A Story Revisited (Anything uPick): Day 6

[THE MEME MEN]

Isn't that literally the point of spoiler tags? To keep things readable?

I wasn't trying to shittalk you btw, I was saying that usually if a post has like 4+ spoilers I'm kinda expecting it to be reeeeeally long

-rh

[Creature]

Probably not northsidegal, not Nero, not Gamma, not jjh

Who else?

[Creature]

Oh prob not profii too

[Creature]

I'm using prob for some reason

Don't mind me

[Creature]

Shoshin can't be the nihilistic I guess

[Jingle]

I think jjh claimed he was nightkilled by scum and no one really had an alternative explanation for the missing nightkill that night

Alternate explanations are that Vecna JK'd mastina who made the kill or scum killed me for crumbing doc. The former makes more sense than JJ eating a kill, the latter is possibly even less likely than jj eating a kill.

[Creature]

Probably not Lady Angel

[Creature]

idk what Porkens is

[Creature]

If Nero is the vig, where are the kills though?

[THE MEME MEN]

shoshin is not the rber either imo

I wanna say Jingle... can't be the rber? or... uhh... hmm

main potentials for scum rber are:

Porkens slot
Lady Angel
maaaaybe Ari?
maaaaaaaaaaybe... not?... Vecna?

is vecna ruled out of being the rber mechanically cause I feel like I keep forgetting some of the miscellaneous shit in this game

I guess you think LA cannot be

so if it's not LA then it's probe Porkens slot then right? like isn't that the easiest explanation?

-rh

[THE MEME MEN]

I have a theory about Nero's missing kills but I don't want to discuss it since I don't think he's today's lynch

-rh

[Jingle]

Honestly, JJ's theory that the rb is factional or related to LA's dream makes a ton of sense.

But I still think that lynching Ari is the most likely to net real scum here, and failing that lynching me clears up the most questions. Vecna also clears up questions, but his role is actually useful to town if true at this point, unlike either mine or Ari's.

[Creature]

Oh right, prob not Vecna too

[Creature]

main potentials for scum rber are:

Porkens slot
Lady Angel
maaaaybe Ari?
maaaaaaaaaaybe... not?... Vecna?

Only these?

[Creature]

Actually yeah, Ari feels like the best lynch

Not sure if from mechanical PoV though

[Creature]

Probably not northsidegal, not Nero, not Gamma, not jjh

Who else?

Oh prob not profii too

Shoshin can't be the nihilistic I guess

Probably not Lady Angel

Oh right, prob not Vecna too

[Creature]

1) The MEME Men

2) Northsidegal
6) Gamma Emerald
10) Profii

12) Porkens

14) Vecna
15) Lady Angel

18) Jingle
19) Nero Cain (we gotta first prove his vig claim)
20) Creature (should I strike myself?)

21) jjh927

22) Aristophanes

23) Shoshin

[Jingle]

Meme can't be RB, I saw him get RB'd.

Nero bought a ticket to LYLO with the Wheme flip.

[Creature]

Great, that leaves Porkens' slot, Jingle and Ari from my PoV (still assuming we confirm Nero's claim soon)

You can include me if you wish

[Jingle]

I mean... Your role is maybe confirmed by Vec, I think, but you're not on my lynch plate regardless, FWIW.

Porkens/sheep is reflexive messenger apparently, but he could have more to it pretty easily.

[THE MEME MEN]

I think the thing with porkens is that he seemed way diff than in children of hurin but I haven't actually read him at all outside that game

I never really liked randomidget slot even tho some people thought he was townie for reasons I didn't get

Ari's claim was like really bad

>Ari claimed rb'ed 2 nights ago, but it's hard to understand why scum would rb him that night
>Ari claims he would never not rb as scum, but I haven't meta'd him to evaluate this claim
>Ari seems like a nice guy, maybe he'd be happier leaving this mess of a game?

I think claiming he was the subject of a rb is the main point in his favor but I also kinda don't believe it?

maybe VOTE: Ari -Shiro

gonna taste this one out


can also do porkens slot

-rh

[THE MEME MEN]

like really when the fuck does a hider hide behind a claimed investigative?

like what?

nothing about ari's claim makes any sense tbh

-rh

[THE MEME MEN]

oh right, he said he thought he was weak hider but then he said he misread his role pm...



-rh

[Aristophanes]

Ari's claim was like really bad

>Ari claimed rb'ed 2 nights ago, but it's hard to understand why scum would rb him that night
>Ari claims he would never not rb as scum, but I haven't meta'd him to evaluate this claim
>Ari seems like a nice guy, maybe he'd be happier leaving this mess of a game?

It was.

- It would make no sense, true.
- This is my meta to the best of my understanding but also I am bad at remembering my own meta so...
- Thanks! And also, thanks <3

[Aristophanes]

Regardless, its true so *shrugs* I don't knkw what else to say