Newbie 1881 - Game Over

[IcemanCh]

So I don't get it. We've a melt down because why? I'm seriously not trying to be harsh but..... I'm struggling to understand how two players voting someone means the sky is falling. Maybe, I'm just being insensitive but, I'm really trying to understand.

I'm down for a Nancy lynch or an Eragon lynch. I'm not convinced on Quick yet.

[Skygazer]

honestly even nancy's tiltedness looks town to me

i dont see scum nancy desperately trying to save trinity at the end of day two, it's an interesting progression that would be so weird for scum to make

didn't get a lot of sleep cause my foster kitties are butts so im not sure when ill do a full catchup post

[Skygazer]

Ice's progression onto nancy is super out of left field to me actually and I'm not sure what to make of it yet

[Skygazer]

There were a lot of D1 posts that I don't see scum-ice making though

[OkaPoka]

I’m not going to make a grumble rant post.

If nancy is town, she probably won’t read any of my apology posts post-game so I might as well make this post now if she is town.

Sorry nancy, sorry that I’ve been getting under your skin, I’m sorry.
I’m sorry that I’ve been pushing your buttons and just pissing you off in general to the point where it bleeds into real life. But honestly, real life takes precedent over this game. If you truly feel the way you feel, I recommend you replace out of this game. You have no obligation to play this game if this game is taking such an emotional toll on you. If you are on the verge of tears from actions that happen in this game because I misplayed, then its not worth it man. Its not worth getting so emotional over a game with people you probably will never talk to again.

Nancy, I’m just an internet stranger. I’m just some random kid over the internet when in 10 years, you won’t talk to, nor would you remember. If I’m really hurting you that much emotionally to the point where your girlfriend begs you to stop playing, then just stop playing man. I don’t know much about relationships (I’m a teenager who plays mafia in his spare time lol), but I sure as hell know that its not worth harming your relationship with people you love because of some random idiots who are playing a game. I realize you’ve invested dozens of hours into solving and playing this game, but remember this is just a game. It’s a game where we want to have fun, but you are obviously not enjoying yourself if you are getting depressed because of it. You don’t have an obligation to this game if this game is hurting you so much irl. Nancy, you are a grown ass woman with responsibilities, you have a family you need to show affection to. Me? Biggest responsibility I have is writing essays for college. I don’t matter to you in the grand scheme of things, but your girlfriend does. She loves you and you love her, why even hurt that relationship because of some kid on the internet?

Also, please don’t leave this site because of people like me. I’m a minority in this website. Yes, we are a vocal minority on this site, but we are a minority. Not everyone is an asshole like me, there are plenty more genuinely good people on this site who help make this site a beautiful website, people like you.

[OkaPoka]

on a side note im thinking about a formerfish lynch, what about everyone else?

[IcemanCh]

on a side note im thinking about a formerfish lynch, what about everyone else?

I don't think I'm anywhere near supporting an FF lynch.

[IcemanCh]

I think most of us agree on Eragon so maybe that's where we should focus and then sort the rest out tomorrow.

[Quick]

on a side note im thinking about a formerfish lynch, what about everyone else?

Uh, yas?

VOTE: FF

[OkaPoka]

VOTE: ff

doesn't look like we have enough biters on the nancy lynch so ill sit here for a day and see where it goes

[nancy]

I’m not going to make a grumble rant post.

If nancy is town, she probably won’t read any of my apology posts post-game so I might as well make this post now if she is town.

Sorry nancy, sorry that I’ve been getting under your skin, I’m sorry.
I’m sorry that I’ve been pushing your buttons and just pissing you off in general to the point where it bleeds into real life. But honestly, real life takes precedent over this game. If you truly feel the way you feel, I recommend you replace out of this game. You have no obligation to play this game if this game is taking such an emotional toll on you. If you are on the verge of tears from actions that happen in this game because I misplayed, then its not worth it man. Its not worth getting so emotional over a game with people you probably will never talk to again.

Nancy, I’m just an internet stranger. I’m just some random kid over the internet when in 10 years, you won’t talk to, nor would you remember. If I’m really hurting you that much emotionally to the point where your girlfriend begs you to stop playing, then just stop playing man. I don’t know much about relationships (I’m a teenager who plays mafia in his spare time lol), but I sure as hell know that its not worth harming your relationship with people you love because of some random idiots who are playing a game. I realize you’ve invested dozens of hours into solving and playing this game, but remember this is just a game. It’s a game where we want to have fun, but you are obviously not enjoying yourself if you are getting depressed because of it. You don’t have an obligation to this game if this game is hurting you so much irl. Nancy, you are a grown ass woman with responsibilities, you have a family you need to show affection to. Me? Biggest responsibility I have is writing essays for college. I don’t matter to you in the grand scheme of things, but your girlfriend does. She loves you and you love her, why even hurt that relationship because of some kid on the internet?

Also, please don’t leave this site because of people like me. I’m a minority in this website. Yes, we are a vocal minority on this site, but we are a minority. Not everyone is an asshole like me, there are plenty more genuinely good people on this site who help make this site a beautiful website, people like you.

You're a sweetheart. And yeah maybe I should have subbed out. But I'm not tilted anymore, I got it out of my system I guess. And it's like, not just you. It's the whole game. And this doesn't happen on other sites, like at all. Anyway sorry for losing my shit.


We should lynch Eragon. He's literally always scum unless all my reads are wrong. Oka is always town, I'm never wrong on that read in this game, iceman is like, 99% town, would bet the game on him being town, WM/Sky is also like 98% town, would also bet the game on the slot being town. Quick and FF are probably never a team, I wouldn't bet the game on that unalignment and would lynch them both before any of Sky/Ice/Oka, but I believe it enough to think that the game is exactly 1 of quick/FF + eragon and we should lynch eragon today then solve in the pair of them tomorrow.

[nancy]

So I don't get it. We've a melt down because why? I'm seriously not trying to be harsh but..... I'm struggling to understand how two players voting someone means the sky is falling. Maybe, I'm just being insensitive but, I'm really trying to understand.

I'm down for a Nancy lynch or an Eragon lynch. I'm not convinced on Quick yet.

If you think that it was because I got 2 votes then yeah you don't get it.

[Skygazer]

nancy if you end up playin mafia on a different site can i play a game or two with you there? You seem rlly cool after reading through these ~70 pages!

I might put my vote on eragon? I think I have a scum game and town game complete with him (newbie 1879 and donner party) so I might meta dive first and stuff

quick is mostly PoE at this point so I probably won't vote there today?

I don't think anyone has the scumrange to play like nancy has as town so at this point my vote is never going there

still townreading ff so my vote isn't going there rn

[Skygazer]

I would say

nancy
Ice
Oka
FF
Quick
Eragon

With nancy locktown for myself, and oka/ice pretty close together in terms of towniness level

[Quick]

I would say

nancy
Ice
Oka
FF
Quick
Eragon

With nancy locktown for myself, and oka/ice pretty close together in terms of towniness level

No offence, but it's a pet peeve of mine when people say someone is lock Town when they are not. You might think this is semantics, but I just don't like people misapplying the meaning to things..

[Quick]

@nancy- i like iceman for town, and you.

I feel like Sky could be scum just based off her reads list, but only for the slightest and most convoluted reason, so it doesnt even really play yet.

I think that Quick is scum and has been trying to play up the AtE and sympathy angles when it comes to me. Says hes trying to re-evaluate me, but doesnt really want to interact with me.

Eragon could be but that would mean that im definitely seeing a town!Oka which im just not 100% on board with yet.

So I guess I'm here

VOTE: Quick

Not really sure what gives you the indication that I am avoiding you when you've made like... how many posts between thinking I should be interacting with you and when I said I was trying to reevaluate you? It's almost as if you are trying to operate under some pre-cognition of what I am going to do or something, which I don't really like.

[Skygazer]

sorry i meant to say nancy is confirmed town

/s

[OkaPoka]

sky sorry u rolled scum

[Skygazer]

me too ):

[nancy]

Sky, make post about reads please. Reasoning.

Also, Iceman is lock town.

[nancy]

God I hate playing from my phone.

[nancy]

Also... I don't think I'm actually out of my scum range. I don't remember all of my posts and there might be points where I pass it but idts. I would even make those ate posts as mafia tbqh. I don't really have a scum range, that's not how you read me. I'm town because the way I've played would be beyond stupid if I were mafia, I could literally never end game with that day 1.

[nancy]

I need more words from WhyMafia about how his read on Oka changed and why he dropped his push to go onto Eragon because the way that played out feels like he was a spinning top that lost momentum and clinked to a halt against the tabletop and the sound of the clink is the sound I hear in my dreams when I think about scum.

Hm. I'm tempted to say this post might be out of my scum range.

I don't think it actually is, but it's probably closer than any other post I've made.

My read flip on Oka would never happen if I were mafia though. There's nothing I like more than getting into an extended 1v1 with a vocal townie to make everyone read me as town, even if I don't even want them lynched.

[Quick]

@nancy,

Is this how you want us to play? To point out how we are Town? Sorta seems somewhat semantical to say "I am Town for XYZ reasons.." *shrug*

[OkaPoka]

hey.

if you townread formerfish

why?