Witches' Halloween Ball [Game Over]

[Firebringer]

Rc is a big poop face

[RadiantCowbells]

Umm

[Firebringer]

Hi

[shortaru]

Umm

Lemme guess... you like the drummer?

Sigh.

[RadiantCowbells]

The drummer?

[shortaru]

Aw, you didn't even watch the video.

Sadness.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

I think Maria<->Cakez is a good pairing.

I also think Dunnstral<->LLD is a good pairing.

Because frankly 1) I think all four of those names are town now seeing their posting

and 2) I think all four of those names are entirely unafraid of killing themselves to kill the other if they get the slightest hint of them being scum.

I do want to run it by other people's reads, specifically interested in our confirmed town's perspective on things, but yeah I think those are a few good pairings.

I'm on board with pairing with you, by the way

I'll probably offer you a dance once I talk with RC a bit more about his reads on monday.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

I think Dunn is a good towny boi

This is right. Cakez is also town male.

[Kokichi Oma]

ill catch up later

[ChibiBear]

Well that seems like the basics but sometimes pairs are more better thought out by the group. Town doesn't normally like to do that though because 'teamwork'

This is probably not that important, but I don't understand what this is supposed to mean.

Tldr is there's a really optimal way to play this set up but town will never do it because of the teamwork it requires

Are you willing to elaborate on what this strategy would be and why it would work?

[MariaR]

I find it odd LLD and Maria seem to both tr each orher

Btw if no one knows this if Maria or LLD flip scum
We need FoS the other because they are insanely at good at hiding scum associations together

This is really bad and you know it. Like are me and LLD good scum players? Yes but that doesn't mean you just auto fos the other player if one of us flips scum. I know LLD is a good scum player but I'm not gonna just go "Oh I would tr lld but it's lld so no" cause that's shitty.

[MariaR]

Well that seems like the basics but sometimes pairs are more better thought out by the group. Town doesn't normally like to do that though because 'teamwork'

This is probably not that important, but I don't understand what this is supposed to mean.

Tldr is there's a really optimal way to play this set up but town will never do it because of the teamwork it requires

Are you willing to elaborate on what this strategy would be and why it would work?

I would basically require the IC and the town to work together to find the most town guy and lady and pair them off one at a time get 2 or 3 lock town v town pairs. Then you get the most scummy pairings together leaving the most scummy lady out of the dance.

[MariaR]

You people are townreading dunn way too easily btw. Nothing he's said is outside his scumrange. The only thing he's done that I've liked is he tr's a lot of the players I do but even then that's not a very good reason to warrant a townread.

[MariaR]

Kokichi are you going to say yes to Sakura by the way. I need to see who I want left out. I assume you're gonna say yes to her regardless but if not that'd be great.

[MariaR]

I'm not sure if I want to pair with Cakez atm given I'm not as widely townread as I was hoping to be. (Although considering I'm Maria I guess that's wishful thinking anyway)

[Kokichi Oma]

who else wants to dance with me?

[DVa]

Me giving a read list isn't anything weird

I mean you didn't do anything near a reads list in Boundaries of Reality, but I guess that game was really short

Of the three of these you have been in, you didn't give a reads list in Midsummer Night's Revelry (where you were town) or New Year's Eve (where you were scum), but you did in Valentine's Dance (where you were also scum) and I haven't seen any of your games where you throw down a reads list as your very first post

I'm not gonna say it's antitown or scummy it just throws me off since my impression of you in Boundaries of Reality was a lot more laid back. Since you're a guy here and you literally cannot die in this phase of the game it's confusing to me why you would be trying really hard to be seen as protown. Since it feels like the other guys are bundles of apathy or freewheeling it (<3 Karmy) you coming in as unusually organized struck me

maybe you just hit the thread where there was already content so you felt like you could do a reads list. I dunno

[MariaR]

How do you feel about Sakura Chi Bri and sor @Dva

[DVa]

RadiantCowbells -- pretty much signing up to die during intermission

Would dance
Karmeleon
Kokichi Oma

Would dance if RC rejected top two picks
SirCakez
Brian Skies
shortaru

Dunnstral
Dunnstral

Would dance with the assumption I will suicide at start of first dance
Gamma Emerald

[MariaR]

Please never auto suicide it's one of the major factors on why town loses this set up over winning. It's best to lynch yourself.

[DVa]

How do you feel about Sakura Chi Bri and sor @Dva

Still like Sakura for town, I need at least four more posts from Chibi before I can make a decision there, Brian defaults to town since there's scummier people in the game,

is sor "Shortaru"? If so I'd say he's town but I think he's wrong on most of his reads

[DVa]

Please never auto suicide it's one of the major factors on why town loses this set up over winning. It's best to lynch yourself.

Sure, that's fine, just giving my sense of the pairing

[MariaR]

Well having opposite reads is more interesting/better than having the same I suppose. Can you go into more detail on Sakura for me.
Pedit: Fair enough.

[DVa]

You're already markedly different than in BoR so unless I have a reason to scumread you I'd say you're not likely to be scum here.

This hasn't really changed. I felt like I had identified Sakura as my 3rd top pick for scum fairly early in BoR (the only of my top three to be correct) so I'm feeling more confident about my ability to correctly sort her as a result. Tonally she feels a lot more town to me here than she did there. I think that if she was scum here she would be pinging me more by now.

What posts from her do you find scummy?

[ChibiBear]

Ok so this is going to be a really dumb question but I don't think it's ever been explicitly stated, if a gentleman accepts a dance invite then it's final right, can't be changed again at any point?