Excalibur [Endgame]

[Nancy Drew 39]

Off to bed the Queen goes. Probably will check in tommorow. But Fire Will probs be dead, so...

See you day 3 I guess.

Not if you’re shooting me, you won’t.

[Gamma Emerald]

That also shifts my from from the “compromise” area to the “actual scumread” area for cherry picking evidence.

do you know what cherry picking is gamma?

Yes. It’s selectively presenting evidence to fit your narrative. You only presented the evidence that fit your claim of possibly being Arthur. I located evidence that was on the same page that discredited your claim. The fact you ignored when initially presenting means you cherry picked.

i didn't anywhere claim to be arthur, gamma.

Not the point, Arthur isn’t informed they’re Arthur so no point. No one seemed to claiming you are Arthur (though iirc Varsoon just posted something to the contrary) so that made you a better option
But again, no lynching let’s people more informed make the decision

[Gamma Emerald]

That also shifts my from from the “compromise” area to the “actual scumread” area for cherry picking evidence.

do you know what cherry picking is gamma?

Yes. It’s selectively presenting evidence to fit your narrative. You only presented the evidence that fit your claim of possibly being Arthur. I located evidence that was on the same page that discredited your claim. The fact you ignored when initially presenting means you cherry picked.

i didn't anywhere claim to be arthur, gamma.

like god i don't know how much simpler i can make this out to be.

lets back up gamma because theres some stupid miscommunication happening here and you aren't even attempting to bridge it.

You said: "No has claimed firebringer is arthur". The point of you saying that was nobody has made a serious claim that i am arthur and that the potential of me being arthur is low. [I am not disputing that, but you never said that]

I was focusing on what you said which is no one claimed i was arthur which was false.

If you want to have some stupid straw man argument with someone who thinks UT or NK15 claims of me being arthur are legitimate go find them. I am not arguing that shit.

In summary shut the hell up.

I never said serious claim because that was the implication. Not my fault you missed the subtext.
If you’re not disputing my point, there’s no real reason for me not to vote you right?
I’d say I like your olive branch but you telling me to shut up killed that.

[Gamma Emerald]

And IIRC, amidst all the fakeclaims, *no one* said Jay had the sword -- this means Jay's claim is pretty probably fake, which means he's scum.

*Ignored Varsoon vehemently saying I'm Auther and Kokichi's claim matching up with mine*

*Somebody's aiming for a bad time*

Varsoon also said MariaR had the sword.
So either Merlin!Varsoon is lying, or Varsoon isn't Merlin FYPOV.
Which is it?

Plus claiming Kokichi’s claim backs her up when Kokichi claims Arthur has the sword

[Gamma Emerald]

"One of me, Maria is lying. Her flip will tell us who. Firebringer is not part of this tho, so I want him killed."

I think this is scum!Jay screwing around after I pointed out the logical inconsistency.

Yeah
I’m going for Elsa instead of Kokichi D3 if we NL today

[Gamma Emerald]

Well arent you gonna look horrible when you die from doing gladitorial combat.

Lady challenged. Lady died. Fire challenged. Looks like fire dies.

Let's make it 3/3, fiendish knight. On the honor of the kingdom, I shall vanquish you.

Lol you think that’ll continue when you’re obvscum? Nice fearmongwring, but no one’ll buy it

[Gamma Emerald]

My running theory is dunnstral is town has the sword and is hard defending maria because he truly misguided believes she is town.

And usually i would ask dunny to come out and completely tell me the truth regarding this, but I can't rely on what he says.

This is very frustrating.

Also I was serious earlier when I said people don't listen to my MariaR read - She literally has the sword and is mod confirmed and people are theorizing situations where I'm biased and wrong on my read on her - then they have the audacity to say that their own read on her would be better than mine in that situation

Mod confirmed HOW?

[Gamma Emerald]

Because that defeats the purpose of all this mayhem I'm causing if I stab her.

My chaos has reason behind it.

Or, better theory:
Elsa is scum and doesn’t want to be caught lying

[Auro]

Plus claiming Kokichi’s claim backs her up when Kokichi claims Arthur has the sword

Well, Kokichi didn't say who Arthur is, so it's possible Jay has it and is Arthur.

[Gamma Emerald]

Yeah she asserted that could be the case
But ahe’s trying to play to two people’s claims at once. That’s not acceptable.

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: No lynch
This brings no lynch to 5 voters

[Auro]

I don't see why lunching Fire is such a bad option?

[Gamma Emerald]

No lynching forces scum to take initiative, which prolly reveals a lot about who they might be

[Auro]

What? No lunching only lets them pick us off one by one through night kills, at least with lunches we could hit scum. O.o
I don't exactly follow your logic here.

[Kokichi Oma]

Jay, how serious are you about having the sword?

Ai yai yai. Do I have to put it in my signature for you that I got the sword?

I mean, I already learned my lesson with signatures, so I ain't doing that, but you get the point.

So we lunch MariaR today, and if it turns out that she has the sword, lunch you D3. Sounds good?

Scum post

[Gamma Emerald]

What? No lunching only lets them pick us off one by one through night kills, at least with lunches we could hit scum. O.o
I don't exactly follow your logic here.

Not EVERY DAY dummy. Just for today when we have all this confusion.

[Kokichi Oma]

id rather shoot myself than consult kokichi on anything except for how bad he is and how to get better

Yeah ok buddy. Whatever helps you sleep at night.

[Auro]

What? No lunching only lets them pick us off one by one through night kills, at least with lunches we could hit scum. O.o
I don't exactly follow your logic here.

Not EVERY DAY dummy. Just for today when we have all this confusion.

So you're thinking scum would take initiative in the next 14 hours if we're all voting to No Lunch? I still don't follow, sorray

[Kokichi Oma]

JAY DOESNT HAVE SWORD. LYNCH FIRE

[Kokichi Oma]

NL ONLY HELPS SCUM. MY GOD

[Auro]

Jay, how serious are you about having the sword?

Ai yai yai. Do I have to put it in my signature for you that I got the sword?

I mean, I already learned my lesson with signatures, so I ain't doing that, but you get the point.

So we lunch MariaR today, and if it turns out that she has the sword, lunch you D3. Sounds good?

Scum post

Explain? Also lol, if I'm scum, who do you think are my buddies?

[Kokichi Oma]

Whoever is town and nling is so bad

[Auro]

NL ONLY HELPS SCUM. MY GOD

And I'm fighting against a No Lunch.
Are you towning Gamma and scumreading me?

[Kokichi Oma]

Jay, how serious are you about having the sword?

Ai yai yai. Do I have to put it in my signature for you that I got the sword?

I mean, I already learned my lesson with signatures, so I ain't doing that, but you get the point.

So we lunch MariaR today, and if it turns out that she has the sword, lunch you D3. Sounds good?

Scum post

Explain? Also lol, if I'm scum, who do you think are my buddies?

Not a town response. But lynch fire and I'll think it over

[Kokichi Oma]

@mod vote count