Just advice to you as a player: if over hundreds of games he has not easily faked being town, that means it is safe to read him on meta. Law of averages or occams razor or w.e the cool term is.In post 999, Aurathebirb wrote:nd the fact that Creature's scum meta has been labeled as very obviously different from his town meta means that he can easily fake being town if he wants to. (That said, see below)
His first post has already been pointed out as scummy, don't think I need to elaborate much there.In post 172, YellowSnow wrote:Wow I haven't posted and I'm already being scumread. A lot of Pages for me To read.
In particular I don't see this response to being pushed so quickly out of the gate coming from town.In post 177, YellowSnow wrote:I can feel the love.
Seems forced, almost looks like he put out a vote just so nobody would call him out for not having one.In post 180, YellowSnow wrote:VOTE: radiantcowbellsIn post 155, RadiantCowbells wrote:shoshin wheres ur scumread so i can lynch them with you
I particularly don't like this post and I think its definitely worth an explanation.In post 293, YellowSnow wrote:If Marality and Boats are scum, and the third scum is roomy or Vedith that puts town in a pretty good spot.
Weird out of place questions really make me think scum. They sort of seem like a scum player who couldn't think of anything else to say and didn't want to come out aggressive. Look at YellowSnow's ISO and see how many of his posts are these kinds of questions. It reminds me of the first few times I played as scum and didn't know what to do.In post 310, YellowSnow wrote:Are mods more likely to replace non posting scum than town?
GrossIn post 322, YellowSnow wrote:I agree town is in a good spot right now. We just need to keep our eyes on the ball.
Slight pause on this, doesn't seem like a scum post but still overall a net negative read.In post 494, YellowSnow wrote:And...the obligitory OMGUS vote.
if this doesn't confirm me as town I don't know what does. My vote's staying on Morality the rest of the day. (unless something significant changes).
Don't like the inclusion of the middle sentence.In post 690, YellowSnow wrote:Considering switching my vote to creature but kinda making me queasy because he did this exact same thing last game and was town.I like to learn from my mistakes.He hasn't done anything to help us though.
So you’re saying ScumRC isn’t capable of pulling the wool over people’s eyes Day 1?In post 1002, Yachting n Socializing wrote:I think 690 is a pretty good post if Creature is town. Hypothetical scum!Snow had ample opportunity to take the easy mislynch and didnt. Some of it is bad yea, its a fine line between mislynch bait and scum.
You seriously have RC as scum after last night? I dont see that one at all personally.
In post 998, Yachting n Socializing wrote:@RC, Creature read now? Do you agree with me?
I just disagree with you then, nowhere to really go from there. You're right, scum don't hop on easy wagons all the time like the Creature one, I just figure new scum is more likely to. And I think you may be coming from a place of confbias as isoing often does, but like I said before, Snow does have a lot of questionable stuff and there ess a time I wanted him lynched too. You should vote Snow if you think hes scum, I disagree that it is likely to flip red but it's not a hill I'm going to die on.In post 1009, Aurathebirb wrote:Ehh, scum doesn't always eagerly jump on the mislynch. A lot of time scum are the ones who hesitate so they can get points when the mislynch bait flips town. The "learn from mistakes" thing is tone related. It just seems very in your face. Its inclusion in that context set off a buzzer for me.
Yeah, RC's posts last night didn't move him towards town. If anything, went a bit the other way.
Vedith is not trying to appear town. Morality isn't trying to appear town.
Yellow and Cowbells are. At least, from what I see.
Cowbells just seems like he's trying to guilt people into town reading him.
that's, as in creature?In post 1016, RadiantCowbells wrote:Oh I didn't even read the last page anymore because I was so frustrated about the scumreads on me. That's maybe town ok