I leave the game alone for an afternoon, and come back to find 10 pages....
Town reads on Flavour and Jingle have become stronger. Their whole debate, just sounds really like town with differing opinions. And I think Gamma is town. Early on he might not have had a lot really in his content, but now I feel he's engaging well now, and trying to help everyone get stuff done.
In post 2765, Jingle wrote: In post 2760, TheBrie wrote:As town, shouldn't she be pushing something? I'm puzzled as to what point you're trying to make here.
Dannflor is saying she's town because she's thrashing for any raft in the ocean while sinking (which is NAI not town) but she's not thrashing for any raft. She's swimming towards specific rafts while ignoring others that are just as close.
I'd think that's still NAI. Maybe even townie. Because the only ones scum are against lynching in that sort of a situation are partners. She still has clear lynch preference. Conversely, it could be said that you can't really go on all wagons, so she had to pick one over another, and thus it means nothing. (There I just argued myself around to no conclusion.)
In post 2800, Gamma Emerald wrote:Everyone’s being such a fucking stick in the mud whenever someone pushes a lynch they dislike In breaking this out:
@Everyone: what are your top 4 preferred lynches? In order please.
@Wagonimics I want to lynch xtoxm, Vax, Mastina, and Wisdom. I’m aware xtoxm and mastina aren’t scum together ever but there’s plenty of support for multiball both with what has been seen setup/event wise and with how the game is developing. Wisdom I don’t see happening but is one I feel rather confident in.
This also serves as an answer to my own question so thanks for keeping me on top of things.
I want Mastina flipped. I think Vax is scummy, and wouldn't be a bad lynch. But I think there's too much opposition there. And though I'm not seeing a strong case for Ausuka, I'd probably vote there if things went that way, just to get the day over. But I don't think things are going there.
I tend to notice the big posters, the movers of the game for than the quiet ones. Singletonking for example, is a little scummy, but just doesn't rank high enough on my radar for me to really care when there's no deadline forcing me to. So I end up with The Towny, the Meh, and the 'I Kinda thinks they're scum, really want to know their alignment, but I'm slightly paranoid of lynching a great town asset'.
In post 2989, Nancy Drew 39 wrote: In post 2974, Jingle wrote:So... Just gonna put this out there. Nanc might not be town. If she's still alive come day 6 or so, look hard at that slot.
Why? I’m not a PR, that’s why Cheeky was killed over me. This theory is ludicrous. Why would scum care about NKing a town neighbour? Have you thought about that?
That’s how I’m so confident on Purr being town. Unlike Jingle, she can actually read me correctly. Which is why she gave me the fruit,
Varsoon claimed to be a PR, and though that was day 2, I think he said something on Day 1. Which on looking for it, actually confirms the neighbours aren't PRs thing.
post 200 Basically said he could only talk privately. Which makes me surprised about how many of us believed his cop-gambit. But that's not relevant now. Point is, Mastina's argument there is rubbish, and a lot of her stuff is less solid that it looks at first glance.
So let's let Jingle do his hammer thing tomorrow if he really wants to hammer what he thinks is a bad lynch for today.
VOTE: Mastina
I've never mislynched which kinda surprises me.