NY214: Project Pinecone (Game over! Town wins!)

[the worst]

VOTE: profii

I'll get paranoid and tunnel profii eventually let's just get that over with

Will be using this rvs vote more tbh

[profii]

I think TW is a serial killer

Meh who needs a random votes with reads like that
*brushes shoulder*

[the worst]

Easy to selectively scumhunt when you know who 4/5 of the scum are.

as SK it's pretty easy to smell who scum are by how focused they become on you and how badly they ignore groupscum hunting

[Gamma Emerald]

Easy to selectively scumhunt when you know who 4/5 of the scum are.

as SK it's pretty easy to smell who scum are by how focused they become on you and how badly they ignore groupscum hunting

So my theory I crafted early in my mafia career was RIGHT! Mafia DO freak out about SK.

[profii]

nah I still stand by everything I said in this game

SK takes away towns choice of lynches and reduce the amount of lynches, reducing town power
scum love an SK because they reduce the amount of lynches to win the game quicker

the whole point that TW didn't want to kill scum!Sky and essentially made town get lucky is proof of that.

anyone who can NK should be removed asap - if a SK is so obvious, reducing the night kills from 2 to 1 is only pro town.

[Pine]

"Scum love an SK"

...SK kills 3/4 scumteam.

[the worst]

^ it depends entirely on the read accuracy of the SK

if you have a loose sk with either very good reads or reads you just can't gauge, put bullets in that shit asap

[Skygazer]

I wanted to but strategically I had a better chance keeping you alive for a little longer :/

[the worst]

Yeah with so much town alive it was better to roll the dice. I am fun to shoot but not THAT much fun.

[mastina]

For the record.
My stance as a serial killer is to mirror vig play.
My stance as a vig is to never shoot because fuck putting the fate of another player solely into my hands, I hate that with a passion.
Ergo.
My stance as a serial killer is to never kill, holstering the whole game.

I may break this policy if I have a need to prove my claim and I feel it'll conftown me; I may break this policy if we're on evens, no other role exists to get us on odds, and we're approaching but are definitely not AT mylo; in all other circumstances, never shoot.

[mastina]

(Also hi I reviewed this if you didn't know but I was a secondary reviewer; I did literally nothing at all so you have Firebringer to thank/blame for the review rather than me. )

[Raskolnikov]

scum pt or was it vetoed?

[Pine]

Not enough players approved it to be released.

[davesaz]

Was it disapproved, or failure to approve? If it were me modding, silence is approval.

[Inferno390]

I mean
Silence is Golden after all
Just like our fuzzy SK friend

[Pine]

Was it disapproved, or failure to approve? If it were me modding, silence is approval.

The latter. I'll post in the thread and give them two days to object.

[Skygazer]

i just dont want the world to see all the horrible things i had to say about the worst

[Jingle]

It's okay. He is the worst after all.

[Gamma Emerald]

Join my game in the mini theme queue (the worst Idea Mafia)

[Gamma Emerald]

I know I fell down a bit on the flavor this game, and for that you have my apologies.

However, if you enjoy my design aesthetics and the early flavor of this game, Aristophanes and I are in the process of designing a new theme game.

Working title: Plead Your Case
Size: 14 players*
Bastard: No, some disclosed elements
Mechanics: In the confirmation stage, everyone will submit a ranked-order list of preference to become the game’s Magistrate. The Magistrate will become a Town-aligned Treestump, with an important caveat: theirs is the only vote which matters. What the Magistrate says, goes. They have the sole power to dictate lynches, and thus all cases and arguments will be addressed to the Magistrate. They will also have power over procedure, able to set new rules and restrictions (within reason). The remainder of the players will then be issued standard roles in a typical 10:3 spread.

I just realized this is the reverse of revenge of camn

[implosion]

If you want to nominate this game or any people in it (moderator or players) for a scummy, please do!