Newbie 1881 - Game Over

[OkaPoka]

@ff i guess what i want is a consolidated post on what you find scummy in me right now. is it still the aggro thing? is it still meta? what else?

[Quick]

I don't really have a read on Oka. I think something they are doing is Scummy and other things they are doing is incredibly Townie. Overall, I'd say Null Town (which is weaker than Town Lean for me).

[Quick]

I don't think Oka is a good choice for lynching this phase. I'd rather PRs deal with him.

[IcemanCh]

I am having second thoughts on Ice. Reason I was SRing him before is because a lot of his thought process in terms of reads is just plain wrong, but maybe he is actually just a newb and doesn't know any better.

Ex. Him saying nancy poking holes in everything is Scummy... That's actually pretty damn Townie IMO. His Thought process is overly black and white which is not something I would expect from someone playing in games with 20 PRs. I can explain this, but don't feel like it. I have a lot of experience all over the web so just trust me on this. Still, he has this kind of ignorance that I can't help comes from Town.

Seen this twice. I play TOS style mafia on a website dedicated to an MMORPG..... so... I dont feel like a newb. I consider my self somewhat decent there because I do actual reads where as the rest of the players rely mostly on night actions and TIs.

So I guess I am somewhat new but not totally new.... but everyone calls me a newb.

[WhyMafia]

I don't really have a read on Oka. I think something they are doing is Scummy and other things they are doing is incredibly Townie. Overall, I'd say Null Town (which is weaker than Town Lean for me).

What has he done that’s incredibly towny and what’s been scummy?

[Quick]

I don't really have a read on Oka. I think something they are doing is Scummy and other things they are doing is incredibly Townie. Overall, I'd say Null Town (which is weaker than Town Lean for me).

What has he done that’s incredibly towny and what’s been scummy?

Some of the questions Oka has asked have seemed very Town motivated. But what they are pushing is a bit suspect.

[nancy]

I'm going to try to avoid being around too much today because I think I've been posting too much and am still waiting for content from some people, but hi WhyMafia!!! Nice to see you again! Please keep doing things!

@Flicker real-time interactions can be fun too!

[WhyMafia]

I don't really have a read on Oka. I think something they are doing is Scummy and other things they are doing is incredibly Townie. Overall, I'd say Null Town (which is weaker than Town Lean for me).

What has he done that’s incredibly towny and what’s been scummy?

Some of the questions Oka has asked have seemed very Town motivated. But what they are pushing is a bit suspect.

Can you give examples?

[WhyMafia]

And I'm confused by how a question's push can be suspect while also being town motivated so please elaborate on that as well
@Oka sorry, didn't realize there was a post on page 25 so I'll reply to that

[WhyMafia]

While this is all going on can people tell me what they think of Eragon? Curious to see where everyone stands on that slot

[OkaPoka]

town transitioned into null transitioning into scummy because he seems passive too

[WhyMafia]

Why did you originally have him as town again?

[WhyMafia]

And you had earlier said that you had trouble scum reading anyone - you SR the two newbies who hadn't posted much - so I'm assuming you're much more fluid rn on who you want to Lynch? What changed all those opinions? Is a lack of contribution causing you to SR people?

[Quick]

I don't really have a read on Oka. I think something they are doing is Scummy and other things they are doing is incredibly Townie. Overall, I'd say Null Town (which is weaker than Town Lean for me).

What has he done that’s incredibly towny and what’s been scummy?

Some of the questions Oka has asked have seemed very Town motivated. But what they are pushing is a bit suspect.

Can you give examples?

This might sound Scummy or stupid to you, but I have to ask why you need examples.

[OkaPoka]

originalyl had eragon as town because he opened up by making a strong effort catching up and interacting with people

and i townread most people because it seemed like they were all willing to talk it out and interact
but now the doubt sets in, the worry, the panic, the fear, the hatred, the anger, the confusion?

[OkaPoka]

also people aren't doing normally town people are doing, i think i made a post on this with some examples if you want to iso

[WhyMafia]

I don't really have a read on Oka. I think something they are doing is Scummy and other things they are doing is incredibly Townie. Overall, I'd say Null Town (which is weaker than Town Lean for me).

What has he done that’s incredibly towny and what’s been scummy?

Some of the questions Oka has asked have seemed very Town motivated. But what they are pushing is a bit suspect.

Can you give examples?

This might sound Scummy or stupid to you, but I have to ask why you need examples.

Because I want to know your thought process and how you're drawing those conclusions

[WhyMafia]

@nancy what are the point of these questions, especially question number 3

trinity is town because i don't see a new player interact that much and be scum

nancy ur town because i don't see you interacting that much to be scum

stanley feels like a rational town player

---

i thought trinity might have been scum with the rvs vote thing she did on FF but i don't think so anymore, mainly because i think her not understanding it was l2 seems genuine

flicker seems a bit defensive but nothing concrete yet

former is town because reasons

---
unvoted because we are out of rvs

and ill read that eragon post later

Why would Trinity posting lead you to think she's town - Later you said her original posts were fluff and for a long time you were complaining you couldn't scum read anyone. Why did that change? Because in my POV I don't get why you shifted like that.

[WhyMafia]

That first quote shouldn't be there xD

[OkaPoka]

because to an extent interactions can point to being town but then on a revistation, i noticed a pattern.

[WhyMafia]

VOTE: Eragon

[OkaPoka]

oi

tell me how u got to that conclusion

[WhyMafia]

which conclusion ;p

[OkaPoka]

voting eragon

[WhyMafia]

I believe I talked about Eragon already -
Regarding you, I tried thinking of what I'd be thinking in your situations and I don't see anything that's purely scum motivated. Your case on Trinity seems genuine-ish even though you haven't really done the pushing & looked beyond surface-level things. I don't see you trying to convince others why you're right, but I don't think you're scum anymore

P-Edit - Read my catchups