A Story Revisited (Anything uPick): Day 6

[Lady Angel]

VOTE: NicoRobin

If she and NSG aren't aligned with each other, then I don't see any reason to keep her around. Worst case scenario is this flips town and we lynch NSG tomorrow anyways, but if there's garaunteed 1 scum in these two slots then we might as well get started with the scummier one.

I guess one of them could also be indie but I feel like if they were town-friendly indies they would've claimed it by now.

[Gamma Emerald]

Curious why MEME MEN didn’t ask nsg the question they asked Nico

[Aristophanes]

Firthermore, you made a mistake scumreading mastina yesterday

???

[Aristophanes]

tmi

Okay, I still need this new term explained.

I know TMI is "Too Much Info."
But I have seen it used as someone townspewing a few times and here it seems to be leadjng to a scumread and I just...
Someone help me!

[NicoRobin]

Firthermore, you made a mistake scumreading mastina yesterday

???

Typo.

[NicoRobin]

VOTE: NicoRobin

If she and NSG aren't aligned with each other, then I don't see any reason to keep her around. Worst case scenario is this flips town and we lynch NSG tomorrow anyways, but if there's garaunteed 1 scum in these two slots then we might as well get started with the scummier one.

I guess one of them could also be indie but I feel like if they were town-friendly indies they would've claimed it by now.

So why is jjh town exactly? For defending scum to the death? Because either he is scum or he is a self-centered idiot, and in both cases he needs to die before he dooms us.

[NicoRobin]

VOTE: NicoRobin

If she and NSG aren't aligned with each other, then I don't see any reason to keep her around. Worst case scenario is this flips town and we lynch NSG tomorrow anyways, but if there's garaunteed 1 scum in these two slots then we might as well get started with the scummier one.

I guess one of them could also be indie but I feel like if they were town-friendly indies they would've claimed it by now.

So why is jjh town exactly? For defending scum to the death? Because either he is scum or he is a self-centered idiot who refuses to learn from his mistakes, and in both cases he needs to die before he dooms us.

EBWOP

[NicoRobin]

And you, you too were all like 'fearmongering, fearmongering'. Where is my fearmongering now, huh? Where is it?

[NicoRobin]

This all is a farce, isn't it.

You are scumreading a player who called you out on you bs multiple times. You want to get rid of me because I dared to do so, admit it.

[NicoRobin]

And then you yell TMI to hide the fact that you townread her with unreal confidence and shut me up whenever I tried to tell you otherwise.

[THE MEME MEN]

In what way? The rolecop vs tracker/watcher nonsense you mean?

yeah. RC specifically told me that my role would be revealed, not my action.

Let. Me. Write. This. In. A. Way. You. Can. Understand.

I. Have. A. Misleading. Role.

Why. Do. You. Think. You. Can. Understand. My. Own. Role. Better. Than. I. Can. ?

To be clear you're not claiming miller or miller like functionality right?
Rh

[jjh927]

I mean my mistake was assuming she was town because her scumplay was so suboptimal it was insane


I was correct on her telling the truth about her role

[jjh927]

Btw I didn't order a pizza but I wasn't gonna say no

[jjh927]

Something was missing though

[THE MEME MEN]

Curious why MEME MEN didn’t ask nsg the question they asked Nico

I think it was getting obvious I had something, but yeah she should confirm she is not

-rh

[THE MEME MEN]

tmi

Okay, I still need this new term explained.

I know TMI is "Too Much Info."
But I have seen it used as someone townspewing a few times and here it seems to be leadjng to a scumread and I just...
Someone help me!

Yes, that is the risk. With Nico, we are faced with a choice:
did she have a strong early game scumread of Mastina that was correct and her push was a townspew, because she is town
or
did she know mastina was scum and wanted towncred for an early bus, because she is scum

only one of those is what actually happened, and if we want to lynch the correct person in what still looks like a 50/50 we need to answer it correctly

-rh

[NicoRobin]

I mean my mistake was assuming she was town because her scumplay was so suboptimal it was insane


I was correct on her telling the truth about her role

No, you weren't. You kept saying she is loyal, when she was in fact, disloyal.

[Jingle]

I wasn't targeted by a loud doc per se, but by a loud babysitter. Thought I'd get that out of the way.

Well there goes that bit of WIFOM.

Probs still means NR is town barring another kill prevention mechanic though.

Might have two guilties today.

[Jingle]

Oh, nvm. My result wasn't a guilty. just the one then.

[Jingle]

I know TMI is "Too Much Info."

Basically my use of TMI was to say that she was too sure of herself about the mastina read. Like, 0 doubt in her mind, mastina was flipping scum in twilight. Which came across as scum, because town has no reason to arbitrarily increase the strength of their reads post hammer.

[NicoRobin]

I know TMI is "Too Much Info."

Basically my use of TMI was to say that she was too sure of herself about the mastina read. Like, 0 doubt in her mind, mastina was flipping scum in twilight. Which came across as scum, because town has no reason to arbitrarily increase the strength of their reads post hammer.

Says someone who had 0 doubt that mastina was town.

[Jingle]

Also, you are a liar. You said you would apologize to me in public if she flipped scum. Where is that apology, Jingle?

I don't want to make a sig bet, because I can't remember if those are allowed. But I'll apologize somehow if mastina ends up endgaming town despite the fact that I've literally been advocating she die before endgame since I replaced in.

I see no chance of mastina endgaming town, therefore no chance that I will need to apologize.



Also, I fixed the typos in my original post.

[Jingle]

Says someone who had 0 doubt that mastina was town.

Should I go through and dig up all of the posts I make about if mastina is scum? Really? Cause I can, but that seems like a giant waste of my time.

Either way, the combo of you being the protection last night, there likely being no other protections, and the missing kill means you're probably town here.

[NicoRobin]

Says someone who had 0 doubt that mastina was town.

Should I go through and dig up all of the posts I make about if mastina is scum? Really? Cause I can, but that seems like a giant waste of my time.

Either way, the combo of you being the protection last night, there likely being no other protections, and the missing kill means you're probably town here.

Do I need to dig up all the quotes where you outright refused to get her lynched even if she were scum?

[Jingle]

Sure. They prove that I was using her role to find conftown.

Conftown we now have.

I'm glad we can agree I did that clearly protown thing.