A Story Revisited (Anything uPick): Day 6

[NicoRobin]

That awkward moment when someone who claims to townread you wants to shoot you, and the person who you agree with scumreads you.....

This must be the Opposite land.....

[Jingle]

Nah. I'm just willing to let you die to save mastina.

And my read on you is a very limited meta read that has been counterindicated by pretty much everyone else.

[NicoRobin]

You are making a mistake there. What in her play has been towny? Please, do say.......

Even I am more town than she is, despite what others say.

[NicoRobin]

If this is about my ability, why the hell would you want to save someone who possibly lied about their role? Town would let me do my thing and draw their own conclusions from what the results might be, not try to stop my ability altogether.

Also, I am amused you think I have enough sway to run her up, role or no role.

[NicoRobin]

and flattered too.

[Vecna]

Mastina already noted herself that the mod had no flavor for a no lynch. She even stated the mod had given her a troll role. Hints at the setup not being designated to resolve around a day-cop that relies on a lot of trust being given.

Explain how this, in any way, is an argument for mastina being scum.

Its not. It was more an argument of there being a lot more to consider for the counter-side of the argument, aka possibilities of Mastina being scum.

Either way, I think I -might- have lost interest in actually lynching Mastina today. Im gonna give it some more thought and see what other shady shit develops here and make up my mind tomorrow.

[Vecna]

All my scumreads actually leaning in to side with my argument and lynch Mastina means either my reads are really terrible, or im just completely on the wrong side of this and was about to fuck up a town power house.

For me personally, the duel on Chickadee was a wasted action/day, but at least this also contributes to a scum Mastina not having as much of an impact, meaning there is less harm in waiting it out.

[Jingle]

Um. So this is kind of awkward.

Do you know of any completed games we have together? Or equally likely, games that you were in that I may have been tangentially related to?

I have an impression of your game that I thought was from GiF's large, but I just went back to check and you weren't even in that game.

And now I have to try and figure out if that means I'm confusing you with someone or if I just have the wrong game.

[NicoRobin]

So I am shady because I reiterate that reading her for her role alone is a mistake.

I call bullshit on that. Do you know how many games were lost because someone had the bright idea of town-clearing someone based on role alone? Too many. And now you are doing that exact thing, which leads me to believe that you want to lose.

I don't normally say this, but get your heads out of your asses.

If you don't believe me, ask mastina herself. :c

[Jingle]

reads are really terrible

They objectively are.

I didn't want to bring this up, but the reads list wall you made is pretty much 100% of the reason I'm scumreading Vizzy.

[NicoRobin]

And don't ask me damn questions and then fucking ignore me.

You are getting in the way of victory here.

[Porkens]

jingle is scum

[Gamma Emerald]

Game is not bastard, cult and tailor shouldn’t be possible

2) Whether the setup is bastard or not, there will not be any mechanics that involve lying to players outside of standard fare (ninjas, godfathers).

BTW.

Those are barely lies, and fairly common in theme games (ninja is even normal). Cult and Tailor, not so. The game was only stated to be bastard in sign-ups because of complaints during the last game with post-deletion mechanics.

[Gamma Emerald]

Oh yeah and Vecna, if you could do a makeshift readslist by rainbowposting where the first 22 letters are coloured individually depending on the read for the 22 players in order on the list that would be great

Use red for scum, green for town and yellow for null I guess

Also btw.

Yeah I remembered that as I posted the first time about that

[Gamma Emerald]

What? what are you talking about lol.

Mastina duelled Chickadee, but the mod made a votecount between Mastina and Kuroi (including awesomely copy-pasta'd stuff about vax and ginngie still being able to vote).

Im not stating anything about what you said (and my assumptions usually kick ass).

What about Ginngie

[Gamma Emerald]

This rings a bell because you have made this exact argument to me while you were scum and I was correctly setup speccing someone as town

It’s still a correct argument
Just because scum call your play bad doesn’t necessarily mean it’s good

[Gamma Emerald]

Don't have to forgo setup spec when this has got a much higher accuracy rate in this circumstance than play could ever have

Cool
On mastina scumflip you get lynched next day
VOTE: mastina btw

[Creature]

This day was a waste.

Still, though, it's better than lynching town.

[Creature]

Basically we should:

Pretend we're lynching without actually lynching

Our "lynchee" gets gladiated by mastina

We either get a scum lynch we would've lynched anyway or we prevent a mislynch from happening in exchange of a nolynch.

[Creature]

It's as if whoever was mislynched would be revived.

[jjh927]

Yes that is the prevailing opinion of the sane people, Creature

[Creature]

VOTE: nolynch

[Gamma Emerald]

Nah. I'm just willing to let you die to save mastina.

And my read on you is a very limited meta read that has been counterindicated by pretty much everyone else.

This feels twisted as fuck

[Creature]

If we can sort mastina, we could make good use of this.

Fakelynch someone.

Have mastina gladiate them.

Either get guaranteed scumlynch or prevent the mislynch from happening

[Creature]

Nah. I'm just willing to let you die to save mastina.

And my read on you is a very limited meta read that has been counterindicated by pretty much everyone else.

This feels twisted as fuck

This

tf lynching conftown