I don't expect WM to have the same read, but I thought he'd completely flip flopped the read, and especially since stan1ey wasn't the only person to take issue with that post, it seemed odd that he wouldn't mention that at all.In post 1391, nancy wrote:My townread on Flicker is completely gone. Her thoughts about WhyMafia are insane. I don't think it's a remotely believable thought from town that WhyMafia should for some reason have the same reads as stan, that just looks like a super fake way to shade WhyMafia.
(Also, off-topic, but I'd appreciate it if you didn't throw the word "insane" around like this.)
If you don't understand what I meant, why not ask me about it instead of just writing it off as "nonsense"?Her read on Trinity is nonsense. "RVS weirdness that morphed into reads weirdness that doesn't feel as towny" is gibberish.
No, I was wondering why you asked that about Trinity, and not about Oka. I think it's a perfectly fair question. Also, I feel like the Trump comparison is a little below the belt.This is the rhetorical technique Trump uses, she's just trying to deconstruct any reason to townread Trinity's claim.In post 1378, Flicker wrote:What about Oka claiming VT makes sense, if he's mafia?
No and no. I thought it was notable that we went from a bunch of wagons with only one vote, to coalescing around two major wagons. You're reading way too much into my exact word usage here. I also don't know how Trinity's gonna flip, although I know I won't be able to convince you (or anyone else) of that now.The use of "interesting" here is scummy because it's a uselessly vague, throwaway comment and it shows she's not really thinking about the game. It also TMI's that she knows Trinity isn't flipping mafia.In post 1380, Flicker wrote:Definitely gonna be some interesting VCA tomorrow, I think.
I compromised and voted for Trinity, in the interest of town cohesion and getting a lynch, even if it's not the lynch I wanted. Also, FTR it was always a weak town read/lean, given that it hinged on her making mistakes that it felt like scum would be mindful not to make (essentially, Too Weird to be Scum, which doesn't feel like a super-legitimate reason IMO). And in saying my townread was gone, I was basically agreeing with Oka (and Formerfish?) that her reads were all over the place in a way that felt bad.And her votes are just so bad. She scumread Quick but voted Trinity, who she townread. And now her townread is very conveniently "gone". That makes no sense whatsoever.
Not gonna address the rest of the post, other than with this:
