Mini Theme 2043: You've Got Mail - Game Over!

[Celestial Coordinates]

Creature is transparently obvscum and kokichi is 99.9% the other scum

Gamma has been transparently obvtown from the beginning

Everything else is bullshit

Why does scum!Creature do a 180 on TIC?

Why is TIC voting molla over Creature?

Something isn’t adding up if you’re theory is correct.

Why has scum!Creature been hardtown reading Gamma and implying that it’s molla/Kokichi?

Because people do things
Stop ovrranalyzing and making random conclusions
None of this is significant

You making this critical generalizations don’t clarify jack. You need specific arguments.

[Celestial Coordinates]

At any rate,

I strongly urge that we don’t mag before Carca replacement

. They can shed some light on alleged Gamma N2 message.

Anyone disagree with this?

[Creature]

I don't intend to end the day anytime soon anyway

[Creature]

Actually Creature, these posts seem to contradict each other.

How?

[Creature]

I disagree that scum doesn’t try to save you here. With Thor flip, I think the only reason scum busses at this point, is self-pres.

Sure, they could decide to save their partner, but the current claims allow scum to safely bus here. It's not Epic Duel again.

[Wisdom]

nancy there are plenty of posts that gamma and tic dont make as scum here
you just need to read them

also i prefer kokichi to creature after rereading

VOTE: kokichi

[Wisdom]

I was thinking Thor’s reaction to his wrong result was towny until I got the feeling he was positioning CC in a weird way
Any objections to just hammering? I might be heading to bed soon.

As an example. Scum-Gamma does not need to add weird reasons like this or even mention he had started townreading him. Scum-Gamma just declares thor scum and hammers. He had plenty of reasons. This is town-Gamma expressing his exact train of thoughts as it came to him.

[ThoseInCharge]

So I've decided
VOTE: BBmolla

Votecount 1.09

shortaru :
Carcalilly:
SirCakez:
Fuwa Fuwa Time (3): ThoseInCharge, Creature, Carcalilly
Gamma Emerald : Thor665
Thor665 (3): Celestial Coordinates, shortaru, SirCakez
Celestial Coordinates:
ThoseInCharge (5): Wisdom, Flubbernugget, Gamma Emerald, BBmolla, Fuwa Fuwa Time
Flubbernugget:
Creature: Akarin
BBmolla:
Wisdom:
Akarin:


Not voting : no one
No lynch: no one
With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Day 1 ends on (expired on 2018-11-07 16:12:53)

-----------
Moderator notes: Akarin failed to pick up their prod, searching for replacement at the moment

Votecount 1.10

shortaru :
Carcalilly:
SirCakez:
Fuwa Fuwa Time (3): ThoseInCharge, Creature, Carcalilly
Gamma Emerald : Thor665
Thor665 (2): Celestial Coordinates, SirCakez
Celestial Coordinates:
ThoseInCharge (6): Wisdom, Flubbernugget, Gamma Emerald, BBmolla, Fuwa Fuwa Time, shortaru
Flubbernugget:
Creature: Akarin
BBmolla:
Wisdom:
Akarin:


Not voting : no one
No lynch: no one
With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Day 1 ends on (expired on 2018-11-08 16:12:53)

-----------
Moderator notes: In the search for a replacement, the deadline has been extended an additional 24 hours. In addition, Creature & BBmolla have been prodded.
You can find the comprehensive game notes in post 1

Kokichi Oma replaces Akarin

Votecount 1.11

shortaru :
Carcalilly:
SirCakez:
Fuwa Fuwa Time : Creature
Gamma Emerald : Thor665
Thor665 (6): Celestial Coordinates, SirCakez, shortaru, ThoseInCharge, Gamma Emerald, Wisdom
Celestial Coordinates:
ThoseInCharge (4): Flubbernugget, BBmolla, Fuwa Fuwa Time, Carcalilly
Flubbernugget:
Creature: Akarin
BBmolla:
Wisdom:
Akarin:


Not voting : no one
No lynch: no one
With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Day 1 ends on (expired on 2018-11-08 16:12:53)

-----------
Moderator notes: none at the moment

Votecount 1.12

shortaru :
Carcalilly (2): Celestial Coordinates, shortaru
SirCakez : Wisdom
Fuwa Fuwa Time : Creature
Gamma Emerald : Thor665
Thor665 (3): SirCakez, ThoseInCharge, Gamma Emerald
Celestial Coordinates:
ThoseInCharge (4): Flubbernugget, BBmolla, Fuwa Fuwa Time, Carcalilly
Flubbernugget:
Creature: Kokichi Oma
BBmolla:
Wisdom:
Kokichi Oma:


Not voting : no one
No lynch: no one
With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Day 1 ends on (expired on 2018-11-08 16:12:53)

-----------
Moderator notes: Creature shall be replaced if he doesn't pick up his prod by tonight PST on 11/7! For more game notes, see post 1

events

I was thinking about these votecounts, and what caught my eye was Creature and the Kokichi slot being off both wagons. Which means that if Creature and Kokichi are the remaining scum, there are no scum on their partner or their counterwagon, which I find very weird.
Hence a Creature/Kokichi team is unlikely here, so under my current PoE BBmolla is likely scum.

That doesn’t explain why you’d vote molla over obvscum like Creature.

This vote is weird to me. It’s one thing to think molla is scum and entirely different to vote him here. Creature should be the obvious lynch today, not molla.

Especially, if you are convinced Creature is obvscum.

Creature is much higher scum equity than molla. Why would you not vote him here?

Molla is probable scum but not lockscum, as is Creature.

Why would you risk a possible mislynch here?

I'm not lockscuming Creature.

I think the remaining scum are in {BBmolla, Creature, Kokichi Oma}. Since I think it's not Creature/Koki, it's either BB/Creature or BB/Koki, hence the BBmolla vote.

[ThoseInCharge]

Having said that, UNVOTE:

Creature and Kokichi are getting scummier for me

[ThoseInCharge]

Creature is just pretty blatant genuine town but whatever makes you not lynch him idc

Actually this gives me BBmolla/Kokichi vibes

[ThoseInCharge]

Oh yeah let's not lynch anyone before Carca comes back/gets replaced as I think that slot has some vital information

[ThoseInCharge]

But I find it very weird that Creature has been saying "If I'm partners with X" a lot this Day phase.

I have zero experience with Creature though, so I'm not sure about his meta

[ThoseInCharge]

not seeing why thats unlikely

Actually can you help me here? What's unlikely about 2 scum being off both wagons if scum is hard defending its counterwagon?

[ThoseInCharge]

Eh idk about Kokichi being scum. For some reason I always get a feeling of ingenuity whenever he states a scumread but it may be just me

[Wisdom]

i dont get it

creature and kokichi were off thor/tic wagons

and? Why is that weird or unlikely?

[ThoseInCharge]

So scum were not bussing their buddy, and they were not jumping on the counterwagon to save their buddy

Then what were they doing?

[Wisdom]

lurking? Why would it be necessary for them to do something?

[Creature]

Do you consider Kokichi a lurker this game?

[Wisdom]

yes

[Kokichi Oma]

Having said that, UNVOTE:

Creature and Kokichi are getting scummier for me

Look at this parroting

[Kokichi Oma]

i dont get it

creature and kokichi were off thor/tic wagons

and? Why is that weird or unlikely?

When? I was on thor?

[Kokichi Oma]

If you mean day 1, I wasnt there and when I replaced in, YOU were the one yelling at me to vote cakes when time was running low

[Kokichi Oma]

Do you consider Kokichi a lurker this game?

yes

Wisdom you know that I'm known for posting more as scum than town so what are you even doing at this point

[Wisdom]

keep scumposting its making me confident

[Celestial Coordinates]

nancy there are plenty of posts that gamma and tic dont make as scum here
you just need to read them

also i prefer kokichi to creature after rereading

VOTE: kokichi

You are game throwing with this vote. Kokichi is locktown due to lack of associatives.

Creature set him up to be the lynch following molla.

No way is Kokichi ever w/w with Creature here.

Everyone but us, has thrown him under the bus, apparently including his partner. Why does that not concern you at all?