Forgotten Hourglass [Game Over]

[Wisdom]

Try not to lynch Sakura, Moment, Purr, Kats, or Muffin while I'm gone.

kats and muffin have no place in this list

[TehBrawlGuy]

alright matt's posts today are town as fuck

i hesitate to say I townread him just because that's at odds with my view of him for the rest of the game, but he's definitely not in my lynchpool for today anymore

WHAT GIVES YOU A STRONG SCUM READ ON CUPCAKE? IT'S NOT ENTIRELY CLEAR WHAT YOU THINK MAKES HIM SCUM OR WHY YOU FEEL SO STRONGLY ABOUT IT

WHY DID YOU THINK PURR WAS SCUM YESTERDAY AND WHAT CHANGED?

TBG I THINK YOU MISSED MY QUESTIONS TO YOU (MAYBE I DIDNT ALL MY CAPS ENOUGH?)

(you're correct, i actually did miss them)

80+ posts with shockingly little content, which is a scumtell in itself, but worse in context. I have a lot of townreads on the fairly active players, so PoE suggests the remaining ones are likely to be Scum. Katsuki, despite appearing active because of the post-spam, isn't actually contributing or stating any reads - if you could filter down to just content posts, they'd be one of the less active players.

Also, it bothers me how little shade they've gotten for the lack of content. Mylo got lynched for it, and Ank and Spiffeh have taken some, but Katsuki has gotten off really easy by comparison.

As for Purr, honestly, I don't remember much. I remember the read turning with their posts early D2. Not writing shit down and posting pictures will do that to you. I usually don't take outside notes because my posts serve that role, but I probably should've given the circumstances. I can re-read their iso if you really care?

[MariaR]

You're trying to paint a picture on how it's scummy for me to defend the mylo wagon and I'm explaining to you why I did. It's up to everyone else to decide if they think I'm scum for it or not.

[Kokichi Oma]

Btw, on the subject of "busing a mafia pr" please remember that's it's very likely every scum member has a PR, whether that was their weakest PR or not tho, there's no way to know right now.

Yeah, especially with being guaranteed a main character

[Brian Skies]

Try not to lynch Sakura, Moment, Purr, Kats, or Muffin while I'm gone.

kats and muffin have no place in this list

Nah man. They're fine.

And whatever this wagon on Muffin is, well, he probably deserves it but I'm telling you not to do it.

[TehBrawlGuy]

You're trying to paint a picture on how it's scummy for me to defend the mylo wagon and I'm explaining to you why I did. It's up to everyone else to decide if they think I'm scum for it or not.

for the record, I do agree with you

mylo lynch looked very questionable - you're lynching a player who lurks as either alignment, has made no relevant posts, and you're doing this lynch with widespread support? Obviously, we can look back with hindsight, but at the time, what does that look like? It looks like a free mislynch.

It's still not a bad lynch, because getting rid of dead weight players D1 is worthwhile, but I didn't think the odds were good Mylo was going to flip Scum.

[Dunnstral]

Btw, on the subject of "busing a mafia pr" please remember that's it's very likely every scum member has a PR, whether that was their weakest PR or not tho, there's no way to know right now.

Yeah, especially with being guaranteed a main character

What do you mean

[MariaR]

mylo lynch looked very questionable - you're lynching a player who lurks as either alignment, has made no relevant posts, and you're doing this lynch with widespread support? Obviously, we can look back with hindsight, but at the time, what does that look like? It looks like a free mislynch.

FUCKING PREACH

[Katsuki]

And whatever this wagon on Muffin is, well, he probably deserves it

A NEW FUNDAMENTAL LAW OF THE UNIVERSE

BUT UH YA LIKE ISSAC SAYS, DONT DO IT

[Dunnstral]

And whatever this wagon on Muffin is, well, he probably deserves it

A NEW FUNDAMENTAL LAW OF THE UNIVERSE

BUT UH YA LIKE ISSAC SAYS, DONT DO IT

Why not?

[Brian Skies]

Btw, on the subject of "busing a mafia pr" please remember that's it's very likely every scum member has a PR, whether that was their weakest PR or not tho, there's no way to know right now.

Yeah, especially with being guaranteed a main character

What do you mean

He's saying scum probably have a stronger PR.

[Kokichi Oma]

Btw, on the subject of "busing a mafia pr" please remember that's it's very likely every scum member has a PR, whether that was their weakest PR or not tho, there's no way to know right now.

Yeah, especially with being guaranteed a main character

What do you mean

First page says 1 main is guaranteed scum

[Wisdom]

i mean, there's a poisoner

[Brian Skies]

First page says 1 main is guaranteed scum

No it doesn't.

[Kokichi Oma]

There are three Main Characters in this game. At least one of them is aligned with Town.

Oh, I guess I read it wrong. It's one is at least town. But, that probably means one is scum at the very least.

[Dunnstral]

Yeah it doesn't say that, that's what I thought you meant

[Katsuki]

And whatever this wagon on Muffin is, well, he probably deserves it

A NEW FUNDAMENTAL LAW OF THE UNIVERSE

BUT UH YA LIKE ISSAC SAYS, DONT DO IT

Why not?

ARE YOUR EYES FOR SHOW OR DO THEY POSSESS THE FUNCTION TO READ

[Moment]

Brian, talk with me a bit. Let's say (for now) that matt is town, that Dunnstral is right about Maria, and that people can read between the lines when it comes to Katsuki and MuffinMan. Who's scum? Ankamius? Kokichi? Spiffeh?

I'm quoting this again and putting it out there to anyone.

[Dunnstral]

What does reading between the lines of katsuki and muffinman mean?

[Wisdom]

kokichi prolly

[Katsuki]

YOUR MISTAKE IS YOUR ASSUMPTION THAT DUNNSTRAL CAN POSSIBLY BE RIGHT ABOUT ANYTHING

PEDIT: @MOMENT

[Dunnstral]

So are you scumreading MariaR?

[TehBrawlGuy]

Brian, talk with me a bit. Let's say (for now) that matt is town, that Dunnstral is right about Maria, and that people can read between the lines when it comes to Katsuki and MuffinMan. Who's scum? Ankamius? Kokichi? Spiffeh?

I'm quoting this again and putting it out there to anyone.

I'm not sure what you're saying about reading between the lines on Kat and Muffin?

[Katsuki]

I WILL ALWAYS SUPPORT ISSAC ON WHATEVER CRUSADE HE WISHES TO EMBARK ON

[TehBrawlGuy]

Thinking about mylowagon - one reason that we might not have seen a counterwagon off of it is that the likely counterwagon(s) were on Scum, so there wasn't a viable non-Scum candidate. That lends some more weight to Nos being Scum, imo.