A Story Revisited (Anything uPick): Day 6

[Varsoon]

If Porkens isn't willing to give a yes/no to that, they're not playing the game at all.

[Vecna]

Or maybe I don’t like conversations that are likely to narrow down the pool of possible loud doctors and would prefer letting them do whatever the hell they feel like doing.

If you doubt the information I gave out, that’s on you. There is no alignment I could be that would have a reason to lie about a loud doctor visiting me. I don’t know why they chose what they chose and any speculation along those lines is anti town.

Making these resolute statements along the lines of "There is no way" is always so short-sighted. If youre scum that tried to kill mastina last night, you definitely would have reason to throw about claims about roles that couldve saved her, to see what type of reactions you get. Because in that scenario, scum would really really have to find a way to kill Mastina.

The same applies to the JJG claim of being deathproof. Just wait and see if any reactions to other scenario's that mightve resulted in a no-kill come to the surface.

In-direct rolefishing is the most scummy type of rolefishing.

What benefit does town have to knowing JJH is deathproof? Or that there is a loud doctor that went and visited you? It only serves to illuminate to scum why their kill went tits up. Gives them mechanical info, if true.

[WhemeStar]

Wait

So nico claimed a guilty on mastina, admitted to lying about the guilty but that they would get actual results in 48 hours?

[Varsoon]

Nico fucked up their gambit by forgetting they already outted how their role works.
So then when Nico got called out on it, they admitted it was a lie, but failed to reveal what they got out lying, hinting that lying wasn't really a gambit but just a power play to try to get Mastina quicklynched.
Then they walked it back to the 48 hour thing.
All while JJH claimed deathproof with probable assumption that scum-Nico, who was under fire by JJH, goes for a kill on him--we had no death, so possible.
Nico denies, blames JJH and/or Jingle for their role not working the way it should (how?) and then insists that there are plenty of other explanations for why there'd be a no-kill, to which Jingle corroborates that there is a loud doctor but doubts it blocked the kill.

I think that's the whole of it?

[Varsoon]

Now we're waiting on the 48 hour thing and for Porkens corroboration, which is about as annoying as it sounds.

[Vecna]

Im fairly certain that Mastina was commuted or jailkept or something along those lines, because my top secret ability also failed to deliver the expected result.

A roleblock couldve also done it, but to be fair, who would try to roleblock me with my claimed flavor/mechanics.

[Vecna]

Meh, maybe if they tried to verify my music claim, but it still sounds pretty far-fetched

[Vecna]

Regardless, Mastina somehow being untargetable fits by far the best with the result that Nico is dodgily claiming and my result. It also is by far the most likely explanation of what happened with the missing kill.

A jailkeeper really fits terribly with Jingle's claim though, unless either of them is scum. A scum jailkeeper targeting mastina to prevent Nico's pre-announced rolecop could be a thing I guess, but that coinciding with no nightkill would be pretty coincidental.

[Aristophanes]

Meh, maybe if they tried to verify my music claim, but it still sounds pretty far-fetched

Would your music even send if you were roleblobked??

[Vecna]

Not sure on that one, my role pm just states that anyone visiting me hears the music im listening to. If its blockable or not.....id have to ask the mod.

Regardless, such questions make it all the more unlikely a roleblocker would try to roleblock me to confirm that part.

[NicoRobin]

I already had my result and already gave it..... *sigh*

[jjh927]

You were expecting a rolecop result. We know that.

Please tell us unambiguously exactly what you got so we don't have to fill in any gaps

[NicoRobin]

I got no result. Won't say it again. Learn to read.

[jjh927]

Then what the shit was that about a tracker result

[NicoRobin]

I had some misunderstandings over how my role works.

[jjh927]

[jjh927]

Did you think you were a rolecop when you were actually a tracker or some shit?

[Varsoon]

To be fair, I am bad at reading.
Sorry.

[jjh927]

Wow Varsoon did you just imply that Josuke's hair looks like a cat

[NicoRobin]

Did you think you were a rolecop when you were actually a tracker or some shit?

Yes.

[Vecna]

Did you ever learn Porkens role NR? Or got any useful result there?

[jjh927]

Regardless, Mastina somehow being untargetable fits by far the best with the result that Nico is dodgily claiming and my result. It also is by far the most likely explanation of what happened with the missing kill.

A jailkeeper really fits terribly with Jingle's claim though, unless either of them is scum. A scum jailkeeper targeting mastina to prevent Nico's pre-announced rolecop could be a thing I guess, but that coinciding with no nightkill would be pretty coincidental.

Would be a forced commute, not a jailkeep. Jailkeep only roleblocks. Unless there's some rolestopper nonsense in there.

Also, it's definitely not the most likely explanation of the missing kill. As I said, I baited really hard and I'm pretty much unlynchable here unless people are immensely dumb

[jjh927]

Porkens rejected the thing and so NR got the triple vote

[Varsoon]

Porkens rejected the thing and so NR got the triple vote

So what's keeping scum!mastina from rejecting the thing?
I don't understand why nico thought that gambit made sense, considering the above.

[Vecna]

Right. I always keep fucking up on how that works over here.