A Story Revisited (Anything uPick): Day 6

[NicoRobin]

@Jingle I can only use my triple vote against Porkens atm, though this could be changed each day.

[NicoRobin]

Also, I am not the major problem: you guys are. You are townreading someone without even a sliver of doubt and without any reservations whatsoever. Sorry if my experiences so far lead me to believe that your level of surety would bite your in the ass at the end.

[jjh927]

Your arguments don't work from any coherent perspective.

I'm not sheeping Mastina

[NicoRobin]

Your arguments don't work from any coherent perspective.

I'm not sheeping Mastina

Why wouldn't you sheep your own town read who has a better understanding of the game than you ever would?

It's because you know she is scum because you two are partners. And everyone who townreads mastina for her role alone is also scum.

[Firebringer]

S'what I thought.

I can't say I expected more, but dammit man you let grudges get in the way too often.

Also, if you give me a gun and don't lynch mastina I'll shoot NR for you.

You do this to gamma emerald instead and it’s a deal.

I don’t care enough about NicoRobin to want her dead

[NicoRobin]

There, I've said it. Engage me in the game of wits, ladies and gentlemen, Umineko-style.

On the first twilight, gouge the head and kill.
On the 2nd twilight, gouge the neck and kill
On the 3rd twilight, gouge an arm and kill
On the 4th twilight, gouge jjh and kill.

[jjh927]

I have a very good understanding of the game and you shouldn't belittle that, but it's in your scum playbook to do so

[Jingle]

S'what I thought.

I can't say I expected more, but dammit man you let grudges get in the way too often.

Also, if you give me a gun and don't lynch mastina I'll shoot NR for you.

You do this to gamma emerald instead and it’s a deal.

I don’t care enough about NicoRobin to want her dead

Wait, I can save a hard townread by shooting a null read instead of a townlean?

You realize you're sweetening the pot, right?

Done and done.

[NicoRobin]

I have a very good understanding of the game and you shouldn't belittle that, but it's in your scum playbook to do so

Care to explain why you have no doubt whatsoever about mastina being town, then? Are you informed somehow? Cos if you aren't, then you being that certain she is town is icky.

[Invisibility]

are we lynching mastina

[NicoRobin]

are we lynching mastina

I wanna, but dem idiots are refusing solely because of her role.

[Jingle]

And because she's town, but, you know, I probably wouldn't be bargaining for her life without her role being involved so that's a fair assessment.

[Gamma Emerald]

also I want to sort the ex-hydra slots, all of them feel bad.

All 2 of them?

[Invisibility]

wait nico do you think that mastina is scum i skipped like 3 pages

[Gamma Emerald]

You know what fuck it I don’t think anyone is being convinced by my argument
VOTE: No lynch

[Creature]

also I want to sort the ex-hydra slots, all of them feel bad.

All 2 of them?

The three hydras seemed bad.

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm gonna take your lack of answer as: "I don't know what game that could be" NR. Sigh. Now to backtrack through the last 2-3 months of reading games. Joy.

Lack of answer to what

[NicoRobin]

And because she's town, but, you know, I probably wouldn't be bargaining for her life without her role being involved so that's a fair assessment.

Nah, you are townreading her solely because of her role. If I am wrong and you're also townreading her because of her play.......well, then it would be a different story entirely.

@Invisibility Yes, I am. Have been since the beginning.

[Invisibility]

VOTE: mastkna
Actually it's fine

[Gamma Emerald]

S'what I thought.

I can't say I expected more, but dammit man you let grudges get in the way too often.

Also, if you give me a gun and don't lynch mastina I'll shoot NR for you.

You do this to gamma emerald instead and it’s a deal.

I don’t care enough about NicoRobin to want her dead

Wait, I can save a hard townread by shooting a null read instead of a townlean?

You realize you're sweetening the pot, right?

Done and done.

I’m down.

[Gamma Emerald]

also I want to sort the ex-hydra slots, all of them feel bad.

All 2 of them?

The three hydras seemed bad.

Meme men replaced RandL
It’s not an ex-hydra slot

[Jingle]

Nah, you are townreading her solely because of her role. If I am wrong and you're also townreading her because of her play.......well, then it would be a different story entirely.

I'm not arguing that she's town because of her play because I shouldn't have to. The role should be more than enough.

With that said, this IS mastina's towngame, and the only real argument to the contrary I've seen is her lack of presence, which has never been an alignment indicative mastina tell.

[Invisibility]

oh i just wanted ot confirm her role

[Jingle]

I'm gonna take your lack of answer as: "I don't know what game that could be" NR. Sigh. Now to backtrack through the last 2-3 months of reading games. Joy.

Lack of answer to what

I remember her from some game and was hoping she'd know what it was. I'm gonna have to dig through the completed games I've read to see if it's because I'm actually remembering her or if I'm somehow conflating her with someone from the game I thought she was in. TBF, it was kind of a longshot, most of the games I read no one ever finds out.

[NicoRobin]

Nah, you are townreading her solely because of her role. If I am wrong and you're also townreading her because of her play.......well, then it would be a different story entirely.

I'm not arguing that she's town because of her play because I shouldn't have to. The role should be more than enough.

With that said, this IS mastina's towngame, and the only real argument to the contrary I've seen is her lack of presence, which has never been an alignment indicative mastina tell.

Let me welcome you to mastina school of thought, then.

See, now, that's not enough and never will be. Role shouldn't be the sole factor in reading someone. mastina will tell you that herself when she gets here, so I will say no more on the matter.