Because results alone are very weak evidence. How many times do I have to say this? In my first town game on this site, I was investigated guilty despite being town. I was mislynched.In post 2498, skitter30 wrote:ok why were you most paranoid of him if you had an inno result on him? this is the part i'm not following
I was most paranoid of you & NSG, but I knew NSG wasn't committing the nightkill based on the roleblock, and I decided that clearing Gamma was more important that checking you because he was still under a lot of pressure to be lynched, especially after Koki's flip.In post 2498, skitter30 wrote:ok why were you most paranoid of him if you had an inno result on him? this is the part i'm not following
In post 2500, Shoshin wrote:Because results alone are very weak evidence. How many times do I have to say this? In my first town game on this site, I was investigated guilty despite being town. I was mislynched.In post 2498, skitter30 wrote:ok why were you most paranoid of him if you had an inno result on him? this is the part i'm not following
I've seen countless games where investigative results were wrong. I don't trust them. Period.
In post 2501, Shoshin wrote:I do trust Varsoon saying he roleblocked NSG, no nightkill happening, and Gammagooey immediately killing him to prevent him from telling us who he roleblocked. That set of events is strongly indicative that NSG is scum.
ok this is what i was looking forIn post 2502, Shoshin wrote:Like, that's night/day vs me getting an innocent result on someone that could be a godfather or lawyered or when I could have been redirected or bus drove whatever.
because i don't process teh game the same way you doIn post 2499, Shoshin wrote:Gamma's alignment doesn't turn on why I tracked him. You need to read Gamma on his own terms. I'm giving you the exact reasons why Gamma is town. You seem unable to accept the strong probabilistic evidence. Why?In post 2496, skitter30 wrote:i can believe that you strongly believed that
i don't understand why you tracked him the next night then
What altgameIn post 2512, skitter30 wrote:nuance of thought in real-time (it's lke way different from her last few scumgames)
although as i typed htis i realize i need to check that altgame at some point
In post 2347, northsidegal wrote:it's not like anything was really sacrificed from that sequence of events. a fruit vend is pretty useless and unless they were concerned about some remaining investigative or something then using what they have in a series of events designed such that the complicated nature of things makes it look like they're not partnered is just the smart thing to do.
In post 2353, northsidegal wrote:i mean i think this whole time we've also been assuming that shoshin has been telling the truth about having switcheroo but if shoshin and gamma are both scum that isn't even necessarily true, is it?
In post 2360, northsidegal wrote:also honestly i think shoshin's most recent play (maybe even her play ever since around day 2 / 3) makes sense in the context of having some kind of strategy where even if you're scummy you still win - if i had that strategy then i would probably not really put in all that much effort because you just wouldn't even really need to. it might even be better tonotput in effort to get people to scumread you and buy into the lie of switcheroo and then lynch your claimed "target"
^^^ these onesIn post 2395, northsidegal wrote:also looking back there's the fact that shoshin's vote was the one that allowed him to self hammer rather than letting everyone agree on who would vote and get the gold