A Story Revisited (Anything uPick): Day 6

[northsidegal]

First question: is mastina town?

Next questions: I have {GE, Sky, Porkens, Ginngie, Nero Cain, jjh, randomidget} as town. Admittedly, some of those aren't based on my own very close reasoning and are based on sheeping other people claiming strong reads. Does anyone disagree with any of those reads?

Who was conftowned by wh4t's desperado?

[Firebringer]

And
I’m not tunneling. I’m just saying MC did so much nothing it’s scummy. If you contribute I’ll reevaluate, but you’re starting low.

Yes you are tunneling you shit.
I open in this game and you post "something a scum would post".

You know what isn't tunneling? Posting "hey i am scumreading your slot for how it played, I am hoping i can get a better read on you" but you didn't do that, you reconfirmed your own read while positing like my post meant something.

[Nero Cain]

nero cain i trust u without reading a single one of ur posts.
hopefully this convinces u to join me on my wagon of justice.

I'm so pocketed right now. I'll reread Gamma but he's kinda way down my totem pole.

[Gamma Emerald]

Question 1: maybe? She claimed Loyal gladiator
Question 2: I don’t particularly object to those reads
Question 3: vax

[Firebringer]

damn i want to say nsg is town for that post, but she obviously read the game before replacing in. can't townread it now realizing that.

[Nero Cain]

I think JJ is scummy. Let's argue about him.

[Firebringer]

nero cain i trust u without reading a single one of ur posts.
hopefully this convinces u to join me on my wagon of justice.

I'm so pocketed right now. I'll reread Gamma but he's kinda way down my totem pole.

i think its more fair to say u pocketed me, but thats fine if gamma isn't a priority for u. I don't have a legitimate read on him, this is rage cross tunnel for his sheningans.

[Gamma Emerald]

And
I’m not tunneling. I’m just saying MC did so much nothing it’s scummy. If you contribute I’ll reevaluate, but you’re starting low.

Yes you are tunneling you shit.
I open in this game and you post "something a scum would post".

You know what isn't tunneling? Posting "hey i am scumreading your slot for how it played, I am hoping i can get a better read on you" but you didn't do that, you reconfirmed your own read while positing like my post meant something.

Well I was trying to rule you up. Success! Now I have something that should be pretty solid to read you on: PAST META. Remember your 1v1 with NicoRobin last Upick? Prepare to die if this doesn’t match up.

[Firebringer]

i didn't 1v1 nicorobin. I remember explicitly trying to avoid her and she instigated. Unless i am thinking of a different game.

[northsidegal]

i didn't read the game before replacing in (not even close)

i wanted spoilers for this game but rc wouldn't give them to me unless i guessed the scumteam

essentially i did a brief skim of some ISOs for people who i thought i could read and did some sheeping of people claiming strong reads to try to start forming a poe, and even then i never even really started looking for scumreads.

not that any of that matters anyways, i'll be town soon enough if my predecessor wasn't good enough for my slot to be locktown.

[Gamma Emerald]

i didn't 1v1 nicorobin. I remember explicitly trying to avoid her and she instigated. Unless i am thinking of a different game.

You both had killing roles and wanted each other’s heads (you were Town sui bomber, she was Town vig with neg utilities with each shot)

[Firebringer]

i didn't 1v1 nicorobin. I remember explicitly trying to avoid her and she instigated. Unless i am thinking of a different game.

You both had killing roles and wanted each other’s heads (you were Town sui bomber, she was Town vig with neg utilities with each shot)

yeah and i explicitly didn't interact with her. and i shot the scum. I threatened to vig her and didn't do that and basically ignored her.

[northsidegal]

I think JJ is scummy. Let's argue about him.

i'm pretty sure you're wrong and that might be the only read where i'll just say that straight up about it

i'm speaking from memory from another time here, but if jjh is scum he has put far more effort and time into this game than any scumgame he's ever played before. i've correctly scumread jjh before starting from about page 5 to his lynch on day one and i don't think he's scum here.

i'm open to hearing your case but that's probably among my more confident townreads.

[Firebringer]

i didn't read the game before replacing in (not even close)

i wanted spoilers for this game but rc wouldn't give them to me unless i guessed the scumteam

essentially i did a brief skim of some ISOs for people who i thought i could read and did some sheeping of people claiming strong reads to try to start forming a poe, and even then i never even really started looking for scumreads.

not that any of that matters anyways, i'll be town soon enough if my predecessor wasn't good enough for my slot to be locktown.

ur try hard attitude is endearing.

[Firebringer]

okay i am willing to tr u nsg.

right now nero cain is my strongest tr and i again haven't read his posts.

[Gamma Emerald]

i didn't 1v1 nicorobin. I remember explicitly trying to avoid her and she instigated. Unless i am thinking of a different game.

You both had killing roles and wanted each other’s heads (you were Town sui bomber, she was Town vig with neg utilities with each shot)

yeah and i explicitly didn't interact with her. and i shot the scum. I threatened to vig her and didn't do that and basically ignored her.

You’re saying two very different things
Like I explicitly remember you going after her

[Nero Cain]

i'm pretty sure you're wrong and that might be the only read where i'll just say that straight up about it

maid cafe's 109 + his tole fishing Nico from, a few pages ago. Of course, the inverse of that argument is that scum wouldn't blatantly rolefish that hard. Also, he seems to have had a weird drop in activity.

[northsidegal]

{GE, Sky, Porkens, Ginngie, Nero Cain, jjh, randomidget}
{Rylai and Lina, Maid Cafe, Nicorobin, Mastina, Chickadee, Titus, KuroiXHF, Invisibility, Whemestar, Vecna}
{Nosferatu, Lady Angel}



More questions:
What happened with that "a guilty has been declared" thing?
What happened with the Kuroi wagon? (Why did it start, why has it seemed to disappear?)
Why is 1825 so great?

[Firebringer]

i don't think i ever voted her that game or even responded to a post of hers. but i could be wrong. I remember explicitly going out of my to ignore her as much as i could and telling the playerbase she was dying. but i am not talking about that game anymore, i am ignoring her hardcore this game unless i am lynching her in which case ill vote her and not respond say anything to her.

[Gamma Emerald]

i don't think i ever voted her that game or even responded to a post of hers. but i could be wrong. I remember explicitly going out of my to ignore her as much as i could and telling the playerbase she was dying. but i am not talking about that game anymore, i am ignoring her hardcore this game unless i am lynching her in which case ill vote her and not respond say anything to her.

I checked, you didn’t mention her once so you’re correct
I will say that means this is different in that case, what is your response?

[Firebringer]

i think ur question is pointless because i would ignore her as either alignment.

[northsidegal]

i'm pretty sure you're wrong and that might be the only read where i'll just say that straight up about it

maid cafe's 109 + his tole fishing Nico from, a few pages ago. Of course, the inverse of that argument is that scum wouldn't blatantly rolefish that hard. Also, he seems to have had a weird drop in activity.

While I think beeboy is a pretty good player i'm not sure if that one observation and a little bit of rolefishing outweighs the massive amounts of effort that it seems to me that he's put in this game. Again, i'm only going off of what i know, which is that scum jjh puts in a

lot

less effort than what i've seen here. If you have some kind of counterexample i would be glad to see it - completely seriously.

[Gamma Emerald]

{GE, Sky, Porkens, Ginngie, Nero Cain, jjh, randomidget}
{Rylai and Lina, Maid Cafe, Nicorobin, Mastina, Chickadee, Titus, KuroiXHF, Invisibility, Whemestar, Vecna}
{Nosferatu, Lady Angel}



More questions:
What happened with that "a guilty has been declared" thing?
What happened with the Kuroi wagon? (Why did it start, why has it seemed to disappear?)
Why is 1825 so great?

The guilty was flavor for mastina’s ability
We no lynched from the gladiate
Idk because it’s true?

[Firebringer]

let me iso mastina to figure out if she is scum.
i have a pretty decent scumstina detector.

[Gamma Emerald]

i think ur question is pointless because i would ignore her as either alignment.

No I meant your reaction to me feels different than how you played that out
And why tf are you ignoring Nico? You are aware she kinda broke the last Upick right? So any hate is undeserved imo.