Overkill 1: Serenity/Firefly (GAME OVER)

[RadiantCowbells]

I'm pretty sure Elsa is scum claiming 3p
Pretty sure Thor are buddy
Think Toranaga also buddy but he could just be bad

[ruru]

votecount

With 17 alive it takes 9 to lynch.

Reasonably Rational (3):	NicoRobin (473),	Thor665 (544),	Skygazer (598),
Malakittens (2):	Toranaga (549),	the worst (669),
Flicker (1):	northsidegal (153),
Toranaga (1):	Reasonably Rational (363),
RadiantCowbells (1):	BuJaber (384),
BuJaber (1):	Flicker (497),
Thor665 (1):	RadiantCowbells (610),
NicoRobin (1):	CheekyTeeky (687),
Elsa Jay (1):	Toogeloo (729),
Toogeloo (1):	Elsa Jay (730),
Not voting (4):	TPFKAP,	Chickadee,	randomidget,	Malakittens (90),

(expired on 2018-10-16 02:00:00) remain.

[RadiantCowbells]

I'm so, so, so sorry ruru.

[RadiantCowbells]

So let's assume the mball spec is genuine

Thor/Elsa on one team
Maybe Flicker on the other? Tor could even be opposition trying to pocket him by calling him town to avoid getting crosskilled.

[RadiantCowbells]

That's been my major basis for Tor scum ftr

Feel like he saw Elsa claim multiball and assumed they were his opposition and tried to hard seem pocketed to avoid crosskill

[RadiantCowbells]

If Drixx stays at 2 posts I'm happy to Lynch RR.

He's the head I can read.

[RadiantCowbells]

Actually let's readslist

Mala: towny but not locktown
Cheeky: locktown unless mssybe scum with Tor
NSG: locktown
Bujaber: locktown and stupid
RC: cute
RR: not gonna read cerb when I can 100% read Drixx. Lynch if Drixx doesn't post, both heads know he's the weaker scum player.
Elsa: probably scum doctor, likely with Thor
Thor: probably scum with Elsa
Toranaga: scummy but not the scummiest
Flicker: has some real wolfy shit but feels not wolf with thorelsa
NicoRobin: at least a few percentage points more town than not
TW: at least a few % points more scum than not

[RadiantCowbells]

VOTE: Chickadee

[BuJaber]

That's been my major basis for Tor scum ftr

Feel like he saw Elsa claim multiball and assumed they were his opposition and tried to hard seem pocketed to avoid crosskill

This makes sense for both scum!Elsa and neutral!Elsa so why are you scumreading him? Talk me through how scum!Elsa endgames here with a day 1 claim of neutral doc.

Unless you think we'll fail to catch all other scum before we get around to lynching Elsa.

[BuJaber]

Okay that was easy.

Who else is scumreading me?

[the worst]

I'm pretty sure Elsa is scum claiming 3p

ya same

[CheekyTeeky]

VOTE: RadiantCowbells

[Toranaga]

VOTE: radiant cowbells

terrible, terrible posting all game

[Toranaga]

"Cheeky: locktown unless mssybe scum with Tor"

@cheeky

[Toranaga]

associative reads that don't work, like why is thor and elsa scum together? in what world does it make sense to think me and cheeky are maybe scum together, and that's cheeky entire equity as scum? cheeky's progression on me is the towniest, clearest thing to read into from her ISO I'm sure. she was highly suspicious of me, voted me early, declared me scum before it was cool to do so and I'm pretty sure our interactions are readably not svs. but cheeky's scum equity, the entire equity she has, is with me? right.

btw wrt elsa, the worst can think elsa is scum as much as he wants and I think it's towny of him to say that, but RC? there's no way elsa is ever scum. his posting all game is pure, his claim was crumbed from the beginning and makes no sense to gamble as scum, and the way he phrased and acted around his claim is always a genuine thing. I don't expect anyone with 5+ years of mafia obsession to get this wrong ever. it's a banal read.

and thor hasn't been scummy. thor has been thor. he can be scum, he can be town, who knows, right? it's thor, he makes himself hard to read and is one of the only players with MS with a reasonably balanced meta. so that scumread is poop too.

and, yeah. no wanting here, I think RC is scum. I think d2 is wonderful without him regardless but the horrible pushes and nonsensical associative reads are par with RC's scum game.

[Toranaga]

I was sleeping, woke up to piss and had to stop halfway to write this because holy shit

[Toranaga]

I'm pretty sure Elsa is scum claiming 3p
Pretty sure Thor are buddy
Think Toranaga also buddy but he could just be bad

I'm gonna dunk on you so hard today

[Elsa Jay]

You'd think calling me scum doctor with Thor would make you vote me or Thor.

Worst and Toogeloo mindsets being similar are bad, but getting someone who's literally claimed scum page 4 seems like a better idea.

Scum of varying degrees: {RadiantCowbells, Toogeloo, the Worst}

My current town picks: {CheekyTeeky, Thor, Toranaga}

Everyone else to be sorted later.

VOTE: Radiant

[Thor665]

Leaning Toogeloo as town for the Elsa push - that's a pretty ridiculous angle to go at as scum unless you can't read a room for spit. I think he can read a room.

@RC - you always scumread me, so I get that - but what makes Elsa scum and me her partner? That feels like you took a long bong hit and said the first thing that popped into your mind.

[Thor665]

I also think people are mistaking derp wagon push with scum pushing a wagon in the RC votes.
Not really excited by that.

[Reasonably Rational]

@RC - Back to reading and more thoughts incoming. #756 is gross but I'm giving you a pass for the moment simply because we haven't played together since I moved last year (I don't think?) and I doubt you actually know you are basically saying "If Drixx doesn't take time away from caring for his elderly father who is about to have major and risky back surgery and is also showing signs of Alzheimer's OR from his newly started job and be super active, then I'm going to assume he's scum."

Best thing I can says is just check the Drixx account and the recently finished BS game. I had a pretty ugly time crunch early and you probably would have pushed to lynch me based upon what you're saying in #756.

I'm doing my best to avoid that in this game. So speaking of that ... going to try and get 100% current by mid day. I'll check the current thread state occasionally but otherwise see you all on the other side of reading a bunch of posts.

~D

[Reasonably Rational]

Captain's Log: Entry 1

Occupant RadiantCowbells seems to have decided too throw any good will i had with their Mason claim by calling me scummy.

Occupant is also causing a ruckus with my assumed ally,Toranaga.

Cautionary measures may have to be taken. We may have to gag and tie then up.

I promise I'm not going to do the catch up from tens of pages back thing because that's annoying as shit usually but ... I couldn't help but pick up that Elsa has claimed something much later in the game than this quote which ... doesn't seem to jive with this early posting style. Like ... my gut says this early italics "Captain's Log" stuff feels a lot like setting up potential narrative space.

Eh ... we'll see where it goes. It feels really off though. I'm reading Elsa trying to see if the claim makes any sense with the play and this early stuff is making my guts grumble.

~D

[Elsa Jay]

Well, considering my objective is just to live until the end, I thought having those captain logs would be fun to do as long as I'm alive.

Usually when the Captain dies shit also hits the fan, so....

[Chickadee]

You should know me better than this RC. And your vote on me is bad. If you're so sure Elsa and Tor are scum, why vote me? You haven't even mentioned me much.

[RadiantCowbells]

@RC - Back to reading and more thoughts incoming. #756 is gross but I'm giving you a pass for the moment simply because we haven't played together since I moved last year (I don't think?) and I doubt you actually know you are basically saying "If Drixx doesn't take time away from caring for his elderly father who is about to have major and risky back surgery and is also showing signs of Alzheimer's OR from his newly started job and be super active, then I'm going to assume he's scum."

Best thing I can says is just check the Drixx account and the recently finished BS game. I had a pretty ugly time crunch early and you probably would have pushed to lynch me based upon what you're saying in #756.

I'm doing my best to avoid that in this game. So speaking of that ... going to try and get 100% current by mid day. I'll check the current thread state occasionally but otherwise see you all on the other side of reading a bunch of posts.

~D

I haven't given you any sort of invasive timeline
Just that if you not posting is a long term thing it's a problem