Overkill 1: Serenity/Firefly (GAME OVER)

[the worst]

thor showed up and is doing thor things so that's cool

rr wagon is eh but im not a fan of drixx posting

tora posting is still town

elaborate on Drixx

[Elsa Jay]

TW, you realize I'm claiming NEUTRAL DOCTOR and not town, right?

[ruru]

votecount

With 17 alive it takes 9 to lynch.

Reasonably Rational (5):	Toogeloo (449),	NicoRobin (473),	Elsa Jay (474),	Thor665 (544),	Skygazer (598),
Thor665 (2):	RadiantCowbells (610),	CheekyTeeky (613),
Flicker (1):	northsidegal (153),
Toranaga (1):	Reasonably Rational (363),
RadiantCowbells (1):	BuJaber (384),
BuJaber (1):	Flicker (497),
Malakittens (1):	Toranaga (549),
Not voting (5):	TPFKAP,	Chickadee,	randomidget,	Malakittens (90),	the worst (645),

(expired on 2018-10-16 02:00:00) remain.

[the worst]

TW, you realize I'm claiming NEUTRAL DOCTOR and not town, right?

Correct and I'm calling you a wolf. blatantly think this is a groupscum claim.

[Elsa Jay]

So your first response in a game with multiple killing mechanics is too... Kill a Doctor?

[the worst]

he is scummier than everyone else

That’s funny considering a few pages back you said I had a towny post. The only post that I have posted was not understanding the RR wagon.

Also I’m a ‘she’. I really don’t mind the pronouns, but please try

This felt beetlejuicy but I checked your ISO and you HAD been posting I just didn't get anything out of the posts.... nnn.... okay

if this is still a wagon when I catch up I think I'm on it unless Cheeky wants to seriously derail me because her hard TR here was Bold and Cool


pedit: Duh, if the doctor is a wolf

[the worst]

I didn’t beetlejuice I was already posting prior so get your facts right tia

sorry I didn't notice your last scummy post was so recent

saaaaame

[Thor665]

I'm not pigeonholed too "town", just the "Majority".

Big difference.

Not when most non-town factions tend to get to their endgame by killing things.
Also, even if your endgame is 'survive' doesn't mean you're necessarily compatible with other wincons (like, say an SK whose wincon is generally 'be the last living slot'.
Making your protect public fiat is a decent ploy to try to make that work for you also, might work, if I were you I'd try to ally more with the town though - town wincon and your claimed wincon remain the most likely to be compatible unless you know something I don't.

[the worst]

@NicoRobin and randommidget

- Are you caught up? Do you have any reads on people you'd care to share (that you haven't already)?

@TPFKAP

- Where are you?

Also, for what little it's worth, here are my notes on everyone so far.

Spoiler: Barely a reads list at all

.

Vague towny pile

(not in any particular order, which could include any strength of town from 1% to 100%):

Chickadee, CheekyTeeky, northsidegal, Reasonably Rational, Toogeloo, Toranaga

Null/conflicted pile

:

RadiantCowbells,* the worst, Thor665, Malakittens, TPFKAP, Skygazer, randommidget, Elsa Jay**

Vague scummy pile

(same deal as the town pile):

BuJaber, NicoRobin

---

*Probably a permanent resident, but I'll sheep other people's read on him if there's a reasonable consensus
**Pedit: He was in the towny pile until his most recent posts

why on:
Chickadee
Malakittens
Skygazer
Bujaber
Nico Robin

?

[Reasonably Rational]

Whatever the majority desires, dude.

Nothing personal. Unless your trying to hang me, of course.

Speaking of Majority...

ALL PEOPLE MAY BOLD WHO THEY WANT TO BE HEALED. THE ONE WITH THE MOST GETS MY HEAL.

...

Do you think this is likely to make your role effective in preventing kills?

-Cerb

Considering I can't be roleblocked, yes indeed.

I'm basically giving people the ability to vote someone they WANT to be in the next day garunteed.

Killing a Neutral claim this early seems stupid for other scum, and if they know who I'm healing but attack anyway, they really didnt feel like killing anyway.

Look at it as me making them night-immune based on a majority decision.

Let me rephrase.

Do you think this is likely to reduce the KPN of the game? The goal of a doctor is to stay alive and protect likely scum kills, so as to gain information about who is likely town(because a kill failed on a night you protected a certain person) and keep scum further away from winning the game.

Does what your doing right now accomplish this goal? Because if it doesn't, then you're not playing the way a town doctor would, and the only way the town keeps you alive as a 3p is if you PLAY FOR TOWN.

-Cerb

[the worst]

Just

THE HORIFIC BLOODY DEATHS OF ALL OTHER FACTIONS

. Nothing too special.

Oh, and I can't be roleblocked, so there MAY be a roleblocker. Just satin.

ftfy

[the worst]

@thor:
I agree with your assessment on RR but im not a fan of like half of the wagon's posting so far (

tw, tor, nico, elsa

). Between those four I think there's a good chance of the wagon being scum driven

talk to meee

[Elsa Jay]

Well then I'll pray the town takes out any SK with such a wincon for me while I help where I can with my heal and my vote.

Thor, do something about Worst. They going full crazy.

Pedit: Cerb, like I said, I'm doing what I can for the group and atm, that should be enough, because they feel lije finding people who they cant win with.

And making someone who "town" wants alive isn't helping town wincon, even if they're a PR?

[the worst]

I would have also have said most of that shit even if I didnt get a Neutral role, so...

:thnikngi:

[Toranaga]

TW, you realize I'm claiming NEUTRAL DOCTOR and not town, right?

Correct and I'm calling you a wolf. blatantly think this is a groupscum claim.

can you elaborate on this for me? I can't see how elsa is ever scum with this claim

[the worst]

i mean

im hard sring tora
nico has made like literally three posts
elsa is apparently 3rd party
and tw has just kinda been eh like i could see this as his town game but some of the things hes been posting reminds me of his scum game

so i may join you on RR

just worked out what skygazing is

[the worst]

Sky I'm starting to like.

Y

[the worst]

Oh yeah and nsg.. explain nsg townread also please flicker.. because nsg is bordering on her lurky scum meta right now

you realise NSG exists outside of mafia right and it's been like.... less than 24 hours and her posting was way outside of her scum meta and she hasn't been gone that long right....

eh I think this mistake is towny

[RadiantCowbells]

Hey so

Now that at best the Tor read has been proved wrong

I think that's really worth following up again.

[the worst]

can you elaborate on this for me? I can't see how elsa is ever scum with this claim

huuuh

don't be scum please Tora I beg you

VOTE: Mala

[RadiantCowbells]

I think {Thor, Toranaga, Elsa Jay} is a solid starting block

[Elsa Jay]

... Okay.

This is probably why I shouldn't have been dropping hints and claiming this early.

RC come on bro, why are you so focused on Tora and me?

[Toranaga]

can you elaborate on this for me? I can't see how elsa is ever scum with this claim

huuuh

don't be scum please Tora I beg you

VOTE: Mala

I promise you when you see me scum, you'll be able to tell by now.

can you go over how elsa's claim is scummy fypov?

[RadiantCowbells]

Because Tor's read on you felt like utter bullshit.
Now that it's proven to have been utter bullshit (at best even if you're telling the truth 3p isn't town) we can have a serious conversation about it without either town or scum Tor taking the out of blaming past drama for my current problem.

[Toranaga]

my elsa read was perfect