Hmm. What if a pool of five pick a certain player and the other ten don't want that player lynched but are dispersed in such a way that the five get a majority? Can we do a lynch count and a definitely not lynch count with one each?In post 2874, Taly wrote:If anyone has a problem with this method then they should be quick, direct, and succinct.
Corrected this for you.
Oh so you thought the Mafia have both a Jailkeeper and another blocking role?In post 2760, Almost50 wrote:The I listed a possible scenario where scum don't mind directing the vig shot on a partner bc they're going to block him anyway, or that they hope the shot goes elsewhere while they put the vig to rest. In short, there is no "secret reporter". These were just my own thoughts at the time.
You implicitly trust the outed Serial Killer to help you scum hunt by day knowing that each dead Mafia member brings him closer to PoE death? Insert Willy Wonka “Tell me about …” funny gif here.In post 2766, Almost50 wrote:Look. There are only two people here I am willing to 100% trust on xy, and one is tw. If he says to lynch xy today I'd pit my vote back on them. (Don't ask who the other one is. If I wanted to out them I would have).
So you are saying that you’ve adopted an artificial playstyle this game just like Geriatric White Flag?In post 2754, Almost50 wrote:Because that's how I decided to play this game! I hopped into a slot that was almost lynched, and my challenge is to keep my slot from being lynched. That's why I feel fine about being vigged or scum NK'd.
So it took over a thousandish posts for you and your partners to workshop a response to a case?In post 2791, Skygazer wrote:Taly has a pretty substantial case against me/A50's slot/xyzzy in 1725, 1726, and 1727 which I just finally responded to above
Scum generally dislike it when I call for their head and don’t let them dissuade me. Sorry bout your luck there buddy.In post 2758, Skygazer wrote:Don't like that MoI hasn't responded to my latest post at him, if I'm lynched seriously consider looking at him more in depth especially late game if he doesn't die
This is exactly why I said what I did. Ever since I’ve called you out on bad / poor posts you’ve been in “MoI is scum because he’s mean to me mode”. And you’ve been bending over backwards to call me scum for any reason you think can stick, despite multiple other players telling you that you are being bad. That’s irrational tunneling to a tee. Frankly I don’t bother addressing your posts because … it isn’t worth my time. I need to help lynch scum not argue with randomlikelyTowniewhoisplayingderpandgetshisfeelingshurt.com that they are being bad.In post 2857, Inferno390 wrote:I’m going to also come back to this in my ISO, but that attack on me from MoI earlier...
I was thinking about it, and I realized that I haven’t actually been “irrationally tunneling” anyone this game, nor have I had a “complete lack of logic.” However, that sounds suspiciously like some of my early games.
So in other words, that post is a very unnecessary attack on me that doesn’t actually address what I said combined with an apparent meta dive that came out of nowhere.
I don't see the problem there when the scum JK was aIn post 2878, MagnaofIllusion wrote:Oh so you thought the Mafia have both a Jailkeeper and another blocking role?
That's you sayin'. To me the duck is theIn post 2878, MagnaofIllusion wrote:You implicitly trust the outed Serial Killer to help you scum hunt by day knowing that each dead Mafia member brings him closer to PoE death?
Listen, if you're so sure I'm scum ho ahead and vote me. See if I care.In post 2878, MagnaofIllusion wrote:So you are saying that you’ve adopted an artificial playstyle this game just like Geriatric White Flag?
This is a rather curious assessment of the situation. I clearly think Aus is likely scum and haven’t been shy about saying so. Many others have expressed degrees of concern about this. And the Visitor role is not really tangential at all to the Vendor roles given it can only prove to a Tracker / Watcher Inferno’s slot didn’t make the NK.In post 2879, Almost50 wrote:I don't see the problem there when the scum JK was a Prime Numbered Nights limited. After all, we do -presumably Town- have TWO Fruit Vendors AND a Visitor, and nobody's being skeptical about those.
So you don’t see him as SK claiming the shot even when HitAlt basically guiltied him? Hmmm ….In post 2879, Almost50 wrote:That's you sayin'. To me the duck is the Town Vig, and I don't even see him claiming that shot if he was the SK. I'll give it a 5% chance he managed to fool me here, but the other 95% say he doesn't claim if he was scum and especially so if he is working alone.
OkIn post 2879, Almost50 wrote:Listen, if you're so sure I'm scum ho ahead and vote me. See if I care.
The explanation was for those who might care to learn to read me (and believe it or not there are people who have developed some way of reading me). As for you, you just won't get that I play differently in every game, and that I am fully aware of what I did in the previous game I was with you, so it's nigh impossible for me to use the same trick in your presence.
Just lynch me to verify the above-mentioned fact, and let's see if you can win the game on your own (because believe it or not, I am one of your best assets in this game still .. if you are Town that is.)
Where is that?In post 2881, MagnaofIllusion wrote:So you don’t see him as SK claiming the shot even when HitAlt basically guiltied him?
nights 2,3,5 don't seem that underpowered to meIn post 2879, Almost50 wrote:I don't see the problem there when the scum JK was aIn post 2878, MagnaofIllusion wrote:Oh so you thought the Mafia have both a Jailkeeper and another blocking role?Prime Numbered Nightslimited.
Agreed! It's close to being Odd Night. Still there's a gap there where a Non-Prime-Numbered "something" could be fitted. Again, if we have 2 VFs and a Visitors scum has to have something to counter that or we would have 2 confirmed townies each night (or a guilty instead of one). EVEN assuming the FVs are the only alignment investigatives we've got that's already overpowered. Now add a Follower and you'd see scum are defenseless if all they had was Dram's role in that department.In post 2883, Nosferatu wrote:nights 2,3,5 don't seem that underpowered to meIn post 2879, Almost50 wrote:I don't see the problem there when the scum JK was aIn post 2878, MagnaofIllusion wrote:Oh so you thought the Mafia have both a Jailkeeper and another blocking role?Prime Numbered Nightslimited.
In post 2875, Almost50 wrote:Scum are playing a splendid game by day I guess. There is NO ONE that I'mconfidentthey'd flip red.
@Taly: Seriously now.. why am I in your suspects/lynch pool still? And how would my flip help you reconsider your reads? (Hint: To save yourself some effort, just assume I am today's lynch and I flipped GREEN. So what next?)
Yeah, I don't think what I proposed earlier was a great ideaIn post 2878, MagnaofIllusion wrote:@Taly – Please don’t start some pseudo-vote project this close to deadline. It is only going to sidetrack the Town in general when we need to get a lynch complete. Pick your candidate and push them. Even if it isn’t Sky you need to narrow your focus at this stage.
I'd prefer an extended nightphase if it comes down to that.In post 2880, Pine wrote:Inferno390 is being replaced through no fault of his own. This may extend the deadline even further.
Fuck X_X Sorry againIn post 2887, Taly wrote:I'd prefer an extended nightphase if it comes down to that.In post 2880, Pine wrote:Inferno390 is being replaced through no fault of his own. This may extend the deadline even further.
I'm completely withChickadeein the sentiment that this day just needs to end.
profiiis selling himself to the rope, and I could just lynch that because it's a shitshow of WIFOM.
xyzzyisn't around whentheyshould be, buttheirbeen unhelpful.
I just forgotHWSwas in this game, so why not lynch that since scum would supposedly be demotivated and he could be scum anyway?
A50is ?????? - reasons to think they're town and scum
Skyis ?????? - reasons to think they're town and scum
I simply don't know and I already said I have no confident SRs as of yetIn post 2885, Taly wrote:Tell me who you think should be the lynch.
I do! 3 of them. I just didn't want them killed off, but seeing as they're outside the claimed PRs I don't mind saying tw, brass & Gamma are my strongest TRsIn post 2890, brassherald wrote:Do you have any confident TRs?
In post 2892, the worst wrote:I'm a prostitute
In post 2893, the worst wrote:PR***
