Merchant's Daughter [Endgame]

[Firebringer]

Hate Nancy's playstyle all you want she's not scum

she is scum. fite me

Is she scum or do you want to policy Lynch her because her playstyle and actions offend you: you can admit it either way

I am not reading any of her emotional reactions or playstyle as scum here tbh. I said what she was scum for and how she interacted with others was scummy if you want to write all that off as playstyle than we have different agreements on what her playstyle is and we can talk about it because i think there is a fine line and i distinguished it quite well.

i am not really offended by anything nancy done tbh. I am very annoyed by her behavior but i am not wanting to lynch her for behaving like a child.

[Taly]

Okay I think Nancy's replacement is more likely to come from scum than town. Hear me out on this.
So I come from a heavy background of face-to-face mafia. And when I play that, if I'm town and someone accuses me of being mafia, my attitude is more "I'm not mafia, so I can prove this." I don't really get frustrated, maybe a bit annoyed, but not frustrated. But when I'm scum and someone accuses me, I'm more like, "oh shit, they figured me out, I might as well give up now" and then I get frustrated with the game because it seems hopeless.
That being said, Nancy's attitude about replacement obviously falls into the latter category, which leads me to believe she's scum. A town person I don't think would get quite as frustrated; they would be more willing to prove that they're town.

1)

You're comparing forum mafia to face-to-face mafia...
Your argument here is already fragile.

2)

You stating "town would be more willing to prove they're town" is both false and ignores people's individual playstyle.

3)

Why are you continuing the

"

Nancy

is scum"

narrative and not talking about potential partners right now?

[RadiantCowbells]

TBH

I haven't even read NDS iso

I'm just assuming she's villa based on how you've described her which sounds a lot like her villa game

[Firebringer]

TBH

I haven't even read NDS iso

I'm just assuming she's villa based on how you've described her which sounds a lot like her villa game

[Taly]

FB

, do you have ANY thoughts on the game aside from

Nancy

scum?

I'd also like you to be more clear on your scumread there since you're so confident.

[RadiantCowbells]

This game feels so surreal

I've never read a game before where my town reputation preceded me and no one talked about my scum game lol

[Firebringer]

Taly i am 10 seconds away from throwing a bitch fit just because of the tone of that post makes me look like i have no other thoughts.

[Gamma Emerald]

welp Nancy is scum no 2.


we almost have solved the game

so far I am liking your solve

Because I’m not automatically juming aboard an Allo scumwagon?

I’m not convinced of it, so sue me.

That your only defense?

[Taly]

KRAZY ALLOWMANSTER and FREEBRANGER are TOWN-TOWN IN MY MIND AND HEART

Explain this, and find better material than

Nancy

[PvtUrist]

Taly coming in hot.

pedit noo why are we fighting

[Alisae]

Hello my name is

ylat

its very nice to meet everyone today

[Firebringer]

Firebringer annoyance level at Taly: 6.1

maybe we can bring it up higher.

[Allomancer]

Taly, do you have to bold player names? It's kind of jarring and makes it harder to read your posts fluently.

[Dannflor]

Wait fuck I wanted to ask Krazy to dance eventually but he's also a gent

can we be gay lovers

[Alisae]

get it
cuz Taly bolds names
and ylat bolds everything but the name

[Allomancer]

KRAZY ALLOWMANSTER and FREEBRANGER are TOWN-TOWN IN MY MIND AND HEART

Explain this, and find better material than

Nancy

Tbh, this doesn't need much explaining. I've admitted myself that i think fb is town, and krazy is a null-read to me.

[Firebringer]

that was a bad joke granddaughter

[RadiantCowbells]

Hey Firebringer

How do you think I caught you in the last dance game

Have you given it any thoughts?

holy fuck is this civ mafia 2.0

[Allomancer]

get it
cuz Taly bolds names
and ylat bolds everything but the name

oh i got it. it just wasn't funny

[Alisae]

Taly, do you have to bold player names?

yes

pedit: I agree

[Krazy]

Wait fuck I wanted to ask Krazy to dance eventually but he's also a gent

can we be gay lovers

I mean what we do outside of the game is outside the control of the mod

[Taly]

Taly i am 10 seconds away from throwing a bitch fit just because of the tone of that post makes me look like i have no other thoughts.

Sorry, that might've sounded harsher.

But I'm not seeing many posts about you that don't revolve around

Nancy

, and I'd like that dispelled.

You don't need to throw a fit.

Taly, do you have to bold player names? It's kind of jarring and makes it harder to read your posts fluently.

Bolding names helps me organize my posts, and its for my understanding.

If it's such a problem then I suggest quoting me and unbolding it.

I don't how many times people poke at how I bold things as an excuse NOT to engage with me...

[Firebringer]

Hey Firebringer

How do you think I caught you in the last dance game

Have you given it any thoughts?

holy fuck is this civ mafia 2.0

I am going to ignore you because you are being an ass imo.

[Firebringer]

Usually i have immense patience rc, but like now I don't so until you read Nancys posts we have nothing to talk about.

[Taly]

Taly coming in hot.

pedit noo why are we fighting

How about you fan the flames more and actually ask me a question?

If I - alongside a third of the playerlist is a nullread to you - it might be a good idea to do something about it.