Forgotten Hourglass [Game Over]

[Nancy Drew 39]

By the way, just for the sake of this not getting lost to the noise: I'd really like everyone's thoughts on this.

I was trying to buddy Nancy yes. What's your point?

i mean ironically its closer to a town post than a scum tell or anything like that but maria flips red

which means that she may not flip red?
but nothing else from her is really towny

also i know she's not really nice and she's a bully maybe that's why i scumread her

Eh, I'm not entirely convinced. It seems entirely reasonable to me that scum!Maria who was trying to buddy Nancy would simply say that that's what she was doing upon being accused and make the argument that it doesn't make her scum; it may be a more tenable position than trying to argue that she wasn't buddying Nancy.

------

Well, my point was that that would make you scum

Oh okay than

Glad you understand. Are we in agreement, then?

------

Do you believe that the hypocrisy that you're pointing out is more reason to believe that Dunnstral is scum? I think in and of itself hypocrisy isn't a very reliable scumtell.

It's more the amount of words he devoted to saying it that bothers me. It seemed like he needed to look like he was doing something so he decided to put a bunch of effort in explaining the pros of waiting to vote which is ultimately pretty useless and he hasn't done much since

It's not a read I'm married to he's just the player I'm most willing to vote for rn idk

That's an understandable position. In terms of other reads, what are your thoughts on Nosferatu as scum? I talked a little about my own reasoning for him being scum in 307, if you're at all interested.

Also, if you care or are in an explanatory mood, I would be interested in your thoughts on these people:

zMuffin
Brian Skies
Wisdom
Katsuki
Mylo

Nos suddenly putting a vote on me is scummy

DAMN STRAIGHT

WAIT THATS ME

@moment , what do you make of this?

Anyone have any thoughts on this?

[Moment]

And despite all those words spent on Spiffeh, I think the best place for my vote is actually on Nosferatu. His series of posts starting at 292 strikes me as forced, and I feel more confident in that actually being scum indicative than any of the other thoughts I've mentioned so far.

I'll also be keeping my eye on Mylo and MariaR.

VOTE: Nosferatu

[MariaR]

Glad you understand. Are we in agreement, then?

You find buddying people scummy than I understand why you're reading me like you are right now. Nothing I can really do to change that but do you scumread me for other reasons besides the buddying?
Pedit: Quote said stance

[Spiffeh]

I'm interested to hear your reasoning on Maria being town.

It's just gut really

My most recent completed game had scum!Maria in it and she was disengaged and pretty transparent so the fact that I feel the exact opposite on both accounts here is enough reason for me to town lean her for now

[zMuffinMan]

i believe cupcake's claim, doubt he'd lie about that again

[Nancy Drew 39]

I was contributing and I got sakura town out of that, the mod stepped in before I could get any other reads

What about Sakura's reaction to it makes you think she's town?

Her stance at the time was pro-town and before the mod said anything

What about her stance? You mean when she posted “Hurt the day”?

[Nancy Drew 39]

i believe cupcake's claim, doubt he'd lie about that again

[Sakura Hana]

In the last 12 hours we've had more content than in the previous 3 days.
Im happy.

[Moment]

Glad you understand. Are we in agreement, then?

You find buddying people scummy than I understand why you're reading me like you are right now. Nothing I can really do to change that but do you scumread me for other reasons besides the buddying?
Pedit: Quote said stance

I don't think that a town player typically devotes time to getting someone else in specific to townread them instead of trying to find scum, no. I also don't think that's an unreasonable position to take.

The pocketing attempt would be the main reason, but the way you've dealt with it also doesn't really sit well with me.

------

I'm interested to hear your reasoning on Maria being town.

It's just gut really

My most recent completed game had scum!Maria in it and she was disengaged and pretty transparent so the fact that I feel the exact opposite on both accounts here is enough reason for me to town lean her for now

Well, I'm not sure what exactly you mean by "transparent" or what that would look like, but I think "disengaged" would describe Maria decently well - at least, before today, maybe. Either way, I don't expect to be able to argue against your instict; only to show what I see that makes me feel otherwise.

[Purrcocet]

By the way, just for the sake of this not getting lost to the noise: I'd really like everyone's thoughts on this.

I was trying to buddy Nancy yes. What's your point?

i mean ironically its closer to a town post than a scum tell or anything like that but maria flips red

which means that she may not flip red?
but nothing else from her is really towny

also i know she's not really nice and she's a bully maybe that's why i scumread her

Eh, I'm not entirely convinced. It seems entirely reasonable to me that scum!Maria who was trying to buddy Nancy would simply say that that's what she was doing upon being accused and make the argument that it doesn't make her scum; it may be a more tenable position than trying to argue that she wasn't buddying Nancy.

u can buddy as town


Re:Nos

He could have rolled red and that's why the day stalled on his wagon
But I think he would actually play a scum game and not lurk

Nos suddenly putting a vote on me is scummy

DAMN STRAIGHT

WAIT THATS ME

@moment , what do you make of this?

Anyone have any thoughts on this?

lmao hes a funny guy
not scum indicative

his lack of content sucks but he could have like forgot this game was a thing
i -want- to think he puts more effort into playing his scum game but thats nai

[Spiffeh]

If Muffin doesn't do anything helpful before the end of the Day he should die sooner rather than later

[Purrcocet]

maria one sentence why do you scumread dunn

[Katsuki]

In the last 12 hours we've had more content than in the previous 3 days.
Im happy.

I'm not.

I was busy playing hangman with a friend today which has left me woefully behind in this game, and I'm not known for my abilities to catch up in games.

[zMuffinMan]

If Muffin doesn't do anything helpful before the end of the Day he should die sooner rather than later

today i saved a cat stuck in a tree

[Ankamius]

well that's not actually what I meant

but thanks

(Sorry, that was my attempt at humor; probably should've added a wink or something to get that across better!)

I think that would've just made it sound condescending

[Moment]

In the last 12 hours we've had more content than in the previous 3 days.
Im happy.

It is nice, isn't it? What I'm really glad for is that I'm here for it and not playing catch-up in the aftermath.

------

u can buddy as town

Eh.

Even if I were to accept this position - that town can buddy just like scum can - can you agree that buddying someone as your primary goal and then doing pretty much nothing else is scum-indicative?

[MariaR]

I don't think that a town player typically devotes time to getting someone else in specific to townread them instead of trying to find scum, no. I also don't think that's an unreasonable position to take.

No buddying and pocketing is 2 dif things. I was trying to buddy Nancy and get ideas off her because I townread her. If she townreads me great that's a bonus but Nancy isn't a player that town reading me or scumreading me would make me perk my brow unlike someone like maybe Dunn or Kokichi

[Sakura Hana]

his lack of content sucks but he could have like forgot this game was a thing

Probably, I mean, no one was doing anything.

i -want- to think he puts more effort into playing his scum game but thats nai

I guess no one read my posts about Nos...

[Ankamius]

Nos dropped off the face of the planet for forever in police academy and he was town

[Nancy Drew 39]

If Muffin doesn't do anything helpful before the end of the Day he should die sooner rather than later

today i saved a cat stuck in a tree

LMFAO, are you actually TRYING to get yourself lynched?



And cat lovers everywhere thank you.

[Ankamius]

I can vouch for that, I was the cat

[Sakura Hana]

Nos dropped off the face of the planet for forever in police academy and he was town

Really?
I guess im out of touch with everyone at this point.

[Purrcocet]

If Muffin doesn't do anything helpful before the end of the Day he should die sooner rather than later

today i saved a cat stuck in a tree

=^_^=

------

u can buddy as town

Eh.

Even if I were to accept this position - that town can buddy just like scum can - can you agree that buddying someone as your primary goal and then doing pretty much nothing else is scum-indicative?

are you trying to lynch her lmao cause we need to organize this wagon im js
otherwise i dont really see what the point to this approach is


@Wisdom do you still scumread spiffeh

[Spiffeh]

I predict that Wisdom is gonna still want to lynch me after he reads my posts

[Spiffeh]

He shouldn't, but he will

regardless of his alignment