Open 746: Bus Service [Game Over]

[TTTT]

Clem what's your read on me?

[Clemency]

day1 outside a newbie game and Clem is writing complete sentences?
things that make you go hmmm

ah shit he got me again

[Clemency]

i'm townleaning you off gut
though i've never seen your scumgame so idk how much to trust that

[Clemency]

well i have but that was ages ago

[ReaperOfSouls]

day1 outside a newbie game and Clem is writing complete sentences?
things that make you go hmmm

+1

[BuJaber]

This is a weird day 1

[BuJaber]

Scum team is clemency + rb + one of {junko, gamma}

[Clemency]

nah

[Clemency]

wait which game is this

[Clemency]

nah

[TTTT]

Scum team is clemency + rb + one of {junko, gamma}

I'm townleaning rb
junko?
gamma?
what game are you reading?

[Flubbernugget]

Blahhhhh I keep forgetting about this game

[Flubbernugget]

Yeah I need to revisit eliot and lovebird

...fuck I still need to do this

[Flubbernugget]

Flubbernugget Just a question for those that have played with him before, is this how he plays? 179 one game isn't meta.

I don't think you can get a read on someone with meta alone, which includes a single game together. But there are small pieces of information that can be picked from single games

[Flubbernugget]

Yeah I'll still revisit eliott and lovebird but lovebird is town

[Flubbernugget]

triple commas there indicate you are overly concerned with how your writing is viewed
you just subconsciously scum-claimed

especially bc English isn't your native language
one down

Have you been genuinely trying to make a push on clemency based off of this?

[TTTT]

no

c,o,m,m,a t,e,l,l w,a,s a j,o,k,e
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

^you complete me

[TTTT]

but he's still probably scum

[Clemency]

fair

[Sashaddin]

@Clemency:
What do you think of Elliot and Lovebird?

i'm doing this thing where i actually answer questions directed at me
you guys like it?

Yes, but please don't forget me!

[Clemency]

I don't like the way you're conducting business here, lovebird. You're asking lots of questions that make me wonder why you asked them. Asking questions alone does not make you towny. Analysis does. What is your vote on us for, exactly? What are your actual opinions beyond just the "This is towny, this is not?" Any scum can ask questions to look town, and I think that's exactly what you're doing here.

so this kinda makes me curious considering at the time of the post lovebird asked maybe two full direct questions
this post feels reachy/forced to me

The claim is stupid if town, it's way more likely to be from scum.

How is it stupid?

This is the question that pinged us.

If you’re town here, you should be asking why it is scummy, not why it is stupid.

1. It assumes the person is town, which is concerning
2. A Townie would be more interested in why it’s more likely to come from scum and
3. Because of this, it looks more like a filler question than genuine scumhunting, and combined with the naked vote on us along with the lack of reasoning of any reads, looks like someone trying to seem like they are busy without actually digging in to any stances.

i feel like you're deriving far too many conclusions from a fairly insignificant post
this is a view i can only see from someone who's already painted someone as scum in their mind and is looking through that lens
i hate to be that guy but i really think this is tvt

[Akarin]

did you just change your avatar while I was mid-read?
damn you.

This was the first thing, probably the biggest really

triple commas there indicate you are overly concerned with how your writing is viewed
you just subconsciously scum-claimed

I initially took this as serious-but-dumb, and that seemed like something unbelievable for scum to do

plz explain your TR on me

But regardless, I TR this too.

[Akarin]

Scum team is clemency + rb + one of {junko, gamma}

Yeah, gamma is obvscum

[mcqueen]

Expect a bunch of spam as usual;

Akarin 116 Seems to be pursuing a very reachy argument on Eyes w/o a face.

Agree here. Idk why I passed this over when I read it. Akarin will be a good ISO to dive into

[mcqueen]

I feel like the only reason people think my argument is reachy is because people keep misinterpreting it and then I try to explain it more and that level of explanation of any tell would seem reachy.

If I asked the two of you to explain the only-interacting-with-one-person read over and over and kept calling it crazy and you explained it with more and more words, I think it would be equally easy to call it reachy.

There are good reasons to suspect people jumping on (what seems on page 1 like) easy lynchbait

before

there is a wagon. (Because of bad reaction to pressure.)

This isn't a reach and it's not crazy. It's also not the strongest case ever, but it was strong for that point in the game.

Basing a case off a potential 'jumping-on' of a wagon Day 1 is reachy. I understand Day 1 can be slow at times and you're looking for something to cling onto, but this is not an argument that, alone, is going to convince everyone else Eyes without a face is scum.