Merchant's Daughter [Game Restart!]

[Nancy Drew 39]

OK. Let's start over.

Yes, I'm a jerk, and I'm sorry for that.

I do think you are more likely town than scum and won't work towards lynching you - if we can find you a pair you think you'd like, great. Right now I think Krazy slot is town and would make a good pair with you, but of course there's nobody in it and feeling like you've got a partner you can work with is a big thing

Why I townread Slaxx isn't something that can easily be summed up, but I'll try: His tone, his motivations - look at the way he reacted to Krazy, and to other people talking about Krazy. And how his read on you formed.

I think I need to be paired with the most obvtown gent slot left, don’t you? And right now, that’s looking to me like Krazy slot, so hands off that slot for now. But we’ll see.

Haivng a date to prom isn't a right its a privilege

Your point?

While I’m happy Ank isn’t leaving and I understand due to the 8 gold coin thing her hands were kind of tied, but once she accepted Allo dance offer, she and Allo became the #1 obvtown couple so I think it’s in town’s best interest that I’m paired with someone I feel pretty confident about being town and rn, that’s Krazy slot. I wish it could actually be Krazy but no use crying over spilled milk.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Dunn, Celica, Alisae, I would like to know your current reads on Anka.

The thing is, within a normal game, I would have pushed for her lynch until either the lynch happened, or I'm proven incorrect.

Her response to my post, as well as the (non-fluff) ones after it, all fall within how I'd except scum!Anka to be responding.

How many games have you played with Ank? I recently played one with scum!Ank and she was very different in that game. And in Minuet, she hardpocketed me as scum. I feel pretty confident, this is town!Ank we’re seeing here.

[Nancy Drew 39]

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... B%5D=15892

Scum!Ank


https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... &start=400


Obvtown!Ank for reference

(Ank was 98% the main face of RealityCheck hydra).

[PvtUrist]

Thanks Nancy, I'll have a read through the two links.

[Alisae]

OK. Let's start over.

Yes, I'm a jerk, and I'm sorry for that.

I do think you are more likely town than scum and won't work towards lynching you - if we can find you a pair you think you'd like, great. Right now I think Krazy slot is town and would make a good pair with you, but of course there's nobody in it and feeling like you've got a partner you can work with is a big thing

Why I townread Slaxx isn't something that can easily be summed up, but I'll try: His tone, his motivations - look at the way he reacted to Krazy, and to other people talking about Krazy. And how his read on you formed.

I think I need to be paired with the most obvtown gent slot left, don’t you? And right now, that’s looking to me like Krazy slot, so hands off that slot for now. But we’ll see.

Haivng a date to prom isn't a right its a privilege

Your point?

While I’m happy Ank isn’t leaving and I understand due to the 8 gold coin thing her hands were kind of tied, but once she accepted Allo dance offer, she and Allo became the #1 obvtown couple so I think it’s in town’s best interest that I’m paired with someone I feel pretty confident about being town and rn, that’s Krazy slot. I wish it could actually be Krazy but no use crying over spilled milk.

that doesn’t mean you can demand a dance partner

[Nancy Drew 39]

OK. Let's start over.

Yes, I'm a jerk, and I'm sorry for that.

I do think you are more likely town than scum and won't work towards lynching you - if we can find you a pair you think you'd like, great. Right now I think Krazy slot is town and would make a good pair with you, but of course there's nobody in it and feeling like you've got a partner you can work with is a big thing

Why I townread Slaxx isn't something that can easily be summed up, but I'll try: His tone, his motivations - look at the way he reacted to Krazy, and to other people talking about Krazy. And how his read on you formed.

I think I need to be paired with the most obvtown gent slot left, don’t you? And right now, that’s looking to me like Krazy slot, so hands off that slot for now. But we’ll see.

Haivng a date to prom isn't a right its a privilege

Your point?

While I’m happy Ank isn’t leaving and I understand due to the 8 gold coin thing her hands were kind of tied, but once she accepted Allo dance offer, she and Allo became the #1 obvtown couple so I think it’s in town’s best interest that I’m paired with someone I feel pretty confident about being town and rn, that’s Krazy slot. I wish it could actually be Krazy but no use crying over spilled milk.

that doesn’t mean you can demand a dance partner

I’m really not sure where you’re going with this?

[Nancy Drew 39]

Thanks Nancy, I'll have a read through the two links.

I should have probably posted a link to Ank in Heroes but I can do that, if you’re not convinced. And the recent game I’m referencing is offsite but I can post that too if necessary.

[Nancy Drew 39]

P.edit. Obviously, I know I can’t “demand” any dance partner - let alone a specific slot, I’m just thinking that this mechanic - the gold coin thing - has kind of screwed town, since it pretty much forced Ank to pair up with the most obtown unpaired gent - which rendered both of them, the probable NK, so odds are extremely high, we lose two obvtowns before 2nd dance but yeah, that’s obviously up to Ktrazy replacement and who knows, maybe Urist or McQueen town it up even more than Krazy had, right before his replace out. That’s what we really need here - more obvtown gents or town will suffer.

[Allomancer]

close enough

no

[Allomancer]

Mc/Nancy would be a town pair
Allo/Ank is most likely a town pair and I'm just tunneling Ank and wrong.
Ali should go with Pvt
Leave me rein Adel out of the dance so we can't be mislynched/incase one of the other 2 is scum.

You could dance with Krazy replacement

[Allomancer]

Celica I really don't think you should be unpaired because ur probably town and I don't think you realize how few people actually scumread you

Good job

[Nancy Drew 39]

Your avatar is giving me seizures. :/

[Ankamius]

I'm not mad at all but Nancy posted the links to probably my two most embarrassing games on the site within the last year

[Nancy Drew 39]

I'm not mad at all but Nancy posted the links to probably my two most embarrassing games on the site within the last year

Sorry.

I can link to Heroes and the offsite one?

[Allomancer]

Made it to 1800, really not liking celica anymore

[Ankamius]

I just spent this entire time getting a full list and my phone decided to give me the middle finger when I was adding the last game

So I'm not going to do that again

[Slaxx]

Made it to 1800, really not liking celica anymore

Why’s that?

[mcqueen]

Pvt I think you’re scum. Not getting the same vibes here as in Newbie 1911. Sorry.

I need to review ur iso (have seen some of it) and that game to be sure, but that’s where i’m at right now with you.

—
I’m hesitant to call Ank a scumread because it’s just Omgus from him thinking I am. It’s hard for me to place somebody in this situation. So they remain null for me. That’s why I wanted him to explain in better detail why he thinks i’m scum

Newbie 1911. I would agree that I play Cop in a Newbie differently than in a large theme. Tbh for the vast majority of 1911 I was just messing around with T-Bone.

Alright. Let's say you had to give me a short (few sentence) abstract on why you're town. What would you say?

[FakeGod]

Looking for replacement for Reinhardt.

[mcqueen]

I don't think the game is as easy as rein/Adel both being scum. Maybe one or even none. What's your take on those slots? I feel they'll get lynched regardless of who they're paired with

These two have been mentioned a lot, and once I'm done reading the thread, their ISOs are a good place to start, along with Krazy's, for additional reads.

[mcqueen]

I don't think the game is as easy as rein/Adel both being scum.

What is your reasoning for saying this?

What is/was your reason for asking?

[mcqueen]

How does this make me scum if clem/pink and town?

Hard to explain. Let's call it gut for now. However, I'll sadly want you dead anyway.

Celica, your thought process could've been different in real-time, but from the posts Dunn quoted, Dunn looks pretty town. Unless anyone's sure Clem's gonna flip town, but even then, while Dunn

could've

been pushing an easy target as scum, it was also a seemingly

valid

push, therefore I wouldn't automatically lynch Dunn if Clem flips green.

[mcqueen]

Also to throw your own words back at you. It doesn't really matter if you agree or disagree on what you think is enough to get a read on you. It's my own read and it's how I came to my answer. However you're clearly not reading my posts so this conversation is a bit blah.

I think you're town at the moment, but Dunn's right. You may have your own reads, but if you want anyone else to agree with you on those reads, you're going to have to do a better job at explaining said reads.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Looking for replacement for Reinhardt.

The whole game is gonna be replacing out at this rate. :/

[mcqueen]

Celica I kind of don't really get the associatives between Dunn and Pink Ball?

I don't think it makes them SVS. I do think the way dunn played around them is interesting. Is the best way I can put it

Do you think there's 1 scum in there or...
I'm just confused atm

I'd prob delete my account with how confident I am that if we killed Pink/Clen and Slax/Dunn it doesn't net us scum.

So you are townreading Clem

and

Dunn? I'm quite confused, sorry. Who are your scumreads?