Open 753: Nomination Mafia [Game Over!]

[Irrelephant11]

That’s good

[DoubtingThomas]

jk i was trying to make a funny joke. i am not that cocky

[Irrelephant11]

That’s good

[Vedith]

AtE when he was getting a lot of town reads and really upped his game from d1? i dont get it

He voted himself to L1. He's not going to AtE when at L1...

He voted himself to L-2 I thought

Regardless it's AtE

[DoubtingThomas]

AtE when he was getting a lot of town reads and really upped his game from d1? i dont get it

He voted himself to L1. He's not going to AtE when at L1...

He voted himself to L-2 I thought

Regardless it's AtE

i dunno why he started getting votes all of a sudden. i am not sure if he would randomly AtE out of nowhere despite putting in so much townie work (if he's scum).

he also didn't say anything, which is not consistent with his attitude/behavior this day phase

[Vedith]

Self voting is AtE though.
It started because Volxen tried to shade me. So I voted \o/

[DoubtingThomas]

I won't lie, I didn't read it.
Self meta has no rellevence to me reading someone. Plus it was big words.

I dislike self meta too. But with context, the post itself is good. The logic and tone in the post all makes sense to the point that I forgot she's talking abotu her self meta at times, if that makes sense

[DoubtingThomas]

Self voting is AtE though.
It started because Volxen tried to shade me. So I voted \o/

Self voters are scumbags

[Irrelephant11]

I think vedith might be town?
I would find it scummy if he were working hard to convince everyone that one of the three nominees has to be scum (because I disagree)
I also find it sorta ~weird~ that most of the playerlist has stopped acting like any of the three of us might be scum, which imo means we’re either all town (and scum don’t have motivation to try to scumpaint any of us) or scum!shoshin is confident she’s not getting lynched - I think it’s probably the former, though the latter is theoretically possible.

Given I think we’re all town, though, I like that vedith is just sorta trying to sort us three for potential scum, and that that’s why his vote is where it is. I could see how from another point of view it’s odd he’s not voting me given how we’ve collectively talked about my scumgame, but fmpov it’s towny of him to keep sorting and voting who he thinks has scum equity

[Irrelephant11]

Wait I’m running out of scumreads

[Irrelephant11]

Fus/Chennis/??

[DoubtingThomas]

I think vedith might be town?
I would find it scummy if he were working hard to convince everyone that one of the three nominees has to be scum (because I disagree)
I also find it sorta ~weird~ that most of the playerlist has stopped acting like any of the three of us might be scum, which imo means we’re either all town (and scum don’t have motivation to try to scumpaint any of us) or scum!shoshin is confident she’s not getting lynched - I think it’s probably the former, though the latter is theoretically possible.

Given I think we’re all town, though, I like that vedith is just sorta trying to sort us three for potential scum, and that that’s why his vote is where it is. I could see how from another point of view it’s odd he’s not voting me given how we’ve collectively talked about my scumgame, but fmpov it’s towny of him to keep sorting and voting who he thinks has scum equity

why only scum!shoshin?

[Irrelephant11]

Eh maybe I’m too quick to townread Vedith here he’s not showing a ton of effort either and he happens to be voting the player who’s most focused on him

Pedit: because I know I’m town and it seems like things slowed down when volxen became the lead wagon

[DoubtingThomas]

if all 3 of you are town, who's the best to keep around, iyo, irrelephant

[DoubtingThomas]

boy does vedith give me challenge every game. a joy to play with, not the best to win with

[Irrelephant11]

If we’re all town
Keep Shoshin
Pick whichever of me/Volxen you want. I’m honestly not sure which of us is a better townie tbh
Some players will have more paranoia about me so I’d understand me being the lynch
OTOH some players are having an easier time townreading me and I’m not here to tell them they’re *wrong* to do so

[DoubtingThomas]

shoshin has good reads? that's why you are valuing her?

[Irrelephant11]

I think she also has unique ways of sorting that catch most scum off guard, which when explained allow all players an easier time sorting. She’s also pretty difficult to mislynch which can be a town strength

But yes the primary reason is her reads, which has been borne out across many games

[DoubtingThomas]

As scummy as this may sound, I want to be frank with you, I am not sure if I can work with shoshin. I think she has good scum equity (despite that pretty good post that's starting to make see the possibility of the world where she is town), and her playstyle, imo is just pure antitown, and as shoshin proudly states, I have "personal grudge" on her and feel like she's trying to provoke me further instead of trying to work with me. Unless she starts changing her play style around, there will always be this lingering fear/distaste inside me that would make me scum read her.

Not only that, she herself scum reads me (or at least is trying to actively lynch me). I am, too, a very hard person to mislynch. I am low key worried that shoshin and i are going to just continue to scum read each other and try to lynch each other. That will create further chaos into this already toxic environment. Unless you are thinking you and/or volxen are purely incompetent "town" players, I really think lynching shoshin is all around the better play today.

[Shoshin]

I can see scum aren't too happy about losing out the chance to mislynch me.

[Shoshin]

I'm gonna take a look at Volx games to get a better sense of his town/scum meta.

[Shoshin]

DT pushing my lynch because says he can't work with me is pretty scummy.

[DoubtingThomas]

DT pushing my lynch because says he can't work with me is pretty scummy.

As scummy as this may sound,

Ever think about getting original?

[DoubtingThomas]

I can see scum aren't too happy about losing out the chance to mislynch me.

This post is pinging. It is ignoring a lot of things someone with a townie mindset should be considering. Didn't shoshin agree that the general towniness ranked from thread consensus is Irrel>Shoshin>volxen? I thought she agreed that nominations happened like this to try to make volxen a mislynch target? Right now, volxen is like the only wagon that's formed. Shoshin hasn't really been under much scrutiny. How is the way d2 played out close to her being lynched to begin with? Why would she all of a sudden now think that scums set the whole day up trying to get shoshin lynched?

[Shoshin]

What're your actual reads, DT?