A Story Revisited (Anything uPick): Day 6

[Nero Cain]

So far all JJ has done is talk about how Mastina is town, naked voted Sky and OMGUS voted Gingie/Jingle.

Kuroi had already pointed this out but

Not convinced it's actually towny looking content

what content is "not towny" looking? Let's ignore the fake dayvig, like if ppl want to town read me for that fine and if you don't then that's ok. I mean, I could argue "why in the world do you think a fake daykill is AI." but the fake daykill isn't the sum total of my content. So talk to me about it.

Nah I don't think you're scum; I just phrased "I don't know what's going on there" in a more loaded way in hope that people would jump in on the discussion

Is a hedge.

Wheme, you were in GSGDM. Do you think this vizzy looks the same because I really don't


I do think you popping up with an unorthodox scumread looks pretty bad for you though

This seems like his only scumhunting post so far.

As of 739 he's calling all of Vax, Wheme and Skygazer scum.

Now he is naked voting Lady Angel.

There was a bunch of stuff about him trying to figure out Vecna's role or somthing weird like that.

He then hops on the Pork wagon.

Now he's voting Vecna b/c he believes its a fake post restriction.

Now he's voting Kuroi apparently just so Mastina uses her ability on him.

I mean holy shit this guy as 4 more pages to go but so far all I'm seeing is random vote hopping, he doesn't really seem to commit to his scum reads and not alot of scum hunting.

[Nero Cain]

VOTE: unvote

[Nero Cain]

Had also wanted to say that his kinda saving grace is that he did vote Titus near EOD. Though I guess the other way you could look at it is he voted her when she was in no danger and thus it was distancing *shrugz*

[Creature]

2. Creature's claim was quite literally that Mastina's role had four As in her name or something like that. That is in no way, shape, or form a guilty and the only reason you can call it such is because of hindsight bias. Hell, my own role name has four As in it - am I scum, too?

mastina had four As in role name and one A in flavor.

Also does your role have four As?

[Creature]

here's me catching jjh as scum on page 5, before i even knew about his meta. later on in the day i

did

look at his meta and it made things even more obvious.


i'm honestly getting kind of tired of talking so much about jjh and why he's town and i don't understand how or why people keep asking me about it.

jjh is outed?

[Creature]

If it's 6 mafia, then it's Nico,

Invis

, Nero, and one of Jingle, Gamma, or Lady Angel.

lmao

[jjh927]

That along with the no lynch vote on eod 4? That's also suspect of jjh.

I would like you to expand on this if possible

[Lady Angel]

2. Creature's claim was quite literally that Mastina's role had four As in her name or something like that. That is in no way, shape, or form a guilty and the only reason you can call it such is because of hindsight bias. Hell, my own role name has four As in it - am I scum, too?

mastina had four As in role name and one A in flavor.

Also does your role have four As?

So mine's the near opposite after checking the role PM - one A in role name and three As in flavour, for four total.

If you were to cop that, it would tell you nothing alignment-indicative, just that my role name has four As in it overall.

[Nero Cain]

As of 2021 he's random voting Gamma.

while I can see the argument for Nos scum I also can't accept it at all

hedges on Nos a bit here. This would be really important if Ari flips scum.

Now he's sheeping me on R&L.

Another naked vote on Titus.

Random vote on Wheme.

A kinda random vote on Gin. Like his argument was that Gin is scum that doesn't kill Mastina b/c Mastina town reads him. I said it was a leap.

He's back to voting Wheme b/c he believes Wheme is playing like he did as 3p.

Now he's voting Chick b/c it might "gain traction"

So begins the JJ/Nico sparring match.

The rest of this page (and prob the next 3) are mainly about him going apeshit on Nico. I guess its minorly important to mention that there was a no kill and in his mind that meant Nico's team targeted him.

[Jingle]

It occurs to me that every piece of evidence for NR town has a completely rational alternative explanation, and all of the grey area setup spec items for me are based on/around that role.

I'm gone tonight, but as soon as jj

Za Warudo's and attempts to unvote

I'm going to vote there.

[Jingle]

Also, Creature. Vecna is a good target for your ability. He's fullclaimed flavor and the number of A's in his role might be indicative. Can't think of anyone else off the top of my head, but I'll try to figure out if anyone elses claim could be corroborated.

Meme Men might have an outrageous number of A's? They certainly seem complicated enough to.

[Nero Cain]

Jingle, what were your targets?

[Creature]

So mine's the near opposite after checking the role PM - one A in role name and three As in flavour, for four total.

I got 1 in role name and 1 in flavor :/

[Nero Cain]

I have 2 A's. One before the comma wich I guess is my role and 1 the comma which I guess is flavor.

[Nero Cain]

or maybe 2 A's in flavor and 2 in my role. I'm not really sure.

[jjh927]

Yo guys so I can actually get it out of the way

ZA WARUDO in (expired on 2018-12-01 23:00:00)

[jjh927]

If you're voting at that time then it's your own fault

[jjh927]

I gave plenty of notice

[Lady Angel]

So mine's the near opposite after checking the role PM - one A in role name and three As in flavour, for four total.

I got 1 in role name and 1 in flavor :/

For me?

[Nero Cain]

He's actully sparring with Jingle alot. Scum theatre?

As of 3474 he's backing down on Jingle.

A minorly important event has happened: he's town reading NSG b/c he felt like IC was town.

though at the end of page 3 it seems like his opinion on Mastina is changing just a little bit though I guess you could always argue that he's reading the room and she's the Mastina hate growing and that maintianing his stance that she's town is suicide. But then he goes back to just town reading her.

The rest of his ISO is mainly pushing Nico with some small tunnels on Jingle and Ari.

I guess my feelings are that it's kinda null that he town read Mastina so hard. Like yeah, its possible he's just wrong town but its certainly possible that he defends her so hard. I'm somewhat tempted to town read him based on voting Titus and sparring with Jingle (who I also feel is scummy). Although I'm not seeing this great play and in depth thinking that NSG and Vecna are claiming. I mean, he asks a few people about their role but that seems more like rolefishing than "setup spec". I'll hold for the incoming "scum wouldn't blatantly fish so hard" argument. He was also town reading Varsoon a bit up until he used his role. I think its totally possible that the Varsoon wagon was a bus to make Mastina look better.
.

[Nero Cain]

If you're voting at that time then it's your own fault

Doesn't freezing votes make us no lynch?

[jjh927]

No

[jjh927]

People who aren't voting can't switch their votes

[jjh927]

People who aren't voting can switch their votes

Whoops ebwop

[Nero Cain]

My biggest worry about JJH is not that he defended Mastina so much but his early game was just directionless vote hopping. I'd expect town to be a little more tunnely (like he is now).