A Story Revisited (Anything uPick): Day 6

[Shoshin]

VOTE: NSG

[northsidegal]

hahaha

[Shoshin]

Yep.

Porkens is town, though. For sure.

[northsidegal]

i agree with you there!

[Lady Angel]

Oh, it was a inner joke because I'm nihilist IRL.

For the record, the former response is not game related in any way?

Hm. That potentially changes things. Not for the creature/mastina thing, but for the creature scumclaiming thing.

I advocate a rolecop on Creature if possible.

Considering that you refuse to even consider the possibility that mastina might be scum who is fakeclaiming, I will refuse to even consider your request.

And now you're a cop again.

I'm starting to think your role is entirely dependent on whether it's an odd or even numbered page at any given moment. Either way, I think that the fact that you're dragging this claim on is stupid and your constant grouping of Mastina/Jingle/JJH kind of sucks, since it's just Mastina + the two people who most vocally believed you were scum.

I'd like to know what the flavour Creature got on Mastina actually is before I do anything. It's easy to say you've gotten a guilty but I'll believe it when there's actual evidence.

On another note, VOTE: NicoRobin

This is easily the scummiest slot in the game.

[Shoshin]

Nice! What are your other reads?

I've got Creature, Porkens, jjh, and Jingle as town so far.

[Shoshin]

NSG replaced Nancy's slot? Hmm, why'd Nancy replace out the game? I feel like she's more likely to do that as scum than town.

[Shoshin]

Though to be fair, Nancy's play felt pretty town in the early part of the game.

[Jingle]

And now you're a cop again.

Her not being a rolecop would violate the second of RC's game specific rules. TBF, so does Shoshin's role, but this would be an explicit violation and not an implicit one.

She is confirmed a rolecop.

[northsidegal]

Nice! What are your other reads?

I've got Creature, Porkens, jjh, and Jingle as town so far.

NSG replaced Nancy's slot? Hmm, why'd Nancy replace out the game? I feel like she's more likely to do that as scum than town.

i agree with all of those townreads (although with jingle being the weakest of them)

i think firebringer, wheme and vecna are town, although all with less strength than the people you mentioned

i think aristophanes is probably scum

also, i think nancy's replacing out had something to do with hydra shenanigans more than her wanting to replace out. don't really remember for sure, though.

[northsidegal]

by the way, just realized that my super secret tell on skygazer was correct

[Shoshin]

Yeah, Jingle's my weakest by far. I really don't like the way he's reading Mastina vs Creature.

Why Aristophanes?

[Shoshin]

He replaced random? I had random as town in the early game.

[Shoshin]

Yeah, just checked my notes. Random's town, so Aristophanes is as well.

[Shoshin]

Can you explain the townreads on Fire, Wheme, and Vecna? If we can narrow this game down to poe, we'll be in a pretty good position to win.

[Jingle]

the two people who most vocally believed you were scum.

I haven't ever believed NR was scum, afair.

I believe she's a good gladiate target, but I don't believe she's scum.

In fact, I'm pretty sure the only person who thinks I believe NR is scum is NR.

[Creature]

I'd like to know what the flavour Creature got on Mastina actually is before I do anything.

I want to see what mastina will claim first.

[Creature]

15) This setup is bastard* (not really).

Hmmm

[Creature]

2) Whether the setup is bastard or not, there will not be any mechanics that involve lying to players outside of standard fare (ninjas, godfathers).

Oh

[Lady Angel]

NSG replaced Nancy's slot? Hmm, why'd Nancy replace out the game? I feel like she's more likely to do that as scum than town.

We're not supposed to talk about Nancy's Hydra getting replaced, apparently.

I townread Creature, Jjh, Jingle, and Nero Cain the most. Mastina'd be a tr based on the fact that Varsoon risked everything to try and get her lynched but I'm waiting to see what Creature actually has right now.

I don't really overtly scumread anyone except NicoRobin, although Firebringer's a bit up there that might just be because of his adamance to lynch Mastina.

[Shoshin]

Lady, why townread Nero? Why scumread Nico?

[Jingle]

HurtCount 4.3:

Ineligible Players:

Adalbert:
Mastina: (4) Firebringer, Creature, Meme Men, Aristophanes

Eligible Players

Firebringer: (5) Vecna, Lady Angel, Mastina, Meme Men, Vecna
Nicorobin: (4) Invisibility, JJH, Meme Men, Jingle, Lady Angel
Creature: (4) Meme Men, Vecna, Adalbert Steiner, Jingle
Whemestar: (4) Meme Men, Vecna, Creature, Jingle
Northsidegal: (3) Nero Cain, Meme Men, Shoshin
Aristophanes: (2) NSG, Meme Men
jjh927: (2) Porkens, Meme Men
Gamma Emerald: (2) Meme Men, Vecna
Nero Cain: (2) Meme Men, Vecna
Jingle: (1) Meme Men
Vecna: (1) Meme Men
Lady Angel: (1) Meme Men
The MEME Men: (1) Meme Men
Porkens: (1) Meme Men
Invisibility: (1) Meme Men
Shoshin: (1) Meme Men

With 18 alive, 10 is the proposed Gladiate Threshhold. If you want to reduce or increase the threshold, please indicate as such.



UNVOTE:

[Jingle]

I perpetually forget to update one of the number of voters parts.

Nico has 5 voters.

[Lady Angel]

Lady, why townread Nero? Why scumread Nico?

I get the same vibe from Nero as I do from JJh, although moreso day 1 than now.

Nico claimed a guilty on mastina in the worst way possible and has just generally been completely nonsensical. The fact that she's constantly switched her role back and forth and is refusing to provide any explanation for anything she's done beyond "Mastina is scum and you guys are stupid for not being able to see it" just makes it worse.

[Jingle]

Hm.

What does buddying mean to you in a mafia context?

@shoshin.