Mini Normal 2044: Game over!

[Persivul]

Plot twist: I was blocked last night.
VOTE: sash

[Sashaddin]

Who did you target?

Why is this a twist? What did you think would happen?

[Persivul]

Who did you target?

That info isn't free.

Why is this a twist? What did you think would happen?

967

[Irrelephant11]

dumb

[Sashaddin]

dumb

What is?

[Sashaddin]

It should resolve tomorrow. Unless scum have a RB, they have to kill me tonight. If garmr's a scum MD, it's doubtful they also have a RB.

It was doubtful to you, yet you predicted what happened. What is there to think about this?

[Irrelephant11]

dumb

What is?

Plot twist: I was blocked last night.
VOTE: sash

[Sashaddin]

That info isn't free.

What do you want, need... and from whom?

[Persivul]

That info isn't free.

What do you want, need... and from whom?

Claims, preferably in the order:

Sash
Irrel
Clem
bji

[Persivul]

It should resolve tomorrow. Unless scum have a RB, they have to kill me tonight. If garmr's a scum MD, it's doubtful they also have a RB.

It was doubtful to you, yet you predicted what happened. What is there to think about this?

No, the opposite of what I said happened. Hence, twist.

[Persivul]

@Irrel - trial balloons are scummy af.

[Irrelephant11]

I don't know what that sentence means
I'm happy to claim in that order

[bji]

Persivul, why would Sash kill Reaper instead of you? Even if he were roleblocker, I think your level of play is higher than everyone else's here so I would expect Sash to want to get rid of you instead of a player (Reaper) who wasn't really contributing anything to town's chances of winning other than being a warm body.

Furthermore, you are I were both agreeing to vote Sash today. So Sash could predict that he would already have two firm votes today, and only needing one more to be lynched, it seems that his only hope would be to eliminate you and hope that two other town besides me wouldn't vote him.

Additionally, your elimination was expected and so wouldn't really give much info about who the scum was.

The question then becomes, is Sash really ballsy enough to count on the above conclusions and do the opposite to throw us off his track? No offense Sash, but I don't think so.

In my opinion scum is either Clem or Irrelephant.

I need to read more to see which player was more likely to kill Reaper than you. Again, busy with work, not sure when I will be able to do this, probably tonight.

[Sashaddin]

Claims, preferably in the order:

Sash
Irrel
Clem
bji

I claim to be a normal towny. I probably won't be able to post until tonight. I really want to hear about the others too.

[Irrelephant11]

I think we resolve claims before entering the wifom-territory of "why is persivul alive"

pedit: assuming that means vt, I am also vt. I tried crumbing that I was minor investigative to eat a nightkill, but that failed

[Sashaddin]

Furthermore, you are I were both agreeing to vote Sash today. So Sash could predict that he would already have two firm votes today, and only needing one more to be lynched, it seems that his only hope would be to eliminate you and hope that two other town besides me wouldn't vote him.

Additionally, your elimination was expected and so wouldn't really give much info about who the scum was.

The question then becomes, is Sash really ballsy enough to count on the above conclusions and do the opposite to throw us off his track? No offense Sash, but I don't think so.

Putting on my scum pants, this is what I probably would have done. I agree with you, getting rid of the most vocal one sounds strategic.

Ballsy? No offense taken. I never claimed to be good at this.

[Irrelephant11]

Persivul, why would Sash kill Reaper instead of you? Even if he were roleblocker, I think your level of play is higher than everyone else's here so I would expect Sash to want to get rid of you instead of a player (Reaper) who wasn't really contributing anything to town's chances of winning other than being a warm body.

btw the answer to this question, regardless of who's scum, is that reaper was towncleared, whereas persivul was not (reaper only confirmed he was visited). Theoretically persivul could still be scum, so anyone else as scum has a greater chance of mislynching persivul here than mislynching reaper

garmr might have chosen the nightkill, too, scum have daychat
I stand by my assertion that this gamestate is dumb, though I guess I should be happier with one scum flip than I am

[Sashaddin]

I tried crumbing that I was minor investigative to eat a nightkill, but that failed

Is it something you try often?

[Irrelephant11]

I've tried it one other time recently, in a newbie game. It didn't work there either

[Irrelephant11]

fwiw I am townreading sash's more recent posts, even as I stand by my analysis of his early game & Garmr interactions

[Persivul]

I don't know what that sentence means

It means that, instead of making a point with your first two posts today, you were purposely vague - floating a trial balloon to see if someone might guess at your point and take it up. If no one does, you just let it die.
UNVOTE:

[Irrelephant11]

??
I was literally just expressing frustration at the fact that your status as semi-conf!town was removed & the implication scum has a pr. That's dumb, and I don't like it. There was nothing to "bite" because "dumb" implies.. nothing? that I can think of

[Persivul]

Persivul, why would Sash kill Reaper instead of you? Even if he were roleblocker, I think your level of play is higher than everyone else's here so I would expect Sash to want to get rid of you instead of a player (Reaper) who wasn't really contributing anything to town's chances of winning other than being a warm body.

Furthermore, you are I were both agreeing to vote Sash today. So Sash could predict that he would already have two firm votes today, and only needing one more to be lynched, it seems that his only hope would be to eliminate you and hope that two other town besides me wouldn't vote him.

Additionally, your elimination was expected and so wouldn't really give much info about who the scum was.

The question then becomes, is Sash really ballsy enough to count on the above conclusions and do the opposite to throw us off his track? No offense Sash, but I don't think so.

I largely agree with this. I didn't necessarily vote Sash because he's still my top scum read. But, two considerations:

- Garmr may have given NK instructions in scum chat. A point interestingly made by Irrel.
- A lot of scum are too fond of wifom in NK selection.

But yeah, I largely agree with you.

In my opinion scum is either Clem or Irrelephant.

I need to read more to see which player was more likely to kill Reaper than you. Again, busy with work, not sure when I will be able to do this, probably tonight.

I also need to do some re-reading and meta reading, but rn I'd say Irrel is more likely than Clem.

[Persivul]

Clem, your turn to claim.

[Irrelephant11]

I guess I have to consider that Persivul's continual shade-throwing in my direction could potentially come from scum trying to save the easier mislynch for lylo