Fire on the Mountain [Over]

[Prince of Renais]

i think that hypothetically if we could lynch everyone below xtoxm we win the game 85-90% of the time
we have to leave two people out. i think that optimally we leave ddl and gamma out of the lynchpool but i won't fault you guys if you think they earn the lynch more than other people in the lynchpool
don't lynch karmeleon or xtoxm unless they really, really underplay from here and don't lynch my townblock ever.

[Extrapolated Eagle]

i feel like if there's a deepwolf in this game it's EE and I'd put them second or third highest scum equity of all the players in the game + i feel like they're not going to get lynched if i don't lynch them now

Lol what a great reason to vote someone.

don't think 3/5 of his scumreads overlapping with mine merits the 'we dont agree on almost any scumreads' thing either

2/6?

How do you get 3/5?

FTR, Elyse was deepwolf in a game grapes and I were in three years ago. I was calling grapes scum.

[Prince of Renais]

3/5 of YOUR scumreads are in my lynch before endgame for sure category and another is in flex so the only scumread we actually disagree on is alisae
shoshin is in a separate category because if she's town she will kill scum before she needs to be lynched.

[Dannflor]

Hm if EE is scum, his buddy is one of his scum reads - most likely someone he's hard pushing imo

I wanna go back and see if Shoshin and EE makes sense as a team

[Extrapolated Eagle]

Yeah I agree on two out of your six scumreads.

The story behind Elyse is that I caught her, called her scum, and pushed her, but she was buddying some of other more prominent members of town, who decided that I was probably scum for scumreading her. (I mean I haven't read the game in a while, but it was a really emotional game for me, I still have dreams about it and stuff so it's possible I'm getting some of the facts wrong, but close enough). Anyways, I called Elyse scum and was pushing her. TSO and Titus didn't believe me, TSO went head to head with me for a long period of day 4. Being as involved as I was (I had the second highest postcount including some of the walliest posts in the game and I was posting on my phone exclusively), I didn't respond in a particularly emotionally stable manner. I fell prey to my inferior emotions and tried to gladiate TSO. We yelled at each other for a bit, I tried to replace out and thought better of it (I know, I'm sorry, I'm a terrible person), and then I thought about everything and pushed Elyse again. Elyse won the game in Lylo because she had TSO so deep pocketed and because I lost my head and couldn't keep it on straight. Anyways I asked him if he remembered Elyse because I'm always thinking about You Could Be Anyone IV. If my memory serves me right, that was some of the best town game I've ever had (I had solid reads that game, IIRC) and I'm relatively proud of everything up until the day when I pushed my own lynch, frustrated, and hoping people would sheep my reads after I was dead. Some day I'll play a game of mafia that surpasses YCBA IV and I'll feel redeemed for my actions.

[Dannflor]

How much time does Shoshin get to do something? I'm worried a lynch on her wouldn't actually go through later in the game

[Dannflor]

The story behind Elyse is that I caught her, called her scum, and pushed her, but she was buddying some of other more prominent members of town, who decided that I was probably scum for scumreading her. (I mean I haven't read the game in a while, but it was a really emotional game for me, I still have dreams about it and stuff so it's possible I'm getting some of the facts wrong, but close enough). Anyways, I called Elyse scum and was pushing her. TSO and Titus didn't believe me, TSO went head to head with me for a long period of day 4. Being as involved as I was (I had the second highest postcount including some of the walliest posts in the game and I was posting on my phone exclusively), I didn't respond in a particularly emotionally stable manner. I fell prey to my inferior emotions and tried to gladiate TSO. We yelled at each other for a bit, I tried to replace out and thought better of it (I know, I'm sorry, I'm a terrible person), and then I thought about everything and pushed Elyse again. Elyse won the game in Lylo because she had TSO so deep pocketed and because I lost my head and couldn't keep it on straight. Anyways I asked him if he remembered Elyse because I'm always thinking about You Could Be Anyone IV. If my memory serves me right, that was some of the best town game I've ever had (I had solid reads that game, IIRC) and I'm relatively proud of everything up until the day when I pushed my own lynch, frustrated, and hoping people would sheep my reads after I was dead. Some day I'll play a game of mafia that surpasses YCBA IV and I'll feel redeemed for my actions.

So I kinda forgot the game was happening, but I've played this setup a couple times in sitechat before...

[Extrapolated Eagle]

grapes do you remember Elyse?

and also thanks so much for reminding me about you could be anyone...

I figured if I still had dreams about that game then you should too!

Still regret getting myself lynched day 4. I think we could have won if I'd just conceded for a bit just enough so people would lynch Elyse with me.

This isn't scum theatre

it's me playing my first game on extrapolated eagle in three years and seeing someone from a game of mafia that had a huge impact on my life and the way i play mafia

[Extrapolated Eagle]

locktown:
Prince of Renais
NerfedBuJ
Alisae
Reiuji Utsuho
mcqueen

strongtown:
Karmeleon
Xtoxm

leantown:
DrDolittle
Gamma Emerald

shoshin:
Shoshin

leftovers:
Clemency
Jingle
Lycanfire
Dannflor
Extrapolated Eagle
Vedith

I wasn't counting Shoshin before. Let's fix that.
Including me and shoshin, seven names:

1. Shoshin
2. Clemency
3. Jingle
4. Lycanfire
5. Dannflor
6. Extrapolated Eagle
7. Vedith

I scumread three of them.

That is 3/7

Let's pretend I don't count (which I do)

That is still 3/6

Where are you getting 3/5? Who are you excluding?

[Alisae]

its okay I'll still have Reiuji when day 3 hits

[Shoshin]

I don't want EE lynched today.

[Extrapolated Eagle]

Looking back I think my reads were ok.

They weren't incredible.

I'm still proud of having deepwolf by the balls.

And ashamed I failed to push a lynch through.

[Shoshin]

Why are you townreading Lycan, EE?

[Extrapolated Eagle]

I don't think the quickhammer was particularly scummy.

I liked his posts earlier in the day.

[Prince of Renais]

shoshin if we gave you complete control over the next two lynches who would they be?

[Shoshin]

I don't think the quickhammer was particularly scummy.

I liked his posts earlier in the day.

I want more detail than this.

[Shoshin]

shoshin if we gave you complete control over the next two lynches who would they be?

I'll get back to you on this.

[Extrapolated Eagle]

I'll give you more detail, I'm constrained on time at the moment.

[Prince of Renais]

Swap jingle with DDL

[Prince of Renais]

If Shoshin is scum always lynch jingle and v/v though

[Prince of Renais]

If Vedith is scum EE isn't scum

Considering changing lynch order

[Vedith]

Busy
Catch up tomorrow

[NerfedBuJ]

I'm voting alisae because I believe her emotions / not getting into the game thing is genuine.

If it is genuine there are only two reasons for such extreme dispassion.
Either a real life thing or having lurkscum partners. Grapes being one of the scum would support the latter.

If real life why wouldn't she rep-out.

Also her reads don't align with mine at all. Should have lead with that.

[Karmeleon]

Lycanfire
Shoshin is town
Gamma Emerald
Alisae
Reiuji Utsuho is town
Dannflor is town
NerfedBuJ
Clemency
Jingle is town
Extrapolated Eagle is town
DrDolittle
Vedith
Prince of Renais is town
mcqueen
Xtoxm
Karmeleon is town

[Karmeleon]

Should we talk about Vedith?