A Story Revisited (Anything uPick): Day 6

[jjh927]

Pagetop gets meme

[Skygazer]

VOTE: NSG

[Gamma Emerald]

My role says tracker/watcher.

Then why does it ask for their role? I want the flavor reason.

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: jjh
For the shitty meme

[Gamma Emerald]

What's the flavour for your different abilities called

Make the damn uPick and You Promised

@Vecna I looked at my role PM again, and it seems that I am not a Watcher after all, but a Role Cop.

Guess this is what happens when I don't read my own role PM thoroughly..... :O

At this point, I deserve to be lynched for sheer stupidity......

Yeah how do you keep messing up what your role is
Looks to me you’re just changing it to fit the climate of the game

[Chickadee]

VOTE: NicoRobin

[Jingle]

I endorse the NR gladiate. If she's town AND she gets the answer to the question I wanted asked that I expect her to, it's likely that both Porkens and Mastina are scum.

I also think today is the day that we should use Varsoon's ability if we're going to use it at all, possibly tomorrow, so would like to consider who we want to lynch in the case that the gladiate goes off.

[Jingle]

"Does my action resolve as two separate actions, or is it one individual one? Specifically, if I was roleblocked between mastina being acted upon and my receiving the result, would I get the normal result or a no result? If I was rolestopped between mastina being acted upon and my receiving the result, would I get the normal result or a no result?"

[Invisibility]

gladiate nico

[jjh927]

VOTE: jjh
For the shitty meme

Screw you new meme formats are always great

[NicoRobin]

None of you seem o be considering the possibility that she'd just refuse to gladiate me if she is scum.

[northsidegal]

It's jjh/Jingle/Porkens/mastina scumteam.

Didn't you notice how whenever I try to pressure Porkens and/or mastina, jjh is always there to defend them in some way?

I wonder why that is?

i really can't tell if this is something she actually believes

[jjh927]

That's because if she refuses to gladiate you we will lynch her, making it an action that she would not do as either alignment

[northsidegal]

not sure if aristophanes is still scum honestly, but i still think varsoon is scum. i thought the same thing spectating that fakegod game that just finished and i was right there (if anyone cares).

VOTE: varsoon

[Lady Angel]

I give it 48 hours until she changes her role back.

Gladiate away, Mastina.

[northsidegal]

hey jjh, what do you think of varsoon?

[mastina]

BTW at work so the soonest you'll get a content post from me is in over 3 hours, but I'd like to reiterate.
If you think Nico is scum, ask yourself, "how does this make sense coming from scum?".
You might default to, "scum caught in a lie, backtracking"…
…Except. While that may work as an explanation for some scummers. It doesn't work as an explanation for NICO. Quite the opposite, it's the very proof that she's town. You might struggle to understand how it makes sense coming from town, but serious question.

How many games have you played?
In how many of those games, was there a town player whose actions made no sense, but they were still town?

You're outright ignorant or lying if it hasn't happened in at least a third of your games.

It's a little difficult to show because she has a dozen past accounts, but I can show Nico's quite extensive history of this sort of thing.

You want real scum?

Try here.
VOTE: Varsoon.
Would vote Firebringer slot if I remembered the name of who holds it, but this works just as well.

[jjh927]

hey jjh, what do you think of varsoon?

Not honestly sure. I'm willing to consider him after NicoRobin but I'm kinda leaning town and I think I need a scumflip before I can really place him

[Lady Angel]

BTW at work so the soonest you'll get a content post from me is in over 3 hours, but I'd like to reiterate.
If you think Nico is scum, ask yourself, "how does this make sense coming from scum?".
You might default to, "scum caught in a lie, backtracking"…
…Except. While that may work as an explanation for some scummers. It doesn't work as an explanation for NICO. Quite the opposite, it's the very proof that she's town. You might struggle to understand how it makes sense coming from town, but serious question.

How many games have you played?
In how many of those games, was there a town player whose actions made no sense, but they were still town?

You're outright ignorant or lying if it hasn't happened in at least a third of your games.

It's a little difficult to show because she has a dozen past accounts, but I can show Nico's quite extensive history of this sort of thing.

You want real scum?

Try here.
VOTE: Varsoon.
Would vote Firebringer slot if I remembered the name of who holds it, but this works just as well.

I don't think anyone's asking how this makes sense from scum, but rather how it makes sense as town. While yes, Town does dumb stuff, I legitimately can't see why a single town slot would do all of the following, in order:

- Fake a guilty. This is probably the most reasonable thing Nico's done today if it weren't for the fact that her claim and role is very easily disputed if she actually used the role last night, which she did.

- Retracting the fake guilty after the claim is fine, calling it a reaction test to call (funny enough) the people calling her scum scum again is slightly less so. She never bothered to explain how it was a reaction test beyond what boiled down to "Well if you went along with it I wouldn't think you're scum"

- Claiming she was a tracker a day after she'd claimed rolecop, and claiming to get no result after she got back the result from you. This was after you claimed she wanted your role, I might add. She stuck by this even after both players she targeted counterclaimed, and after a brief period where she tried to play it as a tracker/watcher who demanded roles...

- Backpedaled to the rolecop claim. This is one of the more fine things she's done, but the damage has already been done at this point.

The thing is, we

know

she got a result, and rather than share it she spent two days trying more or less every possibility to get out of sharing her result. How is that town play? What town motivation does any player have to not share a cop result and instead spend two days derailing everything?

@Nico

, now that you're a rolecop again, what was your result on Mastina?

[jjh927]

Pretty sure it's still gonna be no result even though Mastina received the message and at least that part of the action worked.


Why has nobody acknowledged my meme post as good

[northsidegal]

hey jjh, what do you think of varsoon?

Not honestly sure. I'm willing to consider him after NicoRobin but I'm kinda leaning town and I think I need a scumflip before I can really place him

could you explain why you're leaning town? i really don't think there's a lot of substance in his ISO and it reminds me of his iso in this game that just finished

[Jingle]

Would vote Firebringer slot if I remembered the name of who holds it, but this works just as well.

Firebringer.

3804 has the current playerlist.

And, more importantly, how do you feel about lynching Vecna?

Nico, please ask RC my question.

"Does my action resolve as two separate actions, or is it one individual one? Specifically, if I was roleblocked between mastina being acted upon and my receiving the result, would I get the normal result or a no result? If I was rolestopped between mastina being acted upon and my receiving the result, would I get the normal result or a no result?"

Also, Nico, if mastina refuses to gladiate any target chosen for her by the majority, that majority will lynch her. It's kind of how leashing a role works.

[jjh927]

Could you ask again this time tomorrow when I'm procrastinating doing presentation stuff rather than now when I want to sleep

[Firebringer]

I never left the game mastina, so you going to replace our or what

[Varsoon]

not sure if aristophanes is still scum honestly, but i still think varsoon is scum. i thought the same thing spectating that fakegod game that just finished and i was right there (if anyone cares).

VOTE: varsoon

Completely different game that's only 41 pages where I was a much different role and there since the start
Whereas here I have some bunk-ass hidden vote role with no means of hidden communication and I replaced in 100 pages deep.
But awesome case full of great points about me, I guess. It's at least more than cowtowing to Mastina and/or NicoRobin's play, so even though it's literally wrong, I'm still for it.