In post 2548, Nimueh wrote:You keep saying that but you have yet to explain how Brigitte flip was “useful” because rn I’m not seeing it.In post 2546, Ankamius wrote:Why are you assuming that the only thing that matters is the alignment that flipped
That's silly
Well luckily the trajectory isn't the issue. It's actually a lot simpler than that.In post 2537, Ankamius wrote:I've been paying attention to skitter's trajectory on reading you and nothing she's done so far was weird relative to that. This omgusing on her is silly.
Flubber's last two posts are scummy.
This is where my playing under this account is hurting this game. :/In post 2549, Ankamius wrote:Do you have evidence that she does it as scum
Absense of doing something as town is not a good argument unless there's a damn good reason it's scumindicative
You want to know what's less impressive than 2531? Scum reading me bc "meta" and that's it.In post 2547, Nimueh wrote:2531 doesn’t impress me but I kind of agree with 2532. Are you suggesting it’s a possible pocket of me? Like I said, despite what you believe, 2514 and 1636 make 0 sense together. Short of outting myself, I can 100% vouch for town!Skitter never sr me ever for “overreacting” to votes on me, so no - absolutely NOT even remotely “silly”. I am also not an “idiot”.
Okay that explains it, I thought you were talking about the Nimueh read.In post 2555, Flubbernugget wrote:Well luckily the trajectory isn't the issue. It's actually a lot simpler than that.In post 2537, Ankamius wrote:I've been paying attention to skitter's trajectory on reading you and nothing she's done so far was weird relative to that. This omgusing on her is silly.
Flubber's last two posts are scummy.
I'm not the only one that thought that skitter's vote on me was weird. Why is only my concern scummy? How is it omgus when I called out a second vote outside of her scum reads., which exactly what struck everyone as odd the first time?
What does this have anything to do with how you play? I’m asking how her flip was useful, because all I see is we mislynched and since I believe Tris to be town and taking into account Brigitte self-hammer, I don’t understand how we are better off/have moved the gamestate forward with her flip.In post 2550, Ankamius wrote:In post 2548, Nimueh wrote:You keep saying that but you have yet to explain how Brigitte flip was “useful” because rn I’m not seeing it.In post 2546, Ankamius wrote:Why are you assuming that the only thing that matters is the alignment that flipped
That's silly
Then you don't know how I play
Do you believe this gamestate makes sense with a very active poster and two lurkers?In post 2560, xRECKONERx wrote:too many nonfactors skating by doing fuckall
by which im referencing xtoxm, creature, succinct, elbirn.
id be SHOCKED if there wasn't scum in the replacement pool.
i actually liked succinct's entrance to the game, i remember. but recent posting has left much to be desired (specifically, the indignation at not being spoonfed a game summary + the entirety of the case on flubb being 'meta')
xtoxm had a bizarre entrance and then has done very little. dislike his hop onto the brig wagon yesterday as it kinda came outta nowhere after a lot of nothing and then he's done fuckall d2
creature is pinging me bc of the whole "oh man ah geez i just cant get into this game" which when you're a replacement is kinda underwhelming and lets you hide. coupled with WHO creature replaced (tictac) and the fact tictac contributed fuckall and only had 12 posts, and that slot needs way more hard content.
elbirn i think is town bc the vote hops look kinda natural and the way he ran the fuck away from the brig wagon when, as scum, he could've replaced in and left his vote there while he "caught up" to push the wagon forward
The vote precedes two points on brigette being NAI and a setup to still get tris lynched if that were to become convenient. I think this is a perfect illustration of what I was trying to get at when I said chara's posting looks good in a vacuum. This vote really didn't bring any suspicion to chara at all, but it really should have.In post 2120, Chara wrote:VOTE: Brigitte
the more i think about it, the more i think this is a better lynch. skitter's argument for Brigitte's lack of survivalism/arguing against the townread is a sound one but i get the feeling that Brigitte considers the arguments she's made to be soundly NAI and would have made them regardless.
but her last three votes have all been PoE scumreads and pretty safe bets at the time she made them. i absolutely buy town being in that position but i think what i was townreading from Brigitte was NAI.
i don't find tris towny either and i probably will have to end up hammering that by the end of the day. (i think we have about a day left?)
but it's something for me to consider tomorrow at least. of the two i like this more. tris has this gut feeling recently of being strangely awkward which could be newbscum or could just be a newish sort of feeling. Brigitte i think is more aware of her own play.
pedit: already chose.
I’m a bit confused here as I don’t see Ank and myself as a 1v1 and also, Skitter didn’t sheep Ank onto me. Ank never voted me. I think Ank is town and reading me incorrectly. Sure there’s a very small part of me that thinks there’s a slight possibility of her being S v S with Skitter but unlikely. I would love it if Ank were scum misreading me here, rather than believe she could ever be this off on me, I just really don’t think so.In post 2551, xRECKONERx wrote:I'm lurking and I don't like it but I've hit an entire fucking brick wall with this game and idk why
reading thru the past few pages to try and spark joy.
i feel like creature replacing in and then basically being a nonstarter didnt help. and it's actually suspicious bc it's exactly what scum should do in his situation.
Nim asked how NMSA's 2364 is a town post. I don't particularly see how it's a scum post and again this is not how burden of proof works. The default position for someone to be in mafia is town, you have to prove why they're not. So come back with your own reasons for why that post is scum (If you already posted it, please point me to it).
nim v ank makes me think it's TvS but i honestly, gun to my head, couldn't tell you which was which. ive been really worried ab ank since yesterday with the fake hammer nonsense but im trying not to let my paranoia get the best of me since i townread her before then. ALSO HEY GUYS YOU TWO SPAMMING BACK & FORTH FOR PAGES ON END ISN'T HELPING GAMESTATE.
xtoxm's engagement w/ the game is weird af.
skitter's posts are a bit...unenthused. showing up then just blindly sheeping ank onto nim is a choice. def dropping from the top of my townie list, but still firmly on the town side of the line.
anyway let's do a new readslist without looking at my old one so these are fresh & then ill try to figure out why any changes happened later.
TOWN
{Nim or Ank}
Chara
tris
skitter
NULL/IDFK/LURK
Elbirn
Succinct
xtoxm
NMSA
SCUM
Flubber
Creature
{Nim or Ank}