Mini Normal 2058 (Endgame)

[Yachting n Socializing]

You don't seriously think that a cop would check a guy who claimed to be either ascetic or miller...?

RCE had no reason to ever not target Boon there, and Creature very likely targeted Boon and got a guilty result based on his vote. I think Creature just didn't read. The only other check he could have had is RC (the other person he voted) but based on his apparent hood comment that is slightly unlikely, and RC is scum so that just means we lynch RC first as his cop.

[Morality]

I can't remember the last time I saw a crumb be anything but a wifommy distraction

I think it was like... five years ago.

Good traitors don't need to crumb, the last time I was scum with a traitor, they pushed me in a way that made me realize who the traitor was within a couple days of the game starting. There's enough quality players here that I think it would be pretty simple to fake something similar if any of them are scum

To be fair, COA is known for having an incredibly weak scum game especially in comparison to her town game.

[Something_Smart]

So you lack reading comprehension. Got it.

No, I think you're expecting me to comprehend things that aren't there. There are a LOT of unstated assumptions in your case, and most of them are questionable.

[Yachting n Socializing]

ion have enough time to call SS mean words and reply to ank now and this is making me late for work so pcing

[Morality]

You don't seriously think that a cop would check a guy who claimed to be either ascetic or miller...?

RCE had no reason to ever not target Boon there, and Creature very likely targeted Boon and got a guilty result based on his vote. I think Creature just didn't read. The only other check he could have had is RC (the other person he voted) but based on his apparent hood comment that is slightly unlikely, and RC is scum so that just means we lynch RC first as his cop.

He didn’t check RC. He voted me to start the day, saying he wasn’t changing, then I brought up why him checking me was wrong, and he voted RC. Had he checked RC the me vote wouldn’t have happened.

This isn’t even up for debate. Creature investigated me.

[Morality]

Anyone who is stating that Creature didn’t investigate me Night 1 is just plain wrong.

[Something_Smart]

RCE had no reason to ever not target Boon there

You think it's literally impossible that he scumread someone else more than he scumread Boon? What?

[Morality]

VOTE: Something_Smart

[YellowSnow]

Let's lynch in the non-COA non-hood pool. If I'm wrong then we can reevaluate tomorrow. But I don't think I'll be wrong. We don't want to lynch a CoA lyncher and be down another townie.

[Morality]

RCE had no reason to ever not target Boon there

You think it's literally impossible that he scumread someone else more than he scumread Boon? What?

He didn’t. The only other person he was scum reading was Boats/Creature, and Creature was his last.

[YellowSnow]

I think Smart is just being a little obtuse right now. Doesn't mean he won't improve.

[Something_Smart]

Anyone who is stating that Creature didn’t investigate me Night 1 is just plain wrong.

I have faith that Creature doesn't make an action that can't possibly produce a useful result.

If that gets you mislynched then oh well, we both can yell at him together in postgame.

And even if he did check you, he sure as hell didn't get an inno so I don't know how that would make you cleared.

[Morality]

Anyone who is stating that Creature didn’t investigate me Night 1 is just plain wrong.

I have faith that Creature doesn't make an action that can't possibly produce a useful result.

If that gets you mislynched then oh well, we both can yell at him together in postgame.

And even if he did check you, he sure as hell didn't get an inno so I don't know how that would make you cleared.

He clearly did. He didn’t know about my claim.

[Something_Smart]

RCE had no reason to ever not target Boon there

You think it's literally impossible that he scumread someone else more than he scumread Boon? What?

He didn’t. The only other person he was scum reading was Boats/Creature, and Creature was his last.

You're a mind reader now? You know that he didn't see CoA flip traitor and change his reads? You know that he didn't get paranoid on someone and change his action?

[Yachting n Socializing]

RCE had no reason to ever not target Boon there

You think it's literally impossible that he scumread someone else more than he scumread Boon? What?

It is about MOST LIKELY, stop twisting my words. it is a hider. it is not literally impossible that a hider would talk about scumreading penguin for the whole game and then target meatloaf and die, but rce is a competent player so playing around him throwing is not the first thing on my mind for some reason ? ? ?

[Morality]

VOTE: Morality

I'm like only lynching Morality today but we can see who else is scum.

I’m an ascetic Miller.

One of those are true.

@Creature

VOTE: RadiantCowbells

So, I was pretty sure Creature targeted me Night 1, which shows I’m not Ascetic.

VOTE: RadiantCowbells

I quoted Boats vote by accident. Meant to quote Creature’s.

[Something_Smart]

Let's lynch in the non-COA non-hood pool. If I'm wrong then we can reevaluate tomorrow. But I don't think I'll be wrong. We don't want to lynch a CoA lyncher and be down another townie.

If you can't find a post from CoA that might have been a crumb, then there wasn't one and scum didn't know she was traitor, and this argument is garbage.

So get searching.

[Yachting n Socializing]

VOTE: Something_Smart

No, he's spewed town by Shoshin.

[Morality]

VOTE: Morality

Hmm, I didn't read the role carefully enough. He probably used it on one of Morality/Boats/Creature.

VOTE: Boats

Even Shoshin thought one of us were the likely target.

And RCE was literally crumbing all day he’d be dealing with me through some kind of PR.

[Morality]

VOTE: Something_Smart

No, he's spewed town by Shoshin.

Disagree.

[Morality]

Shoshin was the scummiest person in this game. Give me reasons outside of the replacement, and maybe I’ll agree.

But SS is literally trying to discredit basically confirmed actions.

[Morality]

RCE had no reason to ever not target Boon there

You think it's literally impossible that he scumread someone else more than he scumread Boon? What?

He didn’t. The only other person he was scum reading was Boats/Creature, and Creature was his last.

You're a mind reader now? You know that he didn't see CoA flip traitor and change his reads? You know that he didn't get paranoid on someone and change his action?

Nope. RC was pushing COA, Boats, Morality scum team.

[Something_Smart]

It is about MOST LIKELY, stop twisting my words. it is a hider. it is not literally impossible that a hider would talk about scumreading penguin for the whole game and then target meatloaf and die, but rce is a competent player so playing around him throwing is not the first thing on my mind for some reason ? ? ?

You said the words "no reason," that is an absolute statement, not one about likelihood. You're twisting your own words.

And it's not throwing. It's out-WIFOMing yourself. Reads change. I assume RCE didn't expect CoA to flip traitor specifically, it could very well have influenced his reads during the night. You've done nothing to explain why that's unlikely.

[Morality]

Anyone who is stating that Creature didn’t investigate me Night 1 is just plain wrong.

I have faith that Creature doesn't make an action that can't possibly produce a useful result.

If that gets you mislynched then oh well, we both can yell at him together in postgame.

And even if he did check you, he sure as hell didn't get an inno so I don't know how that would make you cleared.

I’m cleared from RCE, if I’m not cleared Boats is cleared.

[Something_Smart]

But SS is literally trying to discredit basically confirmed actions.

Just like I tried to discredit "confirmed" vig Tchill in Blessed Mafia?