A Story Revisited (Anything uPick): Day 6

[Wh4t]

Is it bad that I want to vote IC for his nonsensical walls?

[Innocent Children]

I'm not really getting why Gamma is town. He's done about of useless posts while either being legit angry or fake angry.

Thought process and lack of agenday type posts. I also like when he mistakenly thought I was outing Chick by analyzing the obvious. I don’t think scum would care about that.

[Nero Cain]

Is it bad that I want to vote IC for his nonsensical walls?

almost as bad as your meatless posts.

[Innocent Children]

Is it bad that I want to vote IC for his nonsensical walls?

Yes. And wt actual f is “nonsensical” about them? Is this even a serious thought?

I wonder if I voted you, would FA consider that a scummy omgus? Lol

Because seriously, you really do look like you’re trying to solve based on little to none content.

[Gamma Emerald]

Why the fuck are you rolefishing

Who was role fishing?

~Sora

Jjh

[Innocent Children]

I have no bias against you nancy. Let's throw meta in trash can, shall we?

I'm just treating your slot like every other slot in the game. I strongly feel those repeated derps were faked so I'm scumreading you for it.

Stop acting like this is personal or if there is more to this. If I see something towny from you that will change my read ofc. what are your current reads?

~Sora

I have no issue with meta, so long as it’s accurate. And once again, you’re wrong. I derp as either alignment and it’s not faked either. I legit thought that Siren’s call was initially some type of doc/vig and later bodyguard. So, this is the kind of thing that annoys me. You think you know how to read me but you don’t. When did I ever even remotely suggest this was “personal”? I have no issues with you afaik? That’s fair. I just hope you are able to actually see that but your sr me for being fake and misjudging my derps, aren’t exactly overwhelming me with confidence atm.

I think Gamma, Nero are town. I think this is probably town!Titus we are seeing here.

I’m kind of wondering about Wheme wanting people to sheep him on Vis - who didn’t seem to have much of a reaction to it and Wheme pretty much dropping it soon after. I’m thinking they could possibly be w/w and this was maybe some attempt at early distancing?

I’m trying to wrap my brain around Mastina claim. Initially it read townie to me but her recent post is making me walk that back. Something may be off there but whether that is AI or not, I couldn’t really say.

It's interesting to me that these are the reads on top of your head. what is your read on jjh? and why do you think gamma, nero and titus are town?

~Sora

Null for now - very slight townlean but not very confident about it.

I have others but I defacto dislike those kind of questions in general - general readslists, I prefer to discuss my reads more organically - which I have done. ISO me, if you doubt this. I currently feel the most confident about those 3, likely being town in this game.

[Gamma Emerald]

One of us 4 is scum.

can you explain this read?



~Sora

Sure! There were 5 players posting: Porkens, Nero, Rylai and Lina, Innocent Children, and Skygazer

And the two conversations were pretty much ignoring each other, so I figure there is at least one scum in those 5 (4 was a miscount).

Why do you include yourself
On the RandL/ICs thing I think RandL makes a good point

[Gamma Emerald]

Did we actually have a dayvig less than a day into D1?

This has the potential to be a real derp unlike what nancy did. for people who want to compare a real and fake derp compare this with stuff that nancy did.

~Sora

Okay this you’re gonna need to back up, why would Nancy not be baited by a fake day vig?

[Innocent Children]

did you just say if he was joking

glad to see someone else is not blind.

anime gifs are a towntell btw

This is called a joke

Do you speak for random?

I can't even ...

Nancy is NOT a naive player who can't understand jokes

. Nancy Knows how to play as town knows how to play as scum. Nearly outlived people as scum by acting this naive recently and I can't allow anyone to give her credit for this attitude.

~Sora

[Innocent Children]

Why the fuck are you rolefishing

Who was role fishing?

~Sora

Jjh

I am not completely caught up from yesterday. Can you link or quote this? Thanks.

[Nero Cain]

84-flavorfishes Wheme.

90-whiteknights Maria

In multiple posts he argues against the role=allignment thing that JJ was pushing.

Nero is this what your role does?

rolefish

VOTE: INVISIBLITY

THIS IS SCUM SHEEP ME

I trust you
...0%

thought this was a really weird reaction.

This is, imo, Gamma sum total of game relavent stuff.

Thought process and lack of agenday type posts.

So can you go more in depth on his thought processes that you liked?

[Innocent Children]

Did we actually have a dayvig less than a day into D1?

This has the potential to be a real derp unlike what nancy did. for people who want to compare a real and fake derp compare this with stuff that nancy did.

~Sora

[Innocent Children]

wheme that slot could be scum but i'd like to hear a case

What slot could be scum? And why not present your own case instead of waiting for others to create the scumread for you?

Please tell the class about

your

cases.

[Innocent Children]

84-flavorfishes Wheme.

90-whiteknights Maria

In multiple posts he argues against the role=allignment thing that JJ was pushing.

Nero is this what your role does?

rolefish

VOTE: INVISIBLITY

THIS IS SCUM SHEEP ME

I trust you
...0%

thought this was a really weird reaction.

This is, imo, Gamma sum total of game relavent stuff.

Thought process and lack of agenday type posts.

So can you go more in depth on his thought processes that you liked?

I don’t think I can point to one specific post in particular but it’s the entire stream of consciousness in his ISO. It just strikes me as coming from a villagery mindset.

I think Nico could possibly be town, she exhibited a similar kind of confidence in Labrynth.

[Nero Cain]

no one asked about nico?

[Innocent Children]

Did we actually have a dayvig less than a day into D1?

This has the potential to be a real derp unlike what nancy did. for people who want to compare a real and fake derp compare this with stuff that nancy did.

~Sora

Okay this you’re gonna need to back up, why would Nancy not be baited by a fake day vig?

There is no legitimate reason for her to think this as she knows you can’t fake day vig on MU, so I am beyond baffled by this.

[Innocent Children]

no one asked about nico?

I know, it was an afterthought.

[Innocent Children]

I think vax is slightly scummy. I heavily disliked his stance on chikaede and I didn't like his conversation with IC

Also, I didn't say my reads on those three names I mentioned when I asked her reads on you. I have a medium TR on you and slight tr on titus for some reasons but I never bet on my town reads and like to keep my reads change-able especially at the very start of the game till I find a good grasp of the game state.

~Sora

Current thoughts on Mastina?

[Innocent Children]

One of us 4 is scum.

can you explain this read?



~Sora

Sure! There were 5 players posting: Porkens, Nero, Rylai and Lina, Innocent Children, and Skygazer

And the two conversations were pretty much ignoring each other, so I figure there is at least one scum in those 5 (4 was a miscount).

Why do you include yourself
On the RandL/ICs thing I think RandL makes a good point

Who is RandL?

[Innocent Children]

P.edit. I’m not scum. I don’t think. Nero is either. I’d really like to think FA isn’t this - burn both of my eyes with a hot poker - bad at reading me but it would seem to be the case. I don’t as of yet have a read on Skygazer but I still don’t get the aescetic comment wrt Chick gift since I can confirm her gifts have no effect on roles. As for Porkens, legit, no clue rn.

[Innocent Children]

I don't like Sora's line on our slot. I'll describe it momentarily once I finish reading all the pages I need to catch up on. Not in a scummy way... just in a "Sora just does not understand how Nancy Drew works" way. It feels disingenuous and a bit of a dodge, but I might end up doing all the defense of this slot. As you've probably figured out, Nancy has some troubles trying to interpret and/or communicating herself.

~Disquieted

[Gamma Emerald]

One of us 4 is scum.

can you explain this read?



~Sora

Sure! There were 5 players posting: Porkens, Nero, Rylai and Lina, Innocent Children, and Skygazer

And the two conversations were pretty much ignoring each other, so I figure there is at least one scum in those 5 (4 was a miscount).

Why do you include yourself
On the RandL/ICs thing I think RandL makes a good point

Who is RandL?

FA And Shiro’s hydra (R(ylai) and L(ina))

[WhemeStar]

VOTE: Porkens

KK THIS IS ALSO GOOD

[WhemeStar]

NICE WHEME DIDNT LAST LONG BUT NICE WHEME IS OVER

BOW BEFORE ME MORTALS AND SHEEP ME IN MY QUEST TO LYNCH SCUM

[Innocent Children]

did you just say if he was joking

glad to see someone else is not blind.

anime gifs are a towntell btw

This is called a joke

Do you speak for random?

I can't even ...

Nancy is NOT a naive player who can't understand jokes. Nancy Knows how to play as town knows how to play as scum. Nearly outlived people as scum by acting this naive recently and I can't allow anyone to give her credit for this attitude.

~Sora

No

she does this to look like whatever she looks like after that. she wants to make people underestimate her. It's her thing.

~Sora

Whatever. I could write a wall about how this is wrong and how you don't understand how Nancy plays mafia. You do not understand how Nancy Drew plays mafia if you believe that Nancy intentionally fakes derps to get by as scum (and this is opposed to making major plays, which I believe she did do in Heroes Wanted, but is not the same type here). You do not understand that Nancy Drew just unintentionally does this regardless of her alignment.

In my honest opinion you sound upset that you believe you caught Nancy Drew as scum in Heroes Wanted but could not push it, and want to replicate that performance by scumreading Nancy Drew for doing things that she would've done anyways as town.

It gets pretty clear you're tunnelled on us when you start quoting a whatever post about my read on Kuroi, which is not garbage - in fact I'm still holding onto it and am still surveying Kuroi's subsequent few posts - and is just you being biased. I recommend you lay off and go read a town game of Nancy Drew's like Labyrinth Mafia, because it's pretty clear that you don't know a stitch about how Nancy plays the game and just want to catch her again for your own reasons.

And don't say meta isn't a part of it. Because you don't go and ride any regular slot into the sunset because of supposed "fake derps". You're on our slot because you want to be right.

~Disquieted