probably I'm just going to end up doing a State of the Game post unless there are specific questions I have missed in my brief phone skimming.

1) Evaluate the

Elbirn

wagon
2) What are your thoughts on my assessments regarding

Elbirn/Sky/xyzzy/HeWhoSwims

?

[Chickadee]

Can we stop voting until people have caught up?

Myself included. A lot of the reading I’ve done has been speed reading while I’m taking a break at work. Aaaaand I’ll be leaving for work again here in a bit.

[Taly]

[Pine]

Ausuka has been prodded. It is her first offense.

[Ausuka]

HI I'M ALIVE SORRY

[Ausuka]

i'm fine with lynching elbirn.

[Raskolnikov]

Ausuka why did you choose to target me btw?

[Ausuka]

Ausuka why did you choose to target me btw?

I thought to myself "who do I not have strong thoughts on and is fairly unlikely to be lynched or nightkilled in the near future?" and I decided that you fit that category best.

[Raskolnikov]

2 loyal fruit vendor claims is so intriguing
Dramonics role logically would shut down the usefulness fairly hard
Granted now there really shouldn't be any more scum RB power though I wouldn't put a JOAT with maybe a track past it (potentially dangerous as could false inno).
Of andrius MoI ausuka I scumread mostly andrius actually but realistically if there's scum it's probably 1 of MoI Ausuka and not a MoI-Andy gambit
But even if MoI might fit the bill for his lynch preferences d1 his posts read fairly convincing as to him trying to gamesolve I think
Has anyone here played with scum MoI ftr?

[Raskolnikov]

In game like this a scum fruit vendor can just be scum fruit vendor, brassherald could just be actually scum BP, and whatever hitalt is could even be scum detective
it's hard to put anything into perspective unless or until maybe a day 4 or 5 massclaim where you can at least have some clue from normal balance guidelines
but until then I guess play is all there is, kills maybe indicate something given they kind of have to be in PRs as powerful as leaving that power is, and maybe maybe if lucky something will conflict with something else at some point

Normally I'd be familiar enough already with some folks to give me a head start
and then hardcore blindmeta until I got a decisive judgment on one or two people that the rest more or less falls into place, but it takes way too long to do nowadays and in a large the whole approach is probably prohibitive while the slot count is as high as it is
As an alternative ideally I'd have people I townread enough who then have other reads on other people they have a track record or reading or just high enough proficiency in general to rely on
But I suppose every game can't have a math/elli/etc or similar to do the heavy lifting
If anyone has a really strong read mostly townwards on someone they are familiar with with some decent level of insight they can offer beyond what's directly present in this game I really do want to hear it (possibly I missed such a thing too in which case just refer me to the post number), even taking townreads and cementing them further is probably useful atm

[Taly]

I highly doubt

Ausuka

is scum, and I like her rationale in 1846 because it seems not only sound judgment for a Town PR but she's furthering her own perception in the game rather than actually using her results or role to incriminate or doubtcast someone.

Ausuka's

the only person I'm familiar with in this game that I have a relatively strong townread on.

Everyone else that I'm familiar with... I'm going to need to see some flips and results before I make a concrete judgment.

I'd have several more scumreads right now if it weren't for claims. Possibly more scumreads than there are scum in this game, actually... Which is both a good and bad thing.