In post 2892, Spiffeh wrote:Matt's recent play seems like genuine frustration: I can see how he would believe that his not being "popular" or w/e could be leading to his lynch. I'm not hard town reading him or anything but that's enough to not want to lynch him for now.
Yeah, I can see that. And I do feel really bad for saying he was whining (feels kind of uncalled for even though that's how I felt about it at the time). I've been coming around to me just being wrong there.
In post 2892, Spiffeh wrote:Ank's play before her replace out and subsequent replace out are things I doubt she would do as scum, I'm actually hard town reading her now.
I'm not going to get into it, but I don't think her replace out there was scum-motivated.
In post 2908, Spiffeh wrote:Hi I think you're probably town and you behaving like this only gives Katsuki and Muffin's garbage/likely scum-motivated play a leg to stand on se please stop
You're right. My behavior is uncalled for and I will stop.
I will also apologize to Nancy Drew since I feel like I may have been condescending towards her even though that wasn't my intention (I'm just a condescending person, I can't help it). I think she's a swell person and she deserves better treatment than what I've given her.
In post 2920, Spiffeh wrote:Hey Brian I get why you’d have a townread on Katsuki because you protected him I guess but unfortunately Katsuki being town does not equal Katsuki telling the truth about his claim or results so can you walk me through why you believe him unconditionally?
You know the one I'm townreading is Muffins and not Katsuki, right? Also, I already explained that I didn't really care about Kats' 'cop result', but it's not like he has to be
absolutely
lying about it.
Like, I didn't even bother crumbing my night action today because of how skeptical I am of the result. I just didn't want to lynch Kats (since I do feel it's possible that he could have been shot) and Kats is technically claiming an
inno
on Muffins. And I did kind of pick up that there was a neighborhood or something going on between them earlier in the Day Phase.
But the whole idea that I don't want to lynch them because 'friendship' is just nonsensical as my townread on Muffin comes and goes (and this can be demonstrated to some degree in the game if people read my posts), and I was more than happy to wagon or lynch Kats yesterday (I just ended up really wanting to lynch Mylo).
Like, even if people read my posts today, it's mostly 'don't lynch Kats or Muffin,' not 'they're obvtown', so idk why people get this impression from me. And I've had scumreads on other players anyway.
And I don't find anything anyone's said about Kats or Muffin to be scum-indicative anyway.
Anyhow, I've been busy all day and will continue to be busy tomorrow, so I don't think I can be relied on to help push a proper wagon through. If you seriously think Muffin is scum here, then lynch him. I still don't think he's scum, but am mostly curious to just see his flip. I'm probably dying tonight, so...if you need his flip to help you figure out this game, then whatever, I guess.
Also,
unless you're scum
, then stop saying what you think scum would or wouldn't do. They're not you, so stop making that assumption.