Excalibur [Endgame]

[Gamma Emerald]

Ok I see it now
Still want to know if anyone has actually cased fire

[Auro]

A: "Fire, a couple questions"
F: "I don't know, I don't care"
A: "How is this town? Vote: Fire"
F: "Frankly these are dumb questions to sort me"
F: "I'm offended you call me scummy"
F: "You didn't use my answer to sort me"
F: "Auro is scummy, do an ISO blah blah"

Looks a lot more scummy than towny to me. I seriously doubt a no lunch is better than lunching Fire.

I think this interaction, plus his bad reads list, is enough reason to vote him.

[Gamma Emerald]

@Gamma: What's your read on Fire? Town/null/scum?
If null, you should vote for him regardless of a case IMO

Maybe I will actually, but I want to see if a case exists before I do vote to evaluate the wagon
Also, I don’t want any hammers until Elsa posts again unless it’s <4 hours to deadline

[Gamma Emerald]

A: "Fire, a couple questions"
F: "I don't know, I don't care"
A: "How is this town? Vote: Fire"
F: "Frankly these are dumb questions to sort me"
F: "I'm offended you call me scummy"
F: "You didn't use my answer to sort me"
F: "Auro is scummy, do an ISO blah blah"

Looks a lot more scummy than towny to me. I seriously doubt a no lunch is better than lunching Fire.

I think this interaction, plus his bad reads list, is enough reason to vote him.

What’s the readlist he made? I don’t need an exact quote, just a quick list

[Auro]

i just realized i have a controversial opinion that chara might be scum.

so my list is looking
{Dva, Dunnstral}
{Jay, Varsoon}
{Nancy, Gamma Emerald}
{UT, Cakez, PenguinPower, Not Known15} <--null
{Auror, Chara}
{Kokichi, Maria}

[Auro]

deadline is in two days, so i suppose i'll read sooner than soonish.
unless someone has a major argument for Fire being town i'll lynch that, really. unless there's some mechanical reason that makes no-lynching preferable to flipping someone who could go either way*.

Speaking of which, Chara, vote?

[Gamma Emerald]

Hm...

[Auro]

Vote!

[Gamma Emerald]

I might. I have something I might like to present. I want to do it in proper fashion though.

[Auro]

I might. I have something I might like to present. I want to do it in proper fashion though.

When? Before the day ends?
Waiting to hear it.

[Kokichi Oma]

Vote fire. Stop being difficult

[Gamma Emerald]

Ok Maria has the sword. I wanted to see what everyone's reactions would be. Lynch fire

i just realized i have a controversial opinion that chara might be scum.

so my list is looking
{Dva, Dunnstral}
{Jay, Varsoon}
{Nancy, Gamma Emerald}
{UT, Cakez, PenguinPower, Not Known15} <--null
{Auror, Chara}
{Kokichi, Maria}

okay replace gamma with kokichi and we get a real good scum list

Okay so I had these out of order in my head, I thought the two quoted fire posted were in reverse order
So while my initial bust is invalid, I have a question for Fire: why are Elsa and Varsoon/Alchemist and UT, who would probably be Arthur and Merlin if it’s not Kokichi and Maria, not top tier for you?

[Kokichi Oma]

why should you want him to out that for scum

[Gamma Emerald]

Out what

[FakeGod]

VoteCount 2.5

Firebringer [6] - MariaR, Varsoon, Dunnstral, Kokichi Oma, Elsa Jay, Auro
MariaR [0] -
No Lynch [5] - Nancy Drew 39, Firebringer, DVa, Not Known 15, Gamma Emerald

Not Voting [4]

- Untrod Tripod, Chara, PenguinPower, SirCakez

With 15 alive it takes 8 votes to lynch.

Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2018-12-09 22:00:00)

[MariaR]

MariaR, how likely is it that Firebringer is scum? What do you think of the "Fire is 99.99% town" arguments? If Fire agrees not to gladiate you D3, would you vote No Lunch?

MariaR, once you answer this, I'll be ready to vote Fire again.

I would but I don't think he ever will/he'd do it anyway so it's weird.
I won't kick and scream at a no lynch but I'm keeping my vote

[SirCakez]

i'm here
I see it's either Fire or no lynch

[SirCakez]

I want to lynch Kokichi tomorrow, that Merlin fakeclaim was scummy af and his constant vomiting all over the thread is scummy too. He's playing like outed scum.
The slots that have been MIA all game are highly suspect to me as well, specifically the FA, Veridian and Ariane slots. None of the replacements have redeemed them. And I totally forgot UT was even in this game christ.

I'm talking about other people then the gladiates because I feel like the majority of the active people right now are town bickering. Feels like town cannibalizing. Which sucks.

And IIRC, amidst all the fakeclaims, *no one* said Jay had the sword -- this means Jay's claim is pretty probably fake, which means he's scum.

You're ignoring the decent chance that Elsa is just badtowning. Either way they prob need death before endgame unless they are legit about having the sword which is just ???? to me right now

VOTE: NoLynch

Look at this scum pop in without any content LOL


My gut is screaming Fire town but he will also just do the same thing tomorrow so it will probably have to be a PL :/. Fire is just a loose cannon.
I would no lynch if Fire would not gladiate Maria again tomorrow so we can instead lynch obvscum Kokichi or NK15
this game is extremely frustrating

[Kokichi Oma]

Lynch fire.

[SirCakez]

there are scummy people on both the fire and no lynch wagons
fire flip would be really useful but I also get the vibes it's what scum wants
somebody help me decide who is not kokichi b/c he is scum

[Auro]

You're ignoring the decent chance that Elsa is just badtowning. Either way they prob need death before endgame unless they are legit about having the sword which is just ???? to me right now

Haha, I'm not ignoring it -- there's a possibility, but it's more fruitful for him as scum anyway. I wanted to see if he'd retract his claim, but he seems to have kept it.

[Auro]

there are scummy people on both the fire and no lynch wagons
fire flip would be really useful but I also get the vibes it's what scum wants
somebody help me decide who is not kokichi b/c he is scum

Yeah I don't like the compositions on either wagon.
We should evaluate whether the Fire lunch actually benefits scum -- keeping him can actually be bad for town since he's not playing the game, and might lolgladiate again tomorrow, right?

[MariaR]

nk15 needs to die
UT needs to die
1 of auro/dva need to die and we'll revisit after that imo

[Kokichi Oma]

I'm Merlin. Stop calling me scum

[Kokichi Oma]

there are scummy people on both the fire and no lynch wagons
fire flip would be really useful but I also get the vibes it's what scum wants
somebody help me decide who is not kokichi b/c he is scum

I'm Merlin. I'm uncc'd. How dense can you be good sir.